It is not clear to me if eligibility in terms of Appeals judges includes turning:
As soon as possible after an Appellate Judge is recused, the Clerk of the Courts shall randomly select an eligible Player to replace em.
clause (iv) of R911:
iv) E is ineligible to Judge the CFJ at the time of selection.
seems to include turning. But it is my belief and memory that the Speaker or CotC was never left of the Board of Appeals solely due to being turned. Thoughts? -Goethe