On 2/8/2020 1:24 PM, Kerim Aydin via agora-official wrote: > The below CFJ is 3797. I assign it to G.. > > status: https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/#3797 > > =============================== CFJ 3797 =============================== > > Coming into existence is a regulated action. > > ==========================================================================
Judgement First to clarify, an action has a subject and an object. Phrased in the passive voice focuses on the object coming into existence (without mentioning the subject) but this statement is identical to asking if creating an object is a regulated action. Simply put: * If the object coming into existence is an "Agoran object" (i.e. something defined by the rules as per R1586) then the answer is TRUE. * If the object is wholly non-Agoran (e.g. a widget from a widget factory) the answer is FALSE. * If the object is an external object that has Agoran properties attached to it (e.g. a natural person who has a default Citizenship switch upon birth) then the "coming into existence" isn't regulated per se, but some of the follow-on consequences of existence are (e.g. assigning a switch value). I judge DISMISS (insufficient information exists as it depends on the object in question).
