This isn't a Notice, no reasons specified.
On Fri, May 4, 2018 at 5:52 AM, Reuben Staley <reuben.sta...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Oh, I must've missed that message. Oops. Either way, thanks for this
> deputization.
>
> Notice of Honour: +1 Corona; -1 Telnaior
>
> On Thu, May 3, 2018, 13:09 Corona <liliumalbum.ag...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
>> Sorry, G. judged that paying without recipient doesn't mean transferring
>> to anyone but it means destruction (see below), so you didn't pay (you
>> would have attempted to transfer to Aris, right?) I'm for a proposal to
>> give you the farm back.
>>
>>
>> Oh heck, if there's a time for a political power play in pursuit of the
>> greater good, it's now.
>>
>> I issue a Cabinet Order of Certiorari (Arbitor) to assign the below case
>> to myself.
>>
>> I deliver the following judgement:
>> FALSE, based on the Caller's Arguments for FALSE.
>>
>> On Mon, 30 Apr 2018, Kerim Aydin wrote:
>> > I CFJ on: If the Rules say you CAN do something by paying assets,
>> without
>> > specifying a destination for the payment, you CAN do it by transferring
>> > those assets to anyone.
>> >
>> > Arguments:
>> >
>> > Straightforward argument for TRUE:
>> > R2166 overrides common definitions by making "pay" a synonym for
>> transfer:
>> > > An asset generally CAN be transferred (syn. paid, given) by
>> > > announcement by its owner to another entity, subject to
>> > > modification by its backing document.
>> >
>> > Straightforward argument for FALSE:
>> > Payments without destination are error-trapped by this later clause in
>> > R2166:
>> > > If a rule, proposal, or other
>> > > competent authority attempts to increase or decrease the balance
>> > > of an entity without specifying a source or destination, then the
>> > > currency is created or destroyed as needed.
>> > so if "payment without destination" is a method in the rules for doing
>> > something, it happens via asset destruction only (not transfer).
>> >
>>
>>
>> ~Corona
>>
>> On Thu, May 3, 2018 at 9:03 PM, Reuben Staley <reuben.sta...@gmail.com>
>> wrote:
>>
>> > Where's my farm though? I"paid" upkeep to the best of my ability.
>> >
>> > On Thu, May 3, 2018, 10:52 Corona <liliumalbum.ag...@gmail.com> wrote:
>> >
>> > > I deputize for the Treasuror to post the following report. Please check
>> > > your actions and balances.
>> > >
>> > >
>> > >
>> > >
>> > > +-------------------------------+----+----+----+---+----+---
>> > -+----+----+----+----+
>> > >
>> > > |Entity
>> > > |Ston|Appl|Corn|Ore|Lmbr|Cotn|Coin|Papr|Fabr|Incs|
>> > >
>> > >
>> > > +-------------------------------+----+----+----+---+----+---
>> > -+----+----+----+----+
>> > >
>> > > |ATMunn | 10| 35| 0| 0| 10| 0| 39|
>> 10|
>> > > 0| 5|
>> > >
>> > > |Aris | 5| 25| 7| 0| 5| 0| 77|
>> 5|
>> > > 0| 5|
>> > >
>> > > |Corona | 24| 40| 21| 17| 9| 18| 89|
>> 16|
>> > > 0| 5|
>> > >
>> > > |CuddleBeam | 11| 13| 9| 4| 8| 9| 40|
>> 8|
>> > > 0| 5|
>> > >
>> > > |G. | 20| 90| 11| 0| 20| 0| 140|
>> 29|
>> > > 0| 5|
>> > >
>> > > |Gaelan | 14| 23| 2| 6| 2| 0| 37|
>> 8|
>> > > 0| 5|
>> > >
>> > > |Kenyon | 14| 32| 4| 6| 20| 3| 35|
>> 7|
>> > > 0| 5|
>> > >
>> > > |Murphy | 5| 25| 4| 0| 8| 0| 60|
>> 9|
>> > > 0| 5|
>> > >
>> > > |Publius Scribonius Scholasticus| 0| 5| 0| 0| 0| 0| 10|
>> 2|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > > |Quazie | 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0|
>> 0|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > > |Telnaior | 5| 25| 3| 0| 5| 0| 55|
>> 9|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > > |Trigon | 3| 20| 11| 2| 4| 12| 28|
>> 6|
>> > > 0| 5|
>> > >
>> > > |VJ Rada | 10| 45| 1| 0| 10| 0| 55|
>> 15|
>> > > 0| 5|
>> > >
>> > > |nichdel | 0| 5| 0| 0| 0| 0| 10|
>> 2|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > > |o | 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0|
>> 0|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > > |omd | 0| 10| 0| 0| 0| 0| 20|
>> 4|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > > |Ouri | 0| 5| 0| 0| 0| 0| 14|
>> 2|
>> > > 0| 5|
>> > >
>> > > |pokes | 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0|
>> 0|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > > |天火狐 | 5| 25| 0| 0| 5| 0| 40| 9|
>> > 0|
>> > > 5|
>> > >
>> > >
>> > > +-------------------------------+----+----+----+---+----+---
>> > -+----+----+----+----+
>> > >
>> > > |farm at 1,-1 | 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0|
>> 0|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > > |mine at -1,-1 | 3| 0| 0| 2| 0| 0| 0|
>> 0|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > > |mine at 1,1 | 3| 0| 0| 2| 0| 0| 0|
>> 0|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > > |orchard at -1,1 | 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0|
>> 0|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > > |(Corona’s) mine at 0,2 | 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0|
>> 0|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > > |(Corona’s) refinery at 1,-2 | 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0|
>> 0|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > > |(Corona’s) orchard at 2,1 | 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0|
>> 0|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > > |Finger Pointing Workaround | 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 1|
>> 0|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > > |Agora | 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 0| 174|
>> 0|
>> > > 0| 0|
>> > >
>> > >
>> > > +-------------------------------+----+----+----+---+----+---
>> > -+----+----+----+----+
>> > >
>> > >
>> > >
>> > > The following abbreviations are used in the table above:
>> > >
>> > > Ston = stone
>> > >
>> > > Appl = apples
>> > >
>> > > Lmbr = lumber
>> > >
>> > > Cotn = cotton
>> > >
>> > > Coin = coins
>> > >
>> > > Papr = papers
>> > >
>> > > Fabr = fabric
>> > >
>> > > Incs = incense
>> > >
>> > >
>> > >
>> > > Recent changes (most recent first, times in UTC, non-self-ratifying):
>> > >
>> > > [Thu May 3 16:32:22] Corona, via Quazie, looted (1,-1) (acquiring 18
>> > corn &
>> > > 18 cotton), destroying 1 apple
>> > >
>> > > [Thu May 3 13:10:20] ATMunn transferred 1 coin to “Finger Pointing
>> > > Workaround” for upkeep
>> > >
>> > > [Wed May 2 06:16:07] Aris destroyed a paper to pend “Crystals v2”
>> > >
>> > > [Tue May 1 06:22:41] If eir scam was successful (FALSE), Corona would
>> > have
>> > > destroyed some stuff
>> > >
>> > > [Tue May 1 00:11:29] G. caused o to transfer all eir (liquid) assets to
>> > > emself, pokes to transfer all eir assets to omd
>> > >
>> > > [Sun Apr 01 00:00] new month begins (payday). Trigon’s farm is, sadly,
>> > > destroyed due to em failing to pay upkeep
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 30 21:50:05] Corona collected assets from eir facilities and
>> > paid
>> > > upkeep for them (totalling 6 coins, 2 stones and 2 lumber, and
>> > destroying 3
>> > > apples to move)
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 30 06:45:43] Trigon looted (-1,1), using 1 corn to move
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 30 00:25:19] ATMunn pended “no more zombies” with 1 paper
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 30 00:00] new week begins (assets are produced in facilities)
>> > >
>> > > [Sun Apr 29 23:18:37] Trigon may have performed the below actions here,
>> > > nobody CFJed it
>> > >
>> > > [Sun Apr 29 22:52:44] Trigon looted (0,-2) (acquiring 6 corn, 6 cotton)
>> > and
>> > > attempted to loot the empty (1,1) and “if, after performing the
>> enclosed
>> > > actions, I would not have any upkeep costs to pay (FALSE): {I transfer
>> 1
>> > > lumber and 1 stone to Aris in order to pay my upkeep costs}”. 1 corn &
>> 1
>> > > apple were destroyed
>> > >
>> > > [Sun Apr 29 22:22:01] Corona attempted some more pointless asset to and
>> > fro
>> > > with Quazie, then eir contingency plan kicked in, looting (1,1), moving
>> > to
>> > > (2,1), building an orchard there & upgrading all eir facilities to rank
>> > 2.
>> > > E also, via Quazie, put 5 ore in the refinery at (1,-2). Total assets
>> > > destroyed: 11 coins, 5 lumber, 5 apples and 9 stones
>> > >
>> > > [Fri Apr 27 23:52:26] A batch of proposals is resolved; VJ Rada gets
>> back
>> > > most of his assets (1 coin being given to each FOR voter and 1 coin
>> and 1
>> > > paper to the pender); incense is created and each non-zombie player
>> > > receives 5 of it
>> > >
>> > > [Thu Apr 26 05:24:18] (Assuming G.’s judgement about the scam not
>> working
>> > > is valid here and elsewhere) Corona moved to (0,2), built a mine there,
>> > > moved Quazie to (1,-2), built a refinery there and attempted a bunch of
>> > > transfers. Total assets destroyed: 5 apples, 9 lumber and 8 stones
>> > >
>> > > [Wed Apr 25 05:30:12] Aris paid 1 paper to pend Agorans are Vulcans
>> > >
>> > > [Tue Apr 24 11:54:45] G. transferred 2 coins to ATMunn
>> > >
>> > > [Tue Apr 24 00:34:39] ATMunn transferred a coin to Agora to create the
>> > > contract “Finger Pointing Workaround”
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 23 14:50:13] G. paid a paper to pend the proposal Officer
>> > patching
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 23 04:48:31] Corona looted (-1,1) and, via Quazie, (-1,-1)
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 23 00:00] new week begins (assets are produced in facilities)
>> > >
>> > > [Sat Apr 21 05:26:47] Trigon pended “Q*Bert the Second” with 1 paper
>> > >
>> > > [Wed Apr 18 04:49:37] Aris transferred 12 coins to Agora for the land
>> > unit
>> > > at (1,2)
>> > >
>> > > [Wed Apr 18 04:07:50] Corona attempted to pay 1 coin to Agora via
>> Quazie
>> > > for the land unit at (2,2), failed
>> > >
>> > > [Wed Apr 18 04:04:33] Corona paid 1 coin to Agora [for the land unit at
>> > > (2,1)]
>> > >
>> > > [Wed Apr 18 00:56:43] G. paid 8 coins to Agora for the land unit at
>> (2,0)
>> > >
>> > > [Tue Apr 17 22:21:12] ATMunn transferred 10 coins to Agora for the land
>> > > unit at (1, 3)
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 16 05:54:54] Trigon looted (0,-2)
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 16 05:25:20] Corona looted (-1,1) and, via Quazie, (-1,-1)
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 16 00:00] new week begins (assets are produced in facilities)
>> > >
>> > > [Sun Apr 15 20:57:07] Trigon pended “5 auctions” with 1 paper
>> > >
>> > > [Sat Apr 14 04:05:48] Aris pended “Consolidated Patch” and “Blot
>> > Expansion
>> > > v3 with 1 paper each
>> > >
>> > > [Sat Apr 14 03:55:02] Aris pended “V.J. Rada Equitable Remedy v2” with
>> 1
>> > > paper
>> > >
>> > > [Fri Apr 13 13:22:58] Corona pended “V.J. Rada Equitable Remedy” with 1
>> > > paper. It’s not very effective...
>> > >
>> > > [Fri Apr 13 08:06:17] Trigon transferred 1 paper to Aris
>> > >
>> > > [Thu Apr 12 12:54:39] ATMunn pended "Medals of Honour Correction Act"
>> > with
>> > > 1 paper
>> > >
>> > > [Thu Apr 12 05:57:39] Aris pended “Impeachment” with 1 paper
>> > >
>> > > [Wed Apr 11 13:33:41] ATMunn attempted to loot some empty facilities,
>> > > destroying 3 apples
>> > >
>> > > [Wed Apr 11 13:27:58] ATMunn looted nichdel’s corpse, and failed to
>> move
>> > >
>> > > [Wed Apr 11 10:04:34] VJ Rada scammed emself with the contract “Hi”,
>> > > transferring all eir assets to it (and paying 1 coin to Agora to create
>> > it)
>> > >
>> > > [Wed Apr 11 08:37:50] Corona doubleposted the previous conditional
>> action
>> > > (nothing happened) and if the orchard (-1,1) was nonempty (TRUE),
>> Corona
>> > > looted it, destroying 2 apples
>> > >
>> > > [Wed Apr 11 07:39:24] If mine at (-1,-1) was nonempty (TRUE), Corona
>> > looted
>> > > it via Quazie, transferring & destroying 3 apples
>> > >
>> > > [Wed Apr 11 07:16:45] Trigon moved around, looted (from (1,1)) & built,
>> > > destroying 2 apples, 1 corn, 5 stones, 4 lumber and 3 coins
>> > >
>> > > Tue Apr 10 13:28:06] ATMunn paid 10 coins to Agora for zombie nichdel
>> > >
>> > > [Tue Apr 10 13:23:36] Gaelan transferred 13 coins to Agora for the land
>> > > unit (-1,-2)
>> > >
>> > > [Tue Apr 10 06:43:05] Corona looted Quazie’s body and paid 31 coins to
>> > > Agora for 2 land units
>> > >
>> > > [Tue Apr 10 06:29:13] Trigon paid 15 coins to Agora for the land unit
>> > > (0,-2)
>> > >
>> > > [Tue Apr 10 05:34:04] Kenyon paid 13 coins to Agora for the land unit
>> > > (-1,2)
>> > >
>> > > [Tue Apr 10 05:23:17] Corona paid 5 coins to Agora for zombie Quazie
>> > >
>> > > [Tue Apr 10 04:31:55] VJ Rada looted PSS’s body
>> > >
>> > > [Tue Apr 10 01:53:08] G. spent 1 paper to pend “Nothing to worry about”
>> > >
>> > > [Tue Apr 10 01:12:02] VJ Rada transferred 12 coins to Agora for zombie
>> > PSS
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 9 17:58:39] G. looted pokes’ and o’s bodies
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 9 17:55:58] G. paid 21 coins to Agora on behalf of omd for
>> > zombie
>> > > pokes, G. paid 21 coins to Agora for zombie o
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 9 17:26:41] G. transferred 25 coins to omd
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 09 00:00] new week begins (assets are produced in facilities)
>> > >
>> > > [Sun Apr 8 19:11:06] Kenyon pended “Paydays Fix” with 1 paper
>> > >
>> > > [Sun Apr 8 13:25:58] ATMunn gave Kenyon 2 coins for reports
>> > >
>> > > [Sat Apr 7 19:30:53] Trigon moved around and created land units, using
>> 15
>> > > apples
>> > >
>> > > [Thu Apr 5 00:52:50] Kenyon pended “Gray Land and the Fountain” with 1
>> > > paper
>> > >
>> > > [Tue Apr 3 13:15:34] ATMunn destroyed an apple to move to (-1,0) and
>> > > destroyed an apple to move to (-1,1) and transferred all assets (none)
>> > from
>> > > (-1,1) to emself
>> > >
>> > > [Tue Apr 3 04:59:23] Gaelan destroyed 2 apples to move to (-1,-1) and
>> > > grabbed everything there (9 stones, 6 ore)
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 2 16:52:14] Corona took all contents (6 stones, 4 ore) of the
>> > mine
>> > > at (1, 1)
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 2 16:24:01] Kenyon took all contents (6 apples, 6 lumber) of
>> the
>> > > orchard at (-1,1)
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 2 06:37:25] G. acted on behalf of omd to transfer all eir
>> > > currencies to emself
>> > >
>> > >
>> > >
>> > > [Last report]
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Apr 02 00:00] new week begins (assets are produced in facilities)
>> > >
>> > > [Sun Apr 01 22:46] Gaelan destroyed 1 paper to pend Cross-Polination
>> > >
>> > > [Sun Apr 01 00:00] new month begins (payday)
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 26 14:21] ATMunn destroyed 1 paper to pend Free Tournaments
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 26 00:00] new week begins (assets are produced in facilities)
>> > >
>> > > [Fri Mar 23 20:52] Reportor repealed by Proposal 8027
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 19 22:56] Corona transferred all currencies (3 stones, 2 ore)
>> > from
>> > > 1,1 to Corona
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 19 15:50] Murphy resolved the Rulekeepor election, no
>> candidates
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 19 15:50] Murphy resolved the Referee election, electing
>> Cuddle
>> > > Beam
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 19 15:50] Murphy resolved the Prime Minister election,
>> electing
>> > G.
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 19 15:50] Murphy resolved the Notary election, electing VJ
>> Rada
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 19 15:37] CuddleBeam transferred all currencies (6 corn, 6
>> > cotton)
>> > > from 1,-1 to CuddleBeam
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 19 14:24] G. destroyed 1 paper to pend Blots v1.0
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 19 01:17] if -1,1 has any assets (true), Kenyon transferred
>> all
>> > > currencies (6 apples, 6 lumber) from -1,1 to Kenyon
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 19 00:00] new week begins (assets are produced in facilities)
>> > >
>> > > [Sun Mar 18 13:18] Aris transferred all currencies (nothing) from -1,-1
>> > to
>> > > Aris
>> > >
>> > > [Fri Mar 16 22:05] if PAoaM Patch isn't pending (false), Kenyon
>> > destroyed 1
>> > > paper to pend PAoaM Patch
>> > >
>> > > [Fri Mar 16 18:06] ATMunn destroyed 1 paper to pend PAoaM Patch
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 12 16:28] if there exists a mine at 1,1 and 1,1 has any assets
>> > > (true), Corona transferred all currencies (3 stones, 2 ore) from 1,1 to
>> > > Corona
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 12 16:28] if there exists a mine at 1,1 and 1,1 has any assets
>> > > (true), Corona destroyed 2 apples
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 12 01:28] if -1,-1 has any assets (false), Aris transferred
>> all
>> > > currencies (nothing) from -1,-1 to Aris
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 12 01:28] if -1,-1 has any assets (false), Aris destroyed 2
>> > apples
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 12 01:12] Kenyon transferred all currencies (3 stones, 2 ore)
>> > from
>> > > -1,-1 to Kenyon
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 12 00:00] new week begins (assets are produced in facilities)
>> > >
>> > > [Sun Mar 11 15:58] ATMunn gave welcome packages to ATMunn
>> > >
>> > > [Sun Mar 11 15:58] ATMunn registered
>> > >
>> > > [Wed Mar 07 07:48] Gaelan transferred 3 lumber from Gaelan to Murphy
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 05 01:55] Kenyon transferred all (3) apples, all (3) lumber
>> from
>> > > -1,1 to Kenyon
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 05 01:55] Kenyon transferred all (3) corn, all (3) cotton from
>> > > 1,-1 to Kenyon
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 05 01:55] Kenyon transferred all (3) stones, all (2) ore from
>> > 1,1
>> > > to Kenyon
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 05 01:55] Kenyon transferred all (3) stones, all (2) ore from
>> > > -1,-1 to Kenyon
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 05 01:55] Kenyon destroyed 8 apples to move around and be that
>> > one
>> > > guy
>> > >
>> > > [Mon Mar 05 00:00] new week begins (assets are produced in facilities)
>> > >
>> > > [Thu Mar 01 15:56] Murphy resolved the Reportor election, electing VJ
>> > Rada
>> > >
>> > > [Thu Mar 01 12:14] Corona destroyed 1 paper to pend
>> > >
>> > > [Thu Mar 01 07:43] Cuddle Beam deputised for Referee and published the
>> > > Referee's weekly report
>> > >
>> > > [Thu Mar 01 03:14] CuddleBeam transferred all (0) apples, all (0)
>> lumber
>> > > from -1,1 to CuddleBeam
>> > >
>> > > [Thu Mar 01 03:14] CuddleBeam transferred all (0) stones, all (0) ore
>> > from
>> > > 1,1 to CuddleBeam
>> > >
>> > > [Thu Mar 01 03:14] CuddleBeam transferred all (0) corn, all (0) cotton
>> > from
>> > > 1,-1 to CuddleBeam
>> > >
>> > > [Thu Mar 01 03:14] CuddleBeam transferred all (0) stones, all (0) ore
>> > from
>> > > -1,-1 to CuddleBeam
>> > >
>> > > [Thu Mar 01 03:14] CuddleBeam destroyed 7 apples to move around to grab
>> > all
>> > > the nonexistent new items
>> > >
>> > > [Thu Mar 01 00:00] new month begins (payday)
>> > >
>> > > ~Corona
>> > >
>> >
>>
--
>From V.J. Rada
