On 9/7/26 11:53, Mischief via agora-discussion wrote:
> On 9/6/26 6:07 PM, Mischief via agora-business wrote:
>> I vote as follows:
>>
>>> 9375*      pizza723       3.0    Acyclic Voting
>> AGAINST. I don't think this fully solves the problem, as two or more players 
>> can still use the same trick.
> Thinking about it more, I wonder if it the fix is as simple as changing 
> "evaluates to a valid vote" in R2127 to "evaluates to a unconditional valid 
> vote" (which makes it agnostic as to the length of the cycle). Thoughts?
>

I would read "evaluate" there to only consider the first step, rather
than the whole chain of evaluation.

A proto:

Title: Determinate conditionals
Adoption index: 3.0
Author: Janet
Coauthors:

{

Amend Rule 2127 by replacing the first paragraph with the following:

{

A conditional vote on an Agoran decision is a vote which indicates a
vote based on some condition(s). The indicated vote is determined at the
end of the voting period. The conditional vote evaluates to what the
indicated vote evaluates to. (A valid unconditional vote evaluates to
itself.) If a conditional vote evaluates to a single determinate,
unconditional, and valid vote, it is counted as that vote; otherwise, it
is counted as PRESENT.

}

}

-- 
Janet Cobb

Assessor, Rulekeepor

Reply via email to