On 7/5/26 5:27 PM, Edward Murphy via agora-discussion wrote:
I floated this idea back in October, as a variation on the Agoran't
tournament of 2023 (a sub-nomic with limited shelf life, and secret
goals to get a win in Agora proper), but this time creating a
successor to B Nomic:
https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-
discussion/2025-October/065042.html
Is there interest in doing something with this, or alternatively does
anyone else have ideas for this year's tournament? (juan had suggested
trying out a minimal initial ruleset of just 4 rules.)
To offer an alternative thought that doesn't require quite as much player
attention... a card collecting game with secret information.
Suppose we have N players. We pick a set of N things (could be elements,
countries, constellations...). Each player secretly picks one of the items
as eir private card type, and makes N commitments: N-1 along the lines of "X
is not my private card type" and one along the lines of "X is my private
card type". The N announced things are "public" card types and each player's
secret type is eir "private" card type and is referred to by the player's
name (e.g., a Mischief card). Cards are tradable.
Each round consists of two phases. The first phase is the seeding phase,
lasting [5] days, during which participating players can once do the
following set of actions (must do ALL of them):
1) seed a public card type in the deck
2) seed a private card type in the deck
3) reveal one of eir unrevealed commitments, if any remain
The second phase is the dealing phase. Whoever's running the game deals two
cards from the shuffled combined deck (private and public cards are NOT
separated) to each player who seeded it in the previous round. Generally, a
player will not get the same card types e seeded, but it could happen. Once
the cards are dealt, it's back to the seeding phase (and the deck is empty,
so only future seeding actions matter for future deals).
A player wins by paying a fee consisting of one card of each item and
revealing any of eir unrevealed commitments. Private cards count as whatever
the respective player initially committed to; private cards that haven't
been conclusively revealed by the player need to be identified by the
purported winner. (For example, if I use a Janet card in my set and Janet
hasn't revealed eir "Yes, it's the whatever" commitment, I need to identify
what I think it is.)
Things that disqualify you from winning:
* falsely claiming a win, including misidentifying unrevealed private cards
-- even if the correct identifications would have still been a valid set
(e.g., if I try to win with a Janet card and a snail card and I state their
correct values reversed, I still have failed). Another player can reveal a
commitment within [7] days to expose an incorrect identification.
* incorrectly committing (e.g., if a player committed to N negative statements)
--
Mischief
Collar, Collector, Executor
Hat: steampunk hat