I recuse Murphy from Cfj 4018 and then assign it to nix (below is for reference, and is not intended to assign to Murphy)
On Sun, Mar 19, 2023 at 10:12 AM Kerim Aydin via agora-official < agora-official@agoranomic.org> wrote: > The below CFJ is 4018. I assign it to Murphy. > > status: https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/#4018 > > =============================== CFJ 4018 =============================== > > I currently own the Radiance stone. > > ========================================================================== > > Caller: snail > Barred: Janet > > Judge: Murphy > > ========================================================================== > > History: > > Called by snail: 15 Mar 2023 03:13:52 > Assigned to Murphy: [now] > > ========================================================================== > > Caller's Arguments: > > Arguments for TRUE: > The Radiance stone is the same stone as the Score stone, just with > different attributes, and so falls under Rule 1586 (Definition and > Continuity of Entities): > > If the entity that defines another entity is amended such that it > defines the second entity both before and after the amendment, but > with different attributes, then the second entity and its > attributes continue to exist to whatever extent is possible under > the new definitions. > > > Caller's Evidence: > > From adopted proposal 8919: > > Amend R2645 by replacing: > > - Score Stone (Weekly, 3): When wielded, a specified player's > (defaulting to the wielder if not specified) Score is increased > by 3. > > with: > > - Radiance Stone (Weekly, 3): When wielded, a specified player > (defaulting to the wielder if not specified) gains 3 radiance. > > > From Rule 2645 (The Stones): > > The following stones are defined, one per paragraph, with the > following format: Stone Name (Frequency, Smoothness): Description. > > > It seems like the different attributes that were changed are just the Stone > Name and Description, and common sense indicates they're the same stone. > > ========================================================================== >
