[sorry for double post, Gmail doesn't have a good way to reply to multiple emails at once. I'm probably going to switch to a desktop client soon.]
On Tue, Oct 17, 2017 at 8:37 PM, Alexis Hunt <aler...@gmail.com> wrote: > Looking it over again, I see three potential other issues: > - A player does not stop becoming eligible at the end of the month. I > would say "eligible for a Medal of Honour that month", to avoid this. > Yep, that's a very good point. I'll add that. > - If a player incorrectly announces eligibility, this could invalidate the > entire vote later. Not sure what the best fix is. > Yeah, I'm not sure about that either. > - Minor typo: E's -> Eir > I'm a derp. > > On Tue, 17 Oct 2017 at 20:31 Kerim Aydin <ke...@u.washington.edu> wrote: > >> >> >> Oh, last thing: you should throw in this Proposal a repeal of the >> Victory Elections >> (Rule 2482). This is a much better replacement and we don't need both. >> >> On Tue, 17 Oct 2017, Kerim Aydin wrote: >> > Just a note: It looks like the Herald isn't required to track who has >> a Medal of >> > Honour once it's awarded. So it's like trust tokens that people just >> have to >> > keep track - is that intentional? (As Herald I'd probably put this in >> my monthly >> > report anyway). >> > >> > Also there's a timing problem. "In the second week of an Agoran >> month..." doesn't >> > play well with "SHALL in a timely fashion" - does that mean in a timely >> fashion after >> > the beginning of the second week? After the end? If you want it done >> in the second >> > week, you'd delete the "in a timely fashion" and then the Herald SHALL >> do it in the >> > second week and it works. The way it reads, it almost sounds >> > like the Herald CAN in the second week only, but SHALL in a timely >> fashion after >> > the second week (so net effect is it can't be done). >> > >> > There's a bit of confusion to me about what "the first week of an Agoran >> > month" is - whether it's the 7 days after the start of the month - or >> somehow the >> > first Agoran week that starts in the month. (this one's minor I'd >> guess the 7 >> > days). >> > >> > Minor grammar point: Instead of "E's" it should be "Eir". >> > >> > (and - apologies for not looking closely until you asked about the >> karma! I >> > really like the idea.) >> > >> > >> > On Tue, 17 Oct 2017, ATMunn . wrote: >> > > I submit the following proposal and pend it with 1 shiny. >> > > >> > > Title: "A Reward for Obedience v3" >> > > Author: ATMunn >> > > Co-Author(s): Aris, Alexis >> > > AI: 1 >> > > >> > > Create a new power-1 rule titled "Medals of Honour" >> > > { >> > > Medals of Honour are a destructible fixed currency tracked by the >> Herald. >> > > >> > > In the first week of an Agoran Month, any player CAN declare >> emself to be eligible for a Medal of Honour by announcement if all of the >> following are true: >> > > * E has made at least 1 message to a public forum in the last >> Agoran month. >> > > * E's Karma is not below -3. >> > > * In the last Agoran month, e has not had a Card issued to em. >> > > >> > > In the second week of an Agoran Month, if there are any players >> who are eligible for a Medal of Honour, the Herald CAN, by announcement, >> and SHALL in a timely fashion, initiate an Agoran Decision on who is to be >> awarded a Medal of Honour. >> > > For this decision, the valid votes are all players who are >> eligible for a Medal of Honour, the vote collector is the Herald, and the >> voting method is instant-runoff. >> > > Upon the resolution of this decision, the Herald CAN, and SHALL >> in a timely fashion, award the outcome of the decision a Medal of Honour by >> announcement. >> > > >> > > If, at any time, any player has 6 or more Medals of Honour, and e >> has not won via this rule previously, e can win the game by announcement, >> destroying all of eir Medals of Honour. >> > > } >> > > >> > > [Changes from the prototype: I made it so that you can still get a >> medal even if your karma is negative, as long as it's not below -3. I also >> reworded the last part of the Agoran Decision section.] >> > > >> > > >> > >> >