RESOLUTION OF PROPOSALS 8837-8848
=================================
ID Title Result
--------------------------------------------------
8838 Kickstarter REJECTED
8839 Not so hard decision REJECTED
8840 Cleanliness security ADOPTED
8841 Spivak Standardization Act v2 REJECTED
8842 Losing Focus ADOPTED
8843 Time B Safe ADOPTED
8844 Fix dreams ADOPTED
8845 Onicers REJECTED
8846 The Cheepening ADOPTED
8847 Bird Powerup REJECTED
8848 Goals REJECTED
I hereby resolve the Agoran decisions to adopt the below proposals.
The quorum for all below decisions was 7.
PROPOSALS
=========
PROPOSAL 8838 (Kickstarter)
AUTHOR: Murphy
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (1): Murphy
AGAINST (3): Gaelan, Pilgore, Secretsnail9
PRESENT (3): G., Jason, ais523
BALLOTS: 7
AI (F/A): 3/9 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: -0.286
OUTCOME: REJECTED
[
Gaelan: Secretsnail9 is the Horsened: Endorsement of Secretsnail9
]
PROPOSAL 8839 (Not so hard decision)
AUTHOR: 4st
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
FOR (1): Murphy
AGAINST (6): G., Gaelan, Jason, Pilgore, Secretsnail9, ais523
PRESENT (0):
BALLOTS: 7
AI (F/A): 3/18 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: -0.714
OUTCOME: REJECTED
[
Secretsnail9: Endorsement of Jason
]
PROPOSAL 8840 (Cleanliness security)
AUTHOR: Jason
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (4): G., Gaelan, Jason, Secretsnail9
AGAINST (0):
PRESENT (3): Murphy, Pilgore, ais523
BALLOTS: 7
AI (F/A): 12/0 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.571
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Secretsnail9: Endorsement of G.
]
PROPOSAL 8841 (Spivak Standardization Act v2)
AUTHOR: Jason
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
FOR (2): Gaelan, Jason
AGAINST (2): G., R. Lee
PRESENT (4): Murphy, Pilgore, Secretsnail9, ais523
BALLOTS: 8
AI (F/A): 6/6 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.000
OUTCOME: REJECTED
[
Secretsnail9: Endorsement of Murphy
]
PROPOSAL 8842 (Losing Focus)
AUTHOR: Pilgore
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (6): G., Gaelan, Jason, Pilgore, Secretsnail9, ais523
AGAINST (0):
PRESENT (1): Murphy
BALLOTS: 7
AI (F/A): 18/0 (AI=2.0)
POPULARITY: 0.857
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
PROPOSAL 8843 (Time B Safe)
AUTHOR: G.
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
FOR (5): G., Gaelan, Jason, Murphy, ais523
AGAINST (1): Pilgore
PRESENT (1): Secretsnail9
BALLOTS: 7
AI (F/A): 15/3 (AI=4.0)
POPULARITY: 0.571
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Gaelan: Endorsement of G.
Secretsnail9: Endorsement of non-voter nix: Inextricable
]
PROPOSAL 8844 (Fix dreams)
AUTHOR: 4st
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (4): Gaelan, Murphy, Pilgore, Secretsnail9
AGAINST (1): Jason
PRESENT (2): G., ais523
BALLOTS: 7
AI (F/A): 12/3 (AI=2.0)
POPULARITY: 0.429
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
PROPOSAL 8845 (Onicers)
AUTHOR: Secretsnail9
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (3): G., Murphy, Secretsnail9
AGAINST (4): Gaelan, Jason, Pilgore, ais523
PRESENT (0):
BALLOTS: 7
AI (F/A): 9/12 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: -0.143
OUTCOME: REJECTED
PROPOSAL 8846 (The Cheepening)
AUTHOR: Secretsnail9
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (3): Gaelan, Pilgore, Secretsnail9
AGAINST (1): Jason
PRESENT (3): G., Murphy, ais523
BALLOTS: 7
AI (F/A): 9/3 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: 0.286
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
PROPOSAL 8847 (Bird Powerup)
AUTHOR: Secretsnail9
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (2): Gaelan, Secretsnail9
AGAINST (2): Jason, ais523
PRESENT (3): G., Murphy, Pilgore
BALLOTS: 7
AI (F/A): 6/6 (AI=2.0)
POPULARITY: 0.000
OUTCOME: REJECTED
PROPOSAL 8848 (Goals)
AUTHOR: 4st
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (2): G., Murphy
AGAINST (4): Jason, Pilgore, Secretsnail9, ais523
PRESENT (1): Gaelan
BALLOTS: 7
AI (F/A): 6/12 (AI=1.0)
POPULARITY: -0.286
OUTCOME: REJECTED
The full text of each ADOPTED proposal is included below:
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 8840
Title: Cleanliness security
Adoption index: 3.0
Author: Jason
Co-authors:
Amend Rule 2221 by appending the following paragraph:
{
Cleaning rules is secured. Refiling rules is secured.
}
[This is maybe arguably not necessary based on the exact wording of
R2221, but better safe than sorry.]
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 8842
Title: Losing Focus
Adoption index: 2.0
Author: Pilgore
Co-authors: nix, Jason, Madrid
Repeal R2638 (Player Focuses)
Repeal R2605 (Ministries)
Amend R2645 (The Stones) to delete the bullet point which reads:
Concentration Stone (monthly, 60%): A specified player (defaulting to the
wielder if not specified) gains the Grant associated with eir Focus.
and replace it with:
Jockey Stone (monthly, 60%): A specified Running horse's Race Position is
increased by 1.
If at the time this proposal is adopted the Concentration Stone is owned
by a player, that player becomes the owner of the Jockey Stone. Otherwise,
Agora becomes the owner of the Jockey Stone.
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 8843
Title: Time B Safe
Adoption index: 4.0
Author: G.
Co-authors: Jason, Murphy
Amend Rule 1698 (Agora Is A Nomic) by replacing:
adopted within a four-week period.
with:
adopted within a real-world (UTC) four-week period.
[
In discord, a Power-5 Rule was suggested: "Rules to the contrary
notwithstanding, this rule CANNOT be changed in January or February of
2023".
Up until the time a proposal to change this rule could take effect before
January 2023, Agora would not be ossified. But then you cross a time
boundary and Agora would become ossified. One *possible* interpretation of
> If any other single change or inseparable group of changes to the
> gamestate would cause Agora to become ossified, or would cause
> Agora to cease to exist, it is cancelled and does not occur, rules
> to the contrary notwithstanding.
is that the "cancelled change" would be time passing! With the conclusion
that time had (as a legal fiction) stopped, with no way of getting it
started again. So this proposal puts an extra protection on time by making
it clear that only "real world" time is relevant. The title a reference B
nomic, an established nomic some years back that was killed when they
accidentally stopped time or at least couldn't get it started again.
]
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 8844
Title: Fix dreams
Adoption index: 2.0
Author: 4st
Co-authors: Jason
For Rule 2675 'Dream of Wandering', change its power to 2.
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 8846
Title: The Cheepening
Adoption index: 1.0
Author: Secretsnail9
Co-authors:
Amend Rule 2661 (Permits) by replacing "A player CAN buy a beast permit by
paying a fee of 50 boatloads of coins." with "A player CAN buy a beast
permit by paying a fee of 30 boatloads of coins."
and by replacing "A player CAN renew eir beast permit by paying a fee of 25
boatloads of coins." with "A player CAN renew eir beast permit by paying a
fee of 15 boatloads of coins."
Amend Rule 2663 (Bird Migration) by replacing "A player CAN buy bird food
by paying a fee of 5 boatloads of coins." with "A player CAN buy bird food
by paying a fee of 3 boatloads of coins."
Amend Rule 2675 (Dream of Wandering) by replacing
- Dream of Beasts: E CAN buy bird food by paying a fee of 3
boatloads of coins. E CAN buy a Beast Permit by paying a fee of
40 boatloads of coins. E CAN renew a Beast Permit by paying a
fee of 20 boatloads of coins.
with
- Dream of Beasts: E CAN buy bird food by paying a fee of 2
boatloads of coins. E CAN buy a Beast Permit by paying a fee of
20 boatloads of coins. E CAN renew a Beast Permit by paying a
fee of 10 boatloads of coins.
[An effort to make birds more approachable. They always fly away when you
get too close.]
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
