I don't think i feel as strongly as CB but I do feel similarly. Both issues would be fixed with a) decentralizing (my prefered format is similar to a CFJ: separate the finger pointer, referee, and judge) cards and b) allowing forgiveness without apology (perhaps as Agoran Consent). To make up for the delay a would cause, we could make cards revoke wins that happened after the cardable event but before the conclusion.
On Sep 24, 2017 5:26 PM, "Cuddle Beam" <cuddleb...@gmail.com> wrote: > Would make tactical card-flinging (tactically exaggerating other people's > wrong-doings for example) a thing and I feel very queasy about giving our > subjective things that kind of power. > > >Until e publishes such an apology, as a penalty, the bad sport is > disqualified from winning, > > I'm also very against near-compulsory apologizing, this is like holy shit > wtf tier stuff for me. > > > > On Mon, Sep 25, 2017 at 12:09 AM, Kerim Aydin <ke...@u.washington.edu> > wrote: > >> >> >> Proto: "losing conditions" >> >> [Right now, it's probably worth it to break the rules to win, because wins >> are far more tangible and lasting than cards. Let's change the >> equation...] >> >> >> Amend Rule 2449 (Winning the Game) by replacing: >> When the Rules state that a person or persons win the game, >> those persons win the game; >> with: >> When the Rules state that a person or persons win the game, >> and those persons are not Disqualified from winning as >> described by the Rules, those persons win the game; >> >> >> Amend the Rule titled "Such is Karma" by appending: >> Etas are disqualified from winning. >> >> >> Amend Rule 2427 (Yellow Cards) by replacing: >> Until e publishes such an apology, as a penalty, the bad sport's >> voting strength >> with: >> Until e publishes such an apology, as a penalty, the bad sport >> is disqualified from winning, and the bad sport's voting strength >> >> >> Amend Rule 2475 (Red Cards) by replacing: >> of the Card is reduced by 2. >> with: >> of the Card is reduced by 2, and e is disqualified from winning >> for 30 days. >> >> >> Amend Rule 2476 (Pink Slips) by appending the following sentence to >> the last paragraph: >> The bad sport is disqualified from winning for 30 days from the >> issuance of the card. >> >> [Was trying to decide what the right length of time was for Red and >> Pink, something between 14-30 I think]. >> >> [Any other losing conditions?] >> >> >> >> >> >
