On Thu, Jun 8, 2023 at 3:08 PM Forest Sweeney via agora-official <
agora-offic...@agoranomic.org> wrote:
> I temporarily Deputise as Ricemastor to publish the following report:
>
> I am planning to temporarily Deputise as Ricemastor to publish the
> following report:
>
> (Please help because I'm sure there's numerous errors in this report)
>
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
> RICE GAME REPORT
> Ricemastor's Report
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
> Date of this report: 8 June 2023
> Date of last report: 22 May 2023
> (all times UTC)
>
> RICE PLANS
> ==========
> Section 1: Harvest of Week 5-28
> ----
> Created: 2023-05-28 by snail
> Up: {active players at time of creation}
> Down: {}
> Signatures: beokirby, snail, Janet, 4st
> ----
> Created: 2023-05-27 by G.
> Up: {G., Janet}
> Down: {4st}
> Signatures: G., Janet, 4st
> ----
> Created: 2023-05-26 by Janet
> Up: {}
> Down: {}
> Signatures: Janet, ais523, 4st
> ----
> Created: 2023-05-22 by juan
> Up: {Aspen, G., Janet, Murphy, ais523, cuddlybanana, juan}
> Down: {4st, beokirby, blob, iWright, nix, snail, Yachay}
> Signatures: ais523, juan, (G, if G hasn't withdrawn eir signature), Janet,
> (4st, if this plan will not be harvested)
> ----
> Created: 2023-05-22 by Yachay
> Up: {4st, beokirby, blob, inalienableWright, nix, snail, Yachay}
> Down: {Aspen, ais523, cuddlybanana, G., Janet, juan, Murphy}
> Signatures: Yachay, beokirby, snail, (4st, if this plan will not be
> harvested)
>
> For section 1: Yachay's plan was harvested.
>
> Section 2: Harvested Week of 6-04
> ----
> Created: 2023-06-04 by Janet
> Up: {Janet}
> Down: {}
> Signatures: Janet
> ----
> Created: 2023-06-04 by G.
> Up: {G.}
> Down: {}
> Signatures: G.
> ----
> Created: 2023-06-04 by 4st
> Up: {G.}
> Down: {All active players with 1 or more rice at the time of creation,
> except 4st}
> Signatures: G., 4st
>
> For section 2, 4st's plan was harvested.
>
> Section 3: Current Rice Plans
> ----
> Created: 2023-06-05 by Beokirby
> Up: {Beokirby, Aspen, G., Janet, Murphy, ais523, cuddlybanana, juan}
> Down: {}
> Signatures: beokirby, juan
>
> RICE HOLDINGS
> ======================================================================
> Player Rice
> ------------ -------
> 4st 2 (+1)
> beokirby 1
> blob 1
> iWright* 1
> nix 1
> snail 1
> Yachay 1
> G. 1 (+1)
>
> *inalienableWright
> (All others have 0 Rice)
>
>
> CoE: CFJ 4034 affects this report. If consent was not withdrawn, juan's
> rice plan is more likely to have been harvested in section 2. In CFJ 4032,
> if consent cannot be given, then the first rice plan each week has won, and
> we'll have to recalculate. Finally, 4st's consent is annoying.
>
> I respond to this CoE by citing several CFJs: 4034, 4032, and a new CFJ:
> I call another CFJ, barring Janet: Yachay's 5-22 rice plan was harvested.
>
> Arguments FOR: G withdrew their consent (CFJ 4034), and 4st's consent
> didn't work or worked on both, so Yachay's plan was earliest and was tied
> for most signatures, and was thus harvested.
>
> Arguments PARADOX:
> G did not withdraw their consent (CFJ 4034), so 4st's consent results in a
> paradox as eir consent only exists if a plan would not be harvested.
> Yachay's plan would not have enough signatures if it were to be harvested,
> and it would have enough signatures if it wasn't going to be harvested.
>
> G withdrew their consent (CFJ 4034), so 4st's consent results in a paradox
> as eir consent only exists if a plan would not be harvested, thus Yachay's
> plan would now have enough signatures, and juan's plan would be tied for
> first.
>
> Arguments AGAINST: G did not withdraw eir consent, and 4st's consent either
> didn't work or worked on both, so juan's plan was harvested.
>
> @Tailor/@Herald: IF I WON THE RICE GAME, I grant myself the Patent Title
> Champion, and award myself an Ultraviolet Ribbon.
> @Prime Minister: Just a heads up that I may have won the rice game, but
> it's pretty unclear.
>
>
> FINALLY: please help check this report, I posted a draft before for a
> reason, so hopefully that improves the confidence here.
>
> --
> 4st
> Referee & Deputy (AKA FAKE) Herald
> Uncertified Bad Idea Generator
>
"Oh crud, forgot to tag the arbitor. Sorry G!"
--
4st
Referee & Deputy (AKA FAKE) Herald
Uncertified Bad Idea Generator
