On 5/19/24 14:10, Janet Cobb via agora-business wrote:
> On 5/19/24 14:07, Jaff via agora-official wrote:
>> RESOLUTION OF PROPOSALS 9111-9113
>> =================================
>>
>> ID Title Result
>> -----------------------------------
>> 9111 Resolve The Paradox ADOPTED
>> 9112 What's a crime? ADOPTED
>> 9113 No apathetic apathy REJECTED
>>
>> I hereby resolve the Agoran decisions to adopt the below proposals.
>>
>> The quorum for all below decisions was 6.
>>
>> VOTING STRENGTHS
>> ================
>>
>> Strength is 3 unless otherwise noted.
>> #: player has voting strength 3
>> $: player has voting strength 4
>> %: player has voting strength 5
>> ^: player has voting strength 6
>>
>> PROPOSALS
>> =========
>>
>> PROPOSAL 9111 (Resolve The Paradox)
>> AUTHOR: ais523
>> CLASS: ORDINARY
>> FOR (7): Jaff, Janet^, Yachay Wayllukuq, ais523%, juan$, snail^, wunst
>> AGAINST (0):
>> PRESENT (0):
>> BALLOTS: 7
>> AI (F/A): 30/0 (AI=2.2)
>> POPULARITY: 1.000
>> OUTCOME: ADOPTED
>>
>> PROPOSAL 9112 (What's a crime?)
>> AUTHOR: Murphy
>> CLASS: ORDINARY
>> FOR (7): Jaff, Janet^, Yachay Wayllukuq, ais523%, juan$, snail^, wunst
>> AGAINST (0):
>> PRESENT (0):
>> BALLOTS: 7
>> AI (F/A): 30/0 (AI=1.7)
>> POPULARITY: 1.000
>> OUTCOME: ADOPTED
>>
>> PROPOSAL 9113 (No apathetic apathy)
>> AUTHOR: Murphy
>> CLASS: ORDINARY
>> FOR (0):
>> AGAINST (7): Jaff, Janet^, Yachay Wayllukuq, ais523%, juan$, snail^, wunst
>> PRESENT (0):
>> BALLOTS: 7
>> AI (F/A): 0/30 (AI=1.0)
>> POPULARITY: -1.000
>> OUTCOME: REJECTED
>>
>> The full text of each ADOPTED proposal is included below:
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 9111
>> Title: Resolve The Paradox
>> Adoption index: 2.2
>> Author: ais523
>> Co-authors:
>>
>>
>> [The following change amends the promise rules to prevent the same
>> paradox re-occurring, via making "cashing a promise from the Library"
>> into a single action rather than two actions linked by a future
>> conditional.]
>>
>> In rule 2618, amend
>> {{{
>> A promise's bearer CAN, by announcement, cash the promise,
>> provided that any conditions for cashing it specified by its text
>> are unambiguously met.
>> }}}
>> to
>> {{{
>> A player (the casher) CAN, by announcement, cash a promise,
>> provided that both a) any conditions for cashing it specified by
>> its text are unambiguously met, and b) either the casher is the
>> promise's bearer, or the promise is owned by the Library.
>> }}}
>> and, as part of the same amendment, amend
>> {{{
>> In a promise's text, "the bearer" (or the like) refers to the
>> promise's bearer, and "this promise" (or the like) refers to the
>> promise.
>> }}}
>> to
>> {{{
>> In a promise's text, "the bearer" and "the casher" (or the like)
>> both refer to the player who cashed the promise, and "this
>> promise" (or the like) refers to the promise.
>> }}}
>> and delete
>> {{{
>> Any player CAN take
>> a specified promise from the Library by announcement, provided e
>> cashes the promise in the same message.
>> }}}.
>>
>> [The following change resolves any gamestate uncertainty caused by the
>> paradox by destroying all relevant promises, and should not affect any
>> promises other than those that were used to cause, or were created by,
>> the paradox.]
>>
>> Destroy all promises that were created on 7 April 2024 and whose
>> creator is ais523.
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 9112
>> Title: What's a crime?
>> Adoption index: 1.7
>> Author: Murphy
>> Co-authors:
>>
>>
>> Amend Rule 2478 (Justice) by replacing each instance of "crime" with
>> "infraction".
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>
> CoE on each above-quoted purported resolution: The resolution fails
> because the voting period has not yet ended.
>
To discharge the duty:
Admitted. I respond to each above-quoted CoE as follows: No Agoran
decision was resolved.
--
Janet Cobb
Assessor, Rulekeepor, Stonemason
