it matters because of the quorum for next week. can't have conditional quorum.
On Sun, Apr 29, 2018 at 5:21 AM, Kerim Aydin <ke...@u.washington.edu> wrote:
>
>
> Actually nvm I don't care all that much - I withdraw this CFJ.
>
> Interestingly, this leave the CoE kinda in limbo. I've done everything
> required of me by initiating an inquiry case, but there's no closure
> (not that it matters as a practical matter because I published a
> conditional revision).
>
> On Sat, 28 Apr 2018, Kerim Aydin wrote:
>> CFJ, barring VJ Rada: PSS voted on the decision to adopt Proposal 8033.
>>
>> Arguments:
>>
>> R2466 says:
>> the agent CAN perform the action in the same
>> manner in which the principal CAN do so, with the additional
>> requirement that the agent must, in the message in which the
>> action is performed, uniquely identify the principal and that the
>> action is being taken on behalf of that person.
>>
>> The message in which VJ Rada attempted to vote on behalf of PSS read:
>> >
>> > I also have PSS vote as I do.
>>
>> While it communicates a general intent, I think it's pretty important (and
>> in the rules) that "act on behalf" or some strong indication thereof of the
>> act-on-behalf mechanism being used, and I don't think this message rises
>> to that standard.
>>
>> [END OF ARGUMENTS]
>>
>> In response to the VJ Rada's CoEs, I note the existence of the above CFJ.
>>
>>
>>
>> On Sat, 28 Apr 2018, Ned Strange wrote:
>> > and for the other proposals with em as well
>> >
>> > On Sat, Apr 28, 2018 at 2:52 PM, Ned Strange <edwardostra...@gmail.com>
>> > wrote:
>> > > CoE: I also voted against Blot Expansion with my zombie PSS
>> > >
>> > > On Sat, Apr 28, 2018 at 9:52 AM, Kerim Aydin <ke...@u.washington.edu>
>> > > wrote:
>> > >>
>> > >>
>> > >> I resolve the Agoran Decisions to adopt Proposals 8033-8041 as follows.
>> > >>
>> > >> Quorum is 3 for all of these proposals.
>> > >>
>> > >> co-author lists:
>> > >> [1] Aris, Cuddle Beam, Gaelan, Trigon
>> > >> [2] omd, pokes, o
>> > >> [3] Medals of Honour Correction Act
>> > >> [4] V.J. Rada
>> > >> [5] Ørjan
>> > >> [6] Trigon, G.
>> > >>
>> > >>> ID Author(s) AI Title Pender
>> > >>> ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
>> > >>> 8033 Kenyon, [1] 2.0 Gray Land and the Fountain Kenyon
>> > >> FOR: Aris, Corona, Trigon, Quazie, Kenyon
>> > >> AGAINST:
>> > >> PRESENT: V.J. Rada, ATMunn, 2xG.
>> > >> FOR/AGAINST: 5/0
>> > >> RESULT: ADOPTED
>> > >>
>> > >>> 8034 G. 2.0 Paydays Fix Kenyon
>> > >> FOR: Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon,
>> > >> 2xG.
>> > >> AGAINST:
>> > >> PRESENT:
>> > >> FOR/AGAINST: 9/0
>> > >> RESULT: ADOPTED
>> > >>
>> > >>> 8035 G., [2] 1.0 Nothing to worry about G.
>> > >> FOR: Corona, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, 2xG., omd, o, pokes
>> > >> AGAINST: Aris, Trigon, Kenyon
>> > >> PRESENT:
>> > >> FOR/AGAINST: 9/3
>> > >> RESULT: ADOPTED
>> > >>
>> > >>> 8036 Aris 2.0 Impeachment Aris
>> > >> FOR: Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon
>> > >> AGAINST: 2xG.
>> > >> PRESENT:
>> > >> FOR/AGAINST: 7/2
>> > >> RESULT: ADOPTED
>> > >>
>> > >>> 8037 ATMunn 1.0 Medals of Honour Correction Act ATMunn
>> > >> FOR: Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon
>> > >> AGAINST:
>> > >> PRESENT: 2xG.
>> > >> FOR/AGAINST: 7/0
>> > >> RESULT: ADOPTED
>> > >>
>> > >>> 8038 V.J. Rada 1.0 V.J. Rada Equitable Remedy. Corona
>> > >> FOR: 2xG.
>> > >> AGAINST: Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon
>> > >> PRESENT:
>> > >> FOR/AGAINST: 2/7
>> > >> RESULT: REJECTED
>> > >>
>> > >>> 8039 Aris, [4] 2.1 V.J. Rada Equitable Remedy v2 Aris
>> > >> FOR: Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon,
>> > >> 2xG.
>> > >> AGAINST:
>> > >> PRESENT:
>> > >> FOR/AGAINST: 9/0
>> > >> RESULT: ADOPTED
>> > >>
>> > >>> 8040 Aris, [5] 3.0 Blot Expansion v3 Aris
>> > >> FOR: Aris, Corona, Trigon, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon, 2xG.
>> > >> AGAINST: V.J. Rada
>> > >> PRESENT:
>> > >> FOR/AGAINST: 8/1
>> > >> RESULT: ADOPTED
>> > >>
>> > >>> 8041 Aris, [6] 2.0 Consolidated Patch Aris
>> > >> FOR: Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon,
>> > >> 2xG.
>> > >> AGAINST:
>> > >> PRESENT:
>> > >> FOR/AGAINST: 9/0
>> > >> RESULT: ADOPTED
>> > >>
>> > >>
>> > >> TEXT OF ADOPTED PROPOSALS
>> > >>
>> > >> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> > >> ID: 8033
>> > >> Title: Gray Land and the Fountain
>> > >> Adoption index: 2.0
>> > >> Author: Kenyon
>> > >> Co-authors: Aris, Cuddle Beam, Gaelan, Trigon
>> > >>
>> > >>
>> > >> Amend "Land Types" (Power=2.0):
>> > >> Replace "whose values are "Black", "White", and "Aether"", with the
>> > >> text "whose values are "Black", "White", "Gray", and "Aether""
>> > >>
>> > >> Create a new rule "Facility Categories", (Power=2.0):
>> > >> A facility's Category is a switch whose possible values are
>> > >> “Production”, “Processing”, “Monument”, and “Miscellaneous”. An “x
>> > >> facility”, where x is a Category, refers to a facility that has
>> > >> Category switch set to x.
>> > >>
>> > >> Amend "Asset Generation with Facilities" (Power=2.0) to read the
>> > >> following:
>> > >> When an Production or Processing facility creates assets, the assets
>> > >> are added to the facility's possession. The rule that creates an
>> > >> Production or Processing facility CAN specify a carrying capacity for
>> > >> assets. If, at any time, the amount of an asset in the possession of
>> > >> an
>> > >> Production or Processing facility exceeds that asset's carrying
>> > >> capacity, an amount of that asset is destroyed until the amount of
>> > >> that
>> > >> asset in the possession of the facility is equal to its carrying
>> > >> capacity.
>> > >>
>> > >> At the end of every Agoran Week, Agora creates a number of assets in a
>> > >> Production facility specified by the rule which creates the facility.
>> > >>
>> > >> At the end of every Agoran Week, Agora destroys any refinable assets
>> > >> in
>> > >> the possession of each Processing facility that that facility can
>> > >> change into refined assets and replaces them with a corresponding
>> > >> number of refined assets to be specified by the rule that creates the
>> > >> facility.
>> > >>
>> > >> A player can take a number of assets from an Production or Processing
>> > >> facility's inventory by announcement if eir location is the same as
>> > >> the facility's and the following criteria are met:
>> > >> 1. if the facility is built on unconserved Public Land, none.
>> > >> 2. if the facility is built on preserved Public Land and less than
>> > >> four days have passed since assets were created in the facility most
>> > >> recently, e must not have taken any assets from the inventory of
>> > >> another facility located on a preserved Land Unit within this Agoran
>> > >> week.
>> > >> 3. if the facility is built on Communal Land, e must be a party to
>> > >> that contract and the text of the contract must permit em to do so.
>> > >> 4. if the facility is built on Private Land, e must own the facility,
>> > >> or the owner must have consented.
>> > >>
>> > >> Amend "Facility Ranks" (Power=2.0) to read the following:
>> > >> Rank is a facility switch tracked by the Cartographor defaulting to 1.
>> > >> Its possible values include all integers between 1 and 5, inclusive.
>> > >>
>> > >> If a facility specifies upgrade costs, a player CAN increase the rank
>> > >> of a facility e owns that is at eir location by exactly 1 by
>> > >> announcement by paying any upgrade costs of the facility for that
>> > >> specific rank. If no upgrade costs are specified for a facility, a
>> > >> player CANNOT increase the rank of that facility unless specified in
>> > >> other rules.
>> > >>
>> > >> Create a new rule "Facility Colors" (Power=2.0):
>> > >> A facility's Allowed Land Types is a switch with allowed values of a
>> > >> list of allowed values of the Land Type switch, with a default value
>> > >> of
>> > >> {"Black", "White"}. A facility may not have a Parent Land Unit whose
>> > >> Land Type is not an element of their Allowed Land Types. If an action
>> > >> or set of actions would cause a facility to be created with a Parent
>> > >> Land Unit whose Land Type is not an element of its Allowed Land Types,
>> > >> that action or set of actions fails. If a facility's Parent Land
>> > >> Unit's
>> > >> Land Type is flipped to a color that is not in that facility's Allowed
>> > >> Land Types, that facility is destroyed.
>> > >>
>> > >> An “x facility”, where x is a Land Type or list of Land Types, refers
>> > >> to a facility that has the Allowed Land Types switch set to x.
>> > >>
>> > >> Create a new rule "Gray Land" (Power=2.0):
>> > >> Gray Land is preserved and owned by Agora. If Land becomes Gray Land,
>> > >> it, along with any facilities with it as their Parent Land Unit, is
>> > >> transferred to Agora.
>> > >>
>> > >> Amend “Actions in Arcadia” (Power=1.0) by replacing the first two
>> > >> element
>> > >> in the list with:
>> > >> 1. 1 apple to move from one Land Unit to an adjacent Unit if their
>> > >> Land
>> > >> Types are the same or one of them is gray, and the destination is not
>> > >> Aether;
>> > >>
>> > >> 2. 2 apples to move from one Land Unit to an adjacent Unit if their
>> > >> Land Types differ, neither is gray, and the destination is not Aether;
>> > >>
>> > >> Create a new rule "Monument Facilities" (Power=1.0):
>> > >> For each type of Monument facility, there may only be one instance of
>> > >> that facility in existence at any one time. An action CANNOT cause an
>> > >> Monument facility to exist while another Monument facility of the same
>> > >> type is already in existence.
>> > >>
>> > >> Create a new rule "The Fountain" (Power=1.0):
>> > >> A fountain is a Gray Monument facility. A fountain has no upkeep cost.
>> > >>
>> > >> Create a new rule "Wishing Fountain", (Power=1.0):
>> > >> If a player's location is the same as a fountain, e CAN destroy a coin
>> > >> to Throw A Coin into the fountain. This does nothing, unless specified
>> > >> in another Rule. A player MAY announce what e wishes for when e Throws
>> > >> A Coin.
>> > >>
>> > >> Set (0, 0)'s Land Type to "Gray".
>> > >> Create a fountain at (0, 0) belonging to Agora.
>> > >>
>> > >> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> > >> ID: 8034
>> > >> Title: Paydays Fix
>> > >> Adoption index: 2.0
>> > >> Author: G.
>> > >> Co-authors:
>> > >>
>> > >>
>> > >> Amend Rule 2559 (Paydays) by replacing the text:
>> > >> e was not issued any Cards other than Green for eir conduct
>> > >> in that office
>> > >> with:
>> > >> no unforgivable fines were levied on em for eir conduct in that
>> > >> office
>> > >>
>> > >> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> > >> ID: 8035
>> > >> Title: Nothing to worry about
>> > >> Adoption index: 1.0
>> > >> Author: G.
>> > >> Co-authors: omd, pokes, o
>> > >>
>> > >>
>> > >> When this proposal takes effect:
>> > >>
>> > >> IF a body of text labelled TALES OF THE ZOMBIE APOCALYPSE has been
>> > >> published since April 1, 2018,
>> > >>
>> > >> AND that body of text has the following SHA-512 Hash:
>> > >> 40ae885e13bb285c25cc19aba4d5d73bf98908781a800a2a389925aa7eb3ad49
>> > >> 17aee5e4cfa14fd615193fa1fe2ba3d15fc246c98fb13f159034ae135beafbdf
>> > >>
>> > >> THEN:
>> > >>
>> > >> - First, the power of that body of text is set to the adoption
>> > >> index of this proposal;
>> > >> - Second the provisions contained in that body of text take effect;
>> > >> - Finally, the power of that body of text is set to 0.
>> > >>
>> > >> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> > >> ID: 8036
>> > >> Title: Impeachment
>> > >> Adoption index: 2.0
>> > >> Author: Aris
>> > >> Co-authors:
>> > >>
>> > >>
>> > >> Enact a new power 2.0 rule, entitled "Impeachment", with the following
>> > >> text:
>> > >>
>> > >> A player CAN be expelled (impeached) from a specified elected office
>> > >> which
>> > >> e holds with 2 Agoran Consent. When a person is impeached from an
>> > >> office,
>> > >> an election is immediately opened for that office. Players SHOULD NOT
>> > >> use
>> > >> this method of removal unless the officer has abused the powers of eir
>> > >> office or otherwise shown emself unworthy the trust of Agora.
>> > >>
>> > >> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> > >> ID: 8037
>> > >> Title: Medals of Honour Correction Act
>> > >> Adoption index: 1.0
>> > >> Author: ATMunn
>> > >> Co-authors:
>> > >>
>> > >>
>> > >> In rule 2529 "Medals of Honour", amend the first paragraph after the
>> > >> bullet
>> > >> list to read as follows:
>> > >> {
>> > >> Beginning in the second Eastman week of an Agoran month and ending
>> > >> when the
>> > >> next Agoran month begins, if there are any players who are eligible
>> > >> for a
>> > >> Medal of Honour, the Herald CAN, by announcement, initiate an Agoran
>> > >> Decision
>> > >> on who is to be awarded a Medal of Honour. E SHALL do so within the
>> > >> second
>> > >> Eastman week of that Agoran month. For this decision, the valid
>> > >> options are
>> > >> all players who are eligible for a Medal of Honour, the vote
>> > >> collector is the
>> > >> Herald, and the voting method is instant-runoff. Upon the resolution
>> > >> of this
>> > >> decision, the Herald CAN, and SHALL in a timely fashion, award the
>> > >> outcome of
>> > >> the decision a Medal of Honour by announcement. After a player is
>> > >> awarded a
>> > >> Medal of Honour, all players who were previously eligible for a Medal
>> > >> of
>> > >> Honour become no longer eligible.
>> > >> }
>> > >>
>> > >> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> > >> ID: 8039
>> > >> Title: V.J. Rada Equitable Remedy v2
>> > >> Adoption index: 2.1
>> > >> Author: Aris
>> > >> Co-authors: V.J. Rada
>> > >>
>> > >>
>> > >> If the Contract "Hi!" does not exist, create in V.J. Rada's
>> > >> possession assets equal to the assets in that Contract at the moment
>> > >> before its destruction. If that Contract still exists, destroy it and
>> > >> then create in V.J. Rada's possession assets equal to the assets in
>> > >> that Contract at the moment before its destruction.
>> > >>
>> > >> Then, transfer one paper and one coin from V.J. Rada to whoever pended
>> > >> this proposal. Then, transfer one coin from V.J. Rada to any player
>> > >> that voted for this proposal.
>> > >>
>> > >> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> > >> ID: 8040
>> > >> Title: Blot Expansion v3
>> > >> Adoption index: 3.0
>> > >> Author: Aris
>> > >> Co-author(s): Ørjan
>> > >>
>> > >>
>> > >> Amend Rule 2483, "Economics", by: {
>> > >> Appending "10. incense", as a new list item after "9. fabric"; and
>> > >>
>> > >> Changing "Stones, apples, and corn are considered unrefinable
>> > >> currencies;"
>> > >> to read "Stones, apples, corn, and incense are considered unrefinable
>> > >> currencies;"
>> > >> }
>> > >>
>> > >> Amend Rule 2563, "Production Facilities", by appending
>> > >>
>> > >> "4. Temples
>> > >> - Build Cost: 2 lumber, and 3 fabric
>> > >> - Upkeep Cost: n-1 fabric
>> > >> - Production Details: 3n incense
>> > >> - Upgrade Costs:
>> > >> - Rank 2: 4 coins, 1 lumber, 1 fabric
>> > >> - Rank 3: 6 coins, 2 lumber, 3 fabric
>> > >> - Rank 4: 8 coins, 4 lumber, 2 stones, 5 fabric
>> > >> - Rank 5: 10 coins, 6 lumber, 4 stones, 7 fabric"
>> > >>
>> > >> Amend Rule 2559, "Paydays", by appending "D. 3 incense", as a new list
>> > >> item
>> > >> after "C. 2 papers".
>> > >>
>> > >> Amend the rule defining welcome packages by adding as a new item,
>> > >> appropriately
>> > >> numbered, at the end of the list "5 incense".
>> > >>
>> > >> Create 5 incense in the possession of each non-zombie player.
>> > >>
>> > >> Amend Rule 2557, "Removing Blots", by changing the first paragraph to
>> > >> read
>> > >> "A player CAN, by announcement, destroy N incense in eir possession to
>> > >> expunge N of eir blots. When e does so, e is STRONGLY ENCOURAGED to
>> > >> publicly
>> > >> and grandiloquently apologize to the Spirit of the Game for eir grave
>> > >> crime
>> > >> in breaking the rules, to verbosely praise the same spirit, and to
>> > >> fervently
>> > >> request forgiveness."
>> > >>
>> > >> Amend Rule 2556, "Penalties", by appending the text
>> > >>
>> > >> "A player CAN, with 7 days notice, deregister (exile) a specified
>> > >> player
>> > >> (the outlaw) who has more than 40 blots."
>> > >>
>> > >> as a new paragraph at the end of the rule.
>> > >>
>> > >> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> > >> ID: 8041
>> > >> Title: Consolidated Patch
>> > >> Adoption index: 2.0
>> > >> Author: Aris
>> > >> Co-author(s): Trigon, G.
>> > >>
>> > >>
>> > >> Reenact Rule 2456, "The Treasuror" (Power = 1.0), with the following
>> > >> text:
>> > >> The Treasuror is an office.
>> > >>
>> > >> The Treasuror's weekly report includes the list of all public classes
>> > >> of assets.
>> > >>
>> > >> Make Gaelan the Treasuror.
>> > >>
>> > >> If Rule 2499 is not currently enacted, re-enact it with the following
>> > >> text: {
>> > >>
>> > >> If a player has not received a Welcome Package since e most
>> > >> recently registered, any player CAN cause em to receive one by
>> > >> announcement.
>> > >>
>> > >> When a player receives a Welcome Package, Agora creates the
>> > >> following assets in eir possession:
>> > >>
>> > >> 1. 10 coins
>> > >> 2. 5 lumber
>> > >> 3. 5 stones
>> > >> 4. 10 apples
>> > >> 5. 3 papers
>> > >> }
>> > >>
>> > >> If a proposal entitled "Gray Land and the Fountain" has not passed: {
>> > >> Amend Rule 2561, Asset Generation with Facilities, by inserting before
>> > >> the text
>> > >>
>> > >> "A player can take a number of assets from a facility's inventory
>> > >> by announcement if eir location is the same as the facility's and
>> > >> the following criteria are met:"
>> > >>
>> > >> the text
>> > >>
>> > >> "A player CANNOT transfer assets to a facility not at eir location."
>> > >> }
>> > >> otherwise: {
>> > >> Amend Rule 2561, Asset Generation with Facilities, by inserting
>> > >> before the
>> > >> text
>> > >> "A player can take a number of assets from an Production or
>> > >> Processing
>> > >> facility's inventory by announcement if eir location is the same as
>> > >> the
>> > >> facility's and the following criteria are met:"
>> > >>
>> > >> the text
>> > >>
>> > >> "A player CANNOT transfer assets to a facility not at eir location."
>> > >> }
>> > >>
>> > >> Amend Rule 2003, Actions in Arcadia, by changing the text "substitute 3
>> > >> apples for 1 corn" to read "substitute 1 coin for three or fewer
>> > >> apples".
>> > >>
>> > >> Amend Rule 2551, "Auction End", by changing the text
>> > >>
>> > >> "When e does so, the Auctioneer SHALL transfer the items in that lot
>> > >> to that winner in a timely fashion. If the Auctioneer is not a
>> > >> person, then a person authorized to cause the Auctioneer to transfer
>> > >> those items SHALL do so in a timely fashion after the winner pays the
>> > >> Auctioneer, instead."
>> > >>
>> > >> to read
>> > >>
>> > >> "When e does so, if the auctioneer CAN transfer the items in that lot
>> > >> to
>> > >> that winner at will, e immediately does so; otherwise, e SHALL do so
>> > >> in a
>> > >> timely fashion. For this purpose, a contract CAN do whatever it could
>> > >> do if it were a person in addition to what it can do as a contract,
>> > >> and Agora CAN do anything."
>> > >>
>> > >> Amend Rule 1885, Zombie Auctions, by removing the final paragraph and by
>> > >> appending the text "For the purpose of such a auction, to transfer a
>> > >> zombie to
>> > >> a player is to set that zombie's master switch to that player." to the
>> > >> third
>> > >> paragraph.
>> > >>
>> > >> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> > >>
>> > >>
>> > >
>> > >
>> > >
>> > > --
>> > > From V.J. Rada
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> > --
>> > From V.J. Rada
>> >
>>
--
>From V.J. Rada
