On Tue, Mar 10, 2009 at 7:50 PM, Sean Hunt <ride...@gmail.com> wrote:
> I submit the following proposal, named Report Accessibility, AI 1:
>
> ========================================================================
>
> Create a new rule of Power 1, named Reports, with the following text:
> {{{
> When a player is required to publish a report, e SHALL do so using
> one of the following methods:
>
> (1) By placing the text of the report in a public message.
>
> (2) By posting, in a public message, a URL or URLs to the
> publicly accessible text of the report.
AGAINST, see Murphy's message.
> I submit the following proposal, entitled Clarifying Actions, with AI 3:
> Create the following rule, entitled Do It On Time
You didn't specify a power explicitly, so this will create a power=1
rule, which I don't think is what you intended.
> {{{
> When a rule requires a player to complete an action, a player
> SHALL complete the action with regards to the circumstances at the
> time the action was first required. This is considered part of the
> obligation to perform the action, and not a separate obligation.
> If a player believes the action was incorrect due to changing
> circumstances, e SHALL take the required action, while stating
> that with N Agoran Consent, where N is an integral multiple of 0.1
> from 2.0 to 9.9, e intends to retract the required action e
> performed and instead perform another one. Such a change is not
> retroactive, and as such it may only be possible to partially
> retract the earlier action. If this is the case, the inability to
> complete part of the retraction does not hamper the remainder of
> the action.
> }}}
Messy. E can pick any type of Agoran Consent to retract the action?
Why would e ever not choose 2.0? What makes an action 'incorrect'?
Retracting actions is generally a Bad Idea anyway,
> This is hopefully a nice solution to the timing issues regarding with
> official obligations, and 2 Agoran Consent is not an easy requirement,
> but it does prevent odd situations and possibly scams from arising.
and I suspect it will create more odd situations than it prevents by
interacting weirdly with rules.
