On Sat, 2009-02-28 at 14:21 -0800, Ed Murphy wrote: > Sgeo wrote: > > > Why would BobTHJ lose eir MwPship? pikhq should have lost it after > > ais523+AFO won. BobTHJ then loses MwPship when comex wins. ais523 > > gains Speakership. > > Actually, I think your awards were correct, while the revocations > platonically occurred due to Rule 1922 (causing Rule 649 to require > you to announce what already happened). > Based on past CFJs, an award by the Herald fails if it's based on an event that didn't happen. The revocations are platonic, so a misreport by the Herald does nothing there but confuse people.
-- H. ais523
