On Mon, 2026-09-07 at 15:35 -0400, Janet Cobb via agora-business wrote:
> I submit the following proposal:
> 
> Title: Numerical planting
> Adoption index: 1.0
> Author: Janet
> Coauthors:
> 
> {
> 
> Amend Rule 2714 by replacing "25 radiance" with "2000 pyrite".
> 
> [We've had several radiance wins involving number cards recently. It
> seems like we're handing these out too quickly, and this is the obvious
> place to reduce their impact.]
> 
> }

I agree that this reward is probably too high. However, it's making me
think that radiance may be more generally broken: individual players
are getting radiance wins at reasonable rates, but there isn't the sort
of competition that may have been envisaged in the radiance system
(rather, players wait until nobody else is actively attempting radiance
wins before aiming for their own, so only a very small amount of
radiance is lost to halving).

It's also the case that we've been adding more mechanisms to gain
radiance recently without raising the target to compensate, which may
mean the wins are going too quickly. (On the other hand, Stamps used to
be a very good source of radiance, but are less so nowadays, so the
number cards may just be filling in that gap.)

A few years ago, I argued that radiance wins by one player should not
make it more difficult for other players to win. I still think that
that sort of "non-competitive" radiance would be a good idea because it
would mean that we could make such wins more difficult without breaking
things.

I also note that the overall rate of wins at Agora recently has been
reasonable, and about what I would expect: it's just that they've
nearly all been radiance-based.

A mechanic from the past that might help here: instead of having just
one type of score (like radiance is at the moment), have two, and
require scoring well on both in order to achieve victory. This helps to
prevent any single scoring category dominating high-score wins.

-- 
ais523

Reply via email to