> On Jun 29, 2026, at 7:24 PM, juan via agora-discussion 
> <[email protected]> wrote:
> 
> ais523 via agora-business [2026-06-28 21:10]:
>> On Tue, 2026-06-23 at 15:07 +0200, Cosmo via agora-official wrote:
>> […]
>>> 9356~      juan+          1.0    Hailboulder
>> AGAINST: this introduces a timing scam on a week where the boulder
>> would fall in which you can choose to push or not push it at the last
>> moment to control whether the values are odd or even (and thus whether
>> the height increases or decreases), which makes it difficult to link
>> the boulder to anything else and somewhat ruins the interest in
>> tracking it even in isolation
>> […]
> 
> Because of the many vote changes, I need to address this issue.
> 
> There is no timing scam here!
> 
> Timing scams would happen if a player had an advantage to gain over others
> by acting at a particular time, maybe with special information. But the
> Boulder subgame is cooperative: everyone has the same goal. So
> this proposal would add a layer of complexity to the game insofar as
> players would now need to coordinate to achieve larger heights. If some
> misanthropic player has diverging goals to the others, now its a game
> of politics.
> 
> It's interesting to track it because we might manage to game the
> mathematics.
> 
> Let the Boulder free!
> 
> Also, we must not attach it to other things if that made it useful.
> 
> --
> juan
> Absurdor
> Boulder enthusiast
> Pun lover

What convinced me was not the timing scam element, but the fact that it would 
largely make the boulder's height useless as a way of tracking player effort. I 
feel like changes to the boulder rules should mostly be about player actions 
that raise the boulder, rather than the boulder doing things on its own.

- Galle

Reply via email to