What is popularity? Is it supposed to be the same for both?

--
4st
putting jesters cap back on, it fell off while mobile


On Sun, Aug 30, 2026, 11:04 AM Janet Cobb via agora-official <
[email protected]> wrote:

> RESOLUTION OF PROPOSALS 9373-9374
> =================================
>
> ID    Title                   Result
> -------------------------------------
> 9373  Dim Prospects v1.1      ADOPTED
> 9374  Tying Up White Ribbons  ADOPTED
>
> I hereby resolve the Agoran decisions to adopt the below proposals.
>
> The quorum for all below decisions was 7.
>
> VOTING STRENGTHS
> ================
>
> Strength is 3 unless otherwise noted.
> #: player has voting strength 3
> $: player has voting strength 4
> %: player has voting strength 5
> ^: player has voting strength 6
>
> PROPOSALS
> =========
>
> PROPOSAL 9373 (Dim Prospects v1.1)
> AUTHOR: Mischief
> CLASS: ORDINARY
> FOR (5): Galle, Mischief^, juan%, msh210, snail%
> AGAINST (0):
> PRESENT (2): Janet^, Murphy^
> BALLOTS: 7
> AI (F/A): 22/0 (AI=1.5)
> POPULARITY: 0.714
> OUTCOME: ADOPTED
>
> PROPOSAL 9374 (Tying Up White Ribbons)
> AUTHOR: Galle
> CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
> FOR (6): Galle, Janet, Mischief, Murphy, juan, snail
> AGAINST (1): 4st
> PRESENT (0):
> BALLOTS: 7
> AI (F/A): 18/3 (AI=3.0)
> POPULARITY: 0.714
> OUTCOME: ADOPTED
>
> The full text of each ADOPTED proposal is included below:
>
> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
> ID: 9373
> Title: Dim Prospects v1.1
> Adoption index: 1.5
> Author: Mischief
> Co-authors: snail
>
>
> [Adding new terms to make the various antecedants more obvious. The one
> in the current third bullet is borderline ambiguous, for example; the
> intent -- I think -- is to refer to the winning player but it could get
> misread as referring to "each other player" in the prior bullet. This
> should also reduce the risk of a subsequent amendment breaking an
> antecedant somewhere. Additionally, changes a singular "their" to "eir"
> in the fifth bullet.]
>
> Amend rule 2711 (Outshining the Sun) by replacing the text reading:
>
>        When a player Outshines the Sun, e wins the game. When a player
>        wins the game this way, the following happen in order:
>
>        * Eir radiance is set to 0.
>
>        * The radiance of each other player is set to half its current
>          value (rounded down).
>
>        * All Pyrite in eir possession is destroyed.
>
>        * Half of all Pyrite in each other player's possession, rounded
>          up, is destroyed.
>
>        * For each player with more than 4000 Pyrite, all but 4000 Pyrite
>          in their possession is destroyed.
>
>        * The Fields Wither.
>
>        * All Hectares are destroyed.
>
>        * Each player is granted 16 Hectares.
>
> with:
>
>        When a pure player Outshines the Sun, the following happen in
>        order:
>
>        * That player (the Luminary) wins the game.
>
>        * The Luminary's radiance is set to 0.
>
>        * The radiance of each other player (each: a Dim One) is set to
>          half its current value (rounded down).
>
>        * All Pyrite in the Luminary's possession is destroyed.
>
>        * Half of all Pyrite in each Dim One's possession, rounded up, is
>          destroyed.
>
>        * For each player with more than 4000 Pyrite, all but 4000 Pyrite
>          in eir possession is destroyed.
>
>        * The Fields Wither.
>
>        * All Hectares are destroyed.
>
>        * Each player is granted 16 Hectares.
>
> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
> ID: 9374
> Title: Tying Up White Ribbons
> Adoption index: 3.0
> Author: Galle
> Co-authors:
>
>
> Amend Rule 2438 ("Ribbons") by replacing the following text:
> ---
> White (W): A player qualifies for a White Ribbon if e has never
> previously owned a White Ribbon (including under previous rulesets). A
> player who has been registered for the past 30+ days or 180+ cumulative
> days and has never acted on eir own behalf to cause another person to
> gain a White Ribbon (including under a previous ruleset) CAN act on eir
> own behalf to cause another person to earn a White Ribbon by announcement.
> ---
>
> With the following text:
> ---
> White (W): A player qualifies for a White Ribbon if e has never
> previously owned a White Ribbon (including under previous rulesets). A
> player who has been registered for the past 30+ days or 180+ cumulative
> days and has never acted on eir own behalf to cause another person to
> earn or gain a White Ribbon (including under a previous ruleset) CAN act
> on eir own behalf to cause another person to earn a White Ribbon by
> announcement.
> ---
>
> [The current version of White Ribbons has a possible loophole: players
> "gift" White Ribbons by causing other players to EARN White Ribbons, and
> then in response Rule 2438 itself causes the earning player to GAIN a
> White Ribbon. However, the "you can only do this once" clause only
> checks to see if the player has previously directly caused another
> player to gain a White Ribbon. You could argue that the current
> mechanism counts, because there's a clear chain of causality from
> earning to gaining, but given the technical nature of the language here
> I think there's definitely a case to be made that the blocking clause
> simply doesn't work as-is. The "gain" wording is kept in to make sure
> everyone who was already blocked is still blocked.]
>
> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>

Reply via email to