On Thu, 2026-07-23 at 05:03 -0700, Aris via agora-discussion wrote: > If the alternative is looking at 7 months of emails, I agree. I'd hoped > that the Numerator and Illuminator would need to calculate those records > anyway, so it wouldn't be redundant work. Again, I haven't been following > well enough to have a great idea of the current state of affairs. > > My fear is that this could inadvertently invalidate what we believe the > current game state to be.
At BlogNomic, this sort of problem comes up very commonly, and the wording we usually use is along the lines of "change the gamestate to what it would currently be if, at past time X, we had made change Y": this is pretty similar to ratification but not quite the same (in particular, you do not need to calculate minimal changes, instead the change to past events is explicitly stated). If you do that at Agora, it generally doesn't change the ruleset (there are a lot of protections against changing the rules by accident and I think at least two of them are relevant), but it does change everything else. So we might have to calculate the effects on the ruleset, but I don't expect there to be any (other than the imagined change of adding a mechanism into the rule). -- ais523

