G. isn't an interested judge (as is correctly listed on your report). It's
too late now, but.
On Mon, Aug 9, 2021 at 11:44 AM Telna via agora-official <
agora-offic...@agoranomic.org> wrote:
> The below CFJ is 3923. I assign it to G.
>
> =====
>
> The quoted message is a distribution message as outlined in Regulation AM0.
>
> Called by Trigon: Fri 06 Aug 2021 22:24:15
>
> =====
>
> On 2021-08-07 08:17, Trigon via agora-business wrote:
> > On 06/08/2021 21:38, Trigon via agora-official wrote:
> >> The Retrieval Period of the Second Victory Auction of Jun 2021 having
> >> ended at 13:07:41 on 6 August 2021, I hereby bring an end to this
> >> auction.
> >>
> >> ====================
> >> BIDS ON THIS AUCTION
> >> ====================
> >>
> >> -- FOR THE WIN CARD --
> >>
> >> [2021-07-21 05:38:48] Trigon 400cn
> >> [2021-07-21 06:12:45] R. Lee 500cn
> >> [2021-07-23 00:53:00] Falsifian 700cn
> >> [2021-07-23 00:56:16] Trigon 800cn
> >> [2021-07-23 23:57:57] *** G. ( 2^(82,589,933) − 1 )cn
> >> [2021-07-24 16:49:34] *** G. (withdrawal)
> >> [2021-07-27 14:29:49] Falsifian 1111cn
> >> [2021-07-30 02:28:28] (3) Trigon 1200cn
> >> [2021-07-30 05:04:57] (2) R. Lee 1500cn
> >> [2021-07-30 12:39:17] (1) Falsifian 1717cn
> >> [2021-07-30 13:07:41] (4) D. Wet 22cn
> >>
> >> -- FOR THE JUSTICE CARD --
> >>
> >> [2021-07-21 06:12:45] (2) R. Lee 1cn
> >> [2021-07-23 00:56:16] (1) Trigon 50cn
> >>
> >> Bids marked with numbers in parenthesis are active bids.
> >> Bids marked with asterisks are bids from withdrawn players.
> >>
> >> ============
> >> DISTRIBUTION
> >> ============
> >>
> >> Falsifian wins the first lot for 1717cn.
> >> Trigon wins the second lot for 50cn.
> >>
> >> No other lots exist.
> >>
> >> If all of the following succeed I do them:
> >> { I revoke from Falsifian 1717cn. I grant em one victory card. }
> >>
> >> If all of the following succeed I do them:
> >> { I revoke from Trigon 628cn. I grant em one justice card. }
> >>
> > CFJ: The quoted message is a distribution message as outlined in
> > Regulation AM0.
> >
> > ARGUMENTS: This may not be a distribution message because of a textual
> > error: I intended to award myself a new justice card for a price 578
> > coins greater that what I bid on it. What, if anything, did this message
> > do? Did it fail as it did not meet the criteria for a distribution
> > message? Did the distribution message succeed and I just violated the
> > "SHALL destroy and transfer" bit?
> >
> > EVIDENCE:
> >
> > Ambiguous quoted text:
> >
> >> Trigon wins the second lot for 50cn.
> > ...
> >> If all of the following succeed I do them:
> >> { I revoke from Trigon 628cn. I grant em one justice card. }
> >
> > Relevant part of AM0:
> >
> > DISTRIBUTION: The auctioneer for an auction CAN and SHALL, within
> > seven days of the ending of that auction's retrieval period,
> > create a public message (henceforth the "distribution message")
> > that contains a full history of bids on the auction and
> > withdrawals from the auction. It must also clearly indicate each
> > awardee and the lot e recieves. In this message, the auctioneer
> > CAN and SHALL destroy the amount to be paid from the inventory
> > each awardee and transfer to that player (or create in eir
> > possession if the item is new) the set of assets associated with
> > the lot e won. Failing to publish a distribution message
> > constitutes the Class 3 Crime of Auction Abandonment.
> >
>
--
>From R. Lee
