RESOLUTION OF PROPOSALS 8478-8487
=================================
ID Title Result
----------------------------------------------------
8478 another talismans fix ADOPTED
8479 Competitive Finger Pointing v2 ADOPTED
8480 Generic welcome package fix ADOPTED
8481 If it's not pending we don't care v2 REJECTED
8482 Offices are complex v2 ADOPTED
8483 a minor adjustment ADOPTED
8484 Clarify asset ownership ADOPTED
8485 Eternal Personhood ADOPTED
8486 Fee-based de-escalation ADOPTED
8487 Simpler ribbon switches ADOPTED
I hereby resolve the Agoran decisions to adopt the below proposals.
The quorum for all below decisions was 6.
VOTING STRENGTHS
================
Strength is 3 unless otherwise noted.
~: player has voting strength 0
@: player has voting strength 2
$: player has voting strength 4
%: player has voting strength 5
^: player has voting strength 6
&: player has voting strength 7
*: player has voting strength 8
=: player has voting strength 10
PROPOSALS
=========
PROPOSAL 8478 (another talismans fix)
AUTHOR: Jason
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
SPONSORED: YES
FOR (9): Aris, Cuddle Beam, Falsifian, Gaelan@, Jason$, Murphy, Publius
Scribonius Scholasticus, Trigon, nix
AGAINST (0):
PRESENT (1): R. Lee~
BALLOTS: 10
AI (F/A): 27/0 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.900
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
PROPOSAL 8479 (Competitive Finger Pointing v2)
AUTHOR: nix
CLASS: ORDINARY
CHAMBER: JUSTICE
SPONSORED: YES
FOR (7): Aris, Cuddle Beam, Falsifian, Gaelan@, Murphy, Publius Scribonius
Scholasticus%, nix%
AGAINST (0):
PRESENT (3): Jason^, R. Lee~, Trigon
BALLOTS: 10
AI (F/A): 24/0 (AI=1.7)
POPULARITY: 0.700
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
PROPOSAL 8480 (Generic welcome package fix)
AUTHOR: Jason
CLASS: ORDINARY
CHAMBER: ECONOMY
SPONSORED: YES
FOR (9): Aris, Cuddle Beam, Falsifian, Gaelan@, Jason^, Murphy, Publius
Scribonius Scholasticus, Trigon&, nix%
AGAINST (0):
PRESENT (1): R. Lee~
BALLOTS: 10
AI (F/A): 35/0 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 0.900
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
PROPOSAL 8481 (If it's not pending we don't care v2)
AUTHOR: Trigon
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
SPONSORED: YES
FOR (4): Cuddle Beam, Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus, nix
AGAINST (5): Aris, Falsifian, Gaelan@, Jason$, Trigon
PRESENT (1): R. Lee~
BALLOTS: 10
AI (F/A): 12/15 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: -0.100
OUTCOME: REJECTED
[
Falsifian: Endorsement of Aris
Jason: Endorsement of Aris
Trigon: Endorsement of Aris
]
PROPOSAL 8482 (Offices are complex v2)
AUTHOR: Trigon
CLASS: ORDINARY
CHAMBER: EFFICIENCY
SPONSORED: YES
FOR (9): Aris, Cuddle Beam, Falsifian%, Gaelan@, Jason*, Murphy%, Publius
Scribonius Scholasticus, Trigon, nix%
AGAINST (0):
PRESENT (1): R. Lee~
BALLOTS: 10
AI (F/A): 37/0 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 0.900
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
PROPOSAL 8483 (a minor adjustment)
AUTHOR: G.
CLASS: ORDINARY
CHAMBER: LEGISLATION
SPONSORED: YES
FOR (13): Aris%, Cuddle Beam, Falsifian, G., Gaelan@, Jason=, Murphy, Publius
Scribonius Scholasticus, R. Lee~, Trigon, nix%, omd, twg
AGAINST (0):
PRESENT (0):
BALLOTS: 13
AI (F/A): 46/0 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 1.000
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Falsifian: Conditional resolved: P8483 would be ADOPTED even if all parties to
the Foot Draggers Union voted AGAINST
Gaelan: Conditional resolved: P8483 would be ADOPTED under the specified
criteria, with at most omd voting AGAINST
omd: Conditional resolved: Gaelan did not cast a ballot matching the specified
criteria
]
PROPOSAL 8484 (Clarify asset ownership)
AUTHOR: Murphy
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
SPONSORED: YES
FOR (6): Aris, Cuddle Beam, Falsifian, Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus,
nix
AGAINST (1): Gaelan@
PRESENT (3): Jason$, R. Lee~, Trigon
BALLOTS: 10
AI (F/A): 18/2 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.500
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
PROPOSAL 8485 (Eternal Personhood)
AUTHOR: Gaelan
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
SPONSORED: YES
FOR (9): Aris, Cuddle Beam, Falsifian, Gaelan@, Jason$, Murphy, Publius
Scribonius Scholasticus, Trigon, nix
AGAINST (0):
PRESENT (1): R. Lee~
BALLOTS: 10
AI (F/A): 27/0 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.900
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
PROPOSAL 8486 (Fee-based de-escalation)
AUTHOR: Jason
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
SPONSORED: NO
FOR (8): Aris, Cuddle Beam, Falsifian, Gaelan@, Jason$, Publius Scribonius
Scholasticus, Trigon, nix
AGAINST (1): Murphy
PRESENT (1): R. Lee~
BALLOTS: 10
AI (F/A): 24/3 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.700
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
PROPOSAL 8487 (Simpler ribbon switches)
AUTHOR: Murphy
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
SPONSORED: YES
FOR (8): Aris, Cuddle Beam, Falsifian, Gaelan@, Jason$, Murphy, Publius
Scribonius Scholasticus, nix
AGAINST (0):
PRESENT (2): R. Lee~, Trigon
BALLOTS: 10
AI (F/A): 24/0 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.800
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Jason: Endorsement of Publius Scribonius Scholasticus
]
The full text of each ADOPTED proposal is included below:
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 8478
Title: another talismans fix
Adoption index: 3.0
Author: Jason
Co-authors: nix, G.
Amend Rule 2574 by replacing the list item beginning "If a player
possesses more than one" with the following:
{
- If a player possesses more than one talisman for persons other than
emself, specify and transfer one of those talismans to Agora;
}
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 8479
Title: Competitive Finger Pointing v2
Adoption index: 1.7
Author: nix
Co-authors: Aris, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus, ATMunn
Amend R2478, "Vigilante Justice" by adding to the beginning of the
list:
- Issuing a Warning to the perp, as described elsewhere;
and by adding after the list items:
Initiating a Finger Pointing found to be Shenanigans is ILLEGAL
and the Class 0+N Crime of Unjustified Gesticulation, where N is
the number of times e has previously committed the crime in the
current Agoran Week.
and by adding, to the very end of the rule:
The player who initiated the most Finger Pointings that resulted
in a Warning, Indictment, or Cold Hand of Justice in the previous
Agoran Week CAN once grant emself a Justice Card by announcement.
Amend R2557 "Sentencing Guidelines" by adding to the end:
When the rules authorize an investigator to issue a Warning for a
violation, e CAN do so by announcement if the violation is
described by the rules as a "Class N Crime" where N is 0 or an
expression that evaluates to 0.
[There is no ruleset support for class 0 crimes right now. So this
version adds support by introducing a new thing the investigator can do
called a Warning.]
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 8480
Title: Generic welcome package fix
Adoption index: 1.0
Author: Jason
Co-authors:
Amend Rule 2499 by deleting the sentence beginning "A player CANNOT" and
by replacing the final paragraph with the following:
{
When a player receives a Welcome Package, if e has not received one in
the past 30 days, then e earns 10 coins and one of each type of Card
defined in the rules.
}
[This makes protects against all possible infinite welcome package scams
that involve one person receiving infinite welcome packages. With this
change, a person can get infinite welcome packages, but only the first
one in each 30 day period will actually grant any rewards (which likely
makes most scams not worth the hassle).]
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 8482
Title: Offices are complex v2
Adoption index: 1.0
Author: Trigon
Co-authors: ATMunn
Enact a new power-1 rule entitled "Complexity" with the text:
Complexity is an office switch reflecting how complex it is to
fulfill the duties of its office. Its possible values are all
integers from 0 to 3 inclusive, where 1 is the default. It is
tracked in the ADoP's weekly report. The ADoP CAN, with 2 Agoran
consent, flip the complexity of an office.
Set the complexity switch of the following offices as such:
ADoP: 1
Arbitor: 2 [comment: if we split CotC this should go down]
Assessor: 3
Coopor: 1
Distributor: 0
Herald: 2
Notary: 2
Prime Minister: 0
Promotor: 3
Referee: 2
Registrar: 1
Rulekeepor: 3
Speaker: 0
Tailor: 1
Treasuror: 3
Webmastor: 1
Amend Rule 2496 "Rewards" by replacing the text "5 coins" in the
following bullet points as such:
- the bullet point beginning "Publishing an office's weekly or monthly
report": 5 coins times the complexity of the office
- the bullet point beginning "Resolving a referendum": 5 coins times
the Assessor's complexity.
- the bullet point beginning "Initiating a referendum", if it exists: 5
coins times the Promotor's complexity.
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 8483
Title: a minor adjustment
Adoption index: 1.0
Author: G.
Co-authors:
If G., acting as emself, has published a single body of text clearly
labeled as "THE MYSTERY DOCUMENT" after the voting period on the
referendum for this proposal has began, this proposal applies all effects
specified in that body of text.
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 8484
Title: Clarify asset ownership
Adoption index: 3.0
Author: Murphy
Co-authors: Cuddle Beam, Aris
Amend Rule 2576 (Ownership) to read:
Each asset has exactly one owner.
If ownership of an asset is restricted to a class of entities,
then that asset CANNOT be gained by or transferred to an entity
outside that class. By default, ownership of an asset is
restricted to Agora, players, and contracts, but an asset's
backing document may modify this.
If an asset's owner would otherwise be nonexistent, indeterminate,
or invalid, then it is owned by the Lost and Found Department (if
possible) or destroyed (otherwise), subject to modification by its
backing document. Rules to the contrary notwithstanding, the Lost
and Found Department can own assets of every type. Assets owned by
the Lost and Found Department can be transferred or destroyed by
any player without objection.
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 8485
Title: Eternal Personhood
Adoption index: 3.0
Author: Gaelan
Co-authors: Aris
In rule 869 "How to Join and Leave Agora", replace
{Any organism that is generally capable of freely originating and
communicating independent thoughts and ideas is a person.}
with
{Any entity that is or ever was an organism generally capable of freely
originating and communicating independent thoughts and ideas is a person.}
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 8486
Title: Fee-based de-escalation
Adoption index: 3.0
Author: Jason
Co-authors: omd
Amend Rule 2579 by replacing the final paragraph with the following: {
If a Rule purports to provide a fee-based method to perform an action
with a fee of no assets, that Rule enables the performance of the action
by announcement. When using such a method, the actor SHOULD announce
that there was a 0 or empty fee.
}
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 8487
Title: Simpler ribbon switches
Adoption index: 3.0
Author: Murphy
Co-authors: R. Lee
Amend Rule 2438 (Ribbons) by replacing this text:
Ribbon Ownership is a secured person switch, tracked by the
Tailor in eir monthly report, whose values are the subsets of
the set of types of Ribbon, defaulting to the empty set. If the
rules are amended to change the types of Ribbon, if a player's
Ribbon Ownership is subsequently illegal, then it is updated by
removing all nonexistent types rather than resetting the entire
value to default.
To "award a person a <Ribbon type>" is to add that type of Ribbon
to that person's Ribbon Ownership. A person "owns a <Ribbon type>"
if that type of Ribbon is an element of eir Ribbon Ownership.
with this text:
For each type of Ribbon, <type> Ribbon Ownership is a secured
negative boolean person switch, tracked by the Tailor in eir
monthly report.
To "award a person a <Ribbon type>" is to flip that person's
<that type> Ribbon Ownership to True. A person "owns a <Ribbon
type>" if eir <that type> Ribbon Ownership is True.
and by replacing this text:
While a person owns all types of Ribbon, that person can Raise a
Banner by announcement. This causes that person to win the game.
That person's Ribbon Ownership becomes the empty set.
with this text:
While a person owns all types of Ribbon, that person can Raise a
Banner by announcement. This causes that person to win the game.
When a person wins this way, for each type of Ribbon, that
person's <type> Ribbon Ownership is flipped to False.
For each type of Ribbon, for each person whose Ribbon Ownership prior to
the adoption of this proposal included that type, flip eir <that type>
Ribbon Ownership to True.
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
