Kiako via agora-business [2023-12-04 16:37]: > > […] > > I additionally supply the following comments, to encourage others to vote > AGAINST 9041 through 9045 if they have not done so already. > > On 9041: > This rule is very clearly integral to the structure of Agora; the verb > "initiate" (and its forms) appears in 20 rules other than 107 itself; > removing the definition and restriction on initiation without reflecting > these changes elsewhere is irresponsible. > > On 9042: > I quite enjoy the concept of tournaments, and see no reason to repeal > this. (Also, removing this orphans 2 other rules.) > > On 9043: > This once again orphans 2 rules. > > On 9044: > This is a safety precaution, and it should not be removed without heavy > consideration. (From the other proposals I am comfortable assuming the > consideration was not given.) > > On 9045: > Quorum is, from what I can tell, a very important safety measure: > inability to vote should not enable a dictatorship, lest we enable the list > host with disproportionate power. > Also, this orphans no fewer than 7 rules through transitivity. (Quorum is > required to define the outcome "FAILED QUORUM", which is mentioned in at > least 2 more rules.)
I change my vote on all of these to AGAINST -- juan
