It wouldn't have worked, the sentence purporting to void transfers in an indeterminate way would have still made it unspecified.
On Thu, May 7, 2020 at 11:36 PM Kerim Aydin via agora-discussion < agora-discussion@agoranomic.org> wrote: > > > On 5/7/2020 6:30 AM, Rebecca via agora-discussion wrote: > > On Thu, May 7, 2020 at 11:26 PM Jason Cobb via agora-discussion < > > agora-discussion@agoranomic.org> wrote: > > > >> On 5/7/20 3:32 AM, Rebecca via agora-business wrote: > >>> I create a contract with the following text > >>> > >>> "Any player may become a party to this contract. Any party to this > >>> contract may act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin away from R. > >> Lee > >>> to emselves. The previous sentence is void and has no effect if a rule > >>> titled "A coin award" was enacted and awarded R. Lee one coin after its > >>> enactment, and then repealed itself. For the avoidance of ambiguity, > the > >>> current position of the said coin does not matter for the purposes of > >> this > >>> contract." > >> > >> > >> By the way, any party to this contract can transfer away all of your > >> coins, so you might want to destroy it. > >> > >> -- > >> Jason Cobb > >> > >> Well, it's indeterminate whether they can or not. > > > > Well sure let's test because the conditional that voids the transfer would > fail, but there's no conditional allowing the transfer: > > I become a party to the above contract. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > I act on behalf of R. Lee to transfer one coin to myself. > > -- >From R. Lee