-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Agoran Court Gazette (Arbitor's Weekly Report)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Date of this report: 2024-08-13
Date of last report: 2024-05-27
(all times UTC)
By publishing this report, I hereby assign CFJ IDs 4089 through 4093 to
the open CFJs noted below. I have not yet assigned these out of a
desire to avoid overwhelming the few current interested judges. I hope
to assign them this week once the current assigned cases are judged or
the bench expands.
RECENT JUDICIAL ASSIGNMENTS
=======================================================================
CFJ 4077 Assigned to Janet
Due 2024-08-20 02:30
CFJ 4083 Assigned to ais523
Due 2024-08-20 02:34
CFJ 4087 Assigned to Murphy
Due 2024-08-20 02:48
CFJ 4088 Assigned to Murphy
Due 2024-08-20 02:48
RIPE INTENTS
=======================================================================
CFJ 4081 Motion to Reconsider tabled by Kate
Current supporters: none
Overripe at 2024-08-26 02:24 UTC
PLAYERS INTERESTED IN JUDGING
=======================================================================
Player Last assigned case
---------------- -----------------------------------
4st never; became interested 2024-08-03
Janet 2024-08-13 (CFJ 4077)
ais523 2024-08-13 (CFJ 4083)
Murphy 2024-08-13 (CFJs 4087 and 4088)
OPEN CASES
=======================================================================
CFJ 4077: There exists a tabled immature intent, sponsored by me, to
Declare Apathy.
[2024-04-07] Called by Kate
[2024-04-07] Arguments submitted by ais523
[2024-04-07] Arguments submitted by 4st
[2024-04-10] Assigned to Gaelan
[2024-05-27] Gaelan recused by Arbitor for lateness
[2024-05-27] Assigned to kiako
[2024-08-13] kiako recused by Arbitor for lateness
[2024-08-13] Assigned to Janet
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4083: In the message quoted in evidence, 4st deputised as Geologist
to publish the Geologist's report.
[2024-05-19] Called by Murphy, barring 4st
[2024-05-27] Assigned to nix
[2024-08-13] nix recused by Arbitor for lateness
[2024-08-13] Assigned to ais523
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4087: Rule 1023 contains the text "Any anniversary."
CFJ 4088: Rule 1023 contains a list with exactly 5 list items.
[2024-06-25] Called by Janet
[2024-06-25] Arguments submitted by Mischief
[2024-06-26] Arguments submitted by ais523
[2024-06-27] Arguments submitted by Mischief
[2024-08-13] Assigned to Murphy
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4089: the appended paragraph exists in the new rule.
[2024-07-14] Called by 4st
[2024-07-14] Arguments submitted by Janet
[2024-07-14] Arguments submitted by Mischief
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4090: I have at least one ownership of the Veblen, since I "gains
ownership of the Veblen".
[2024-07-24] Called by 4st
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4091: I currently have 5 spendies.
[2024-07-24] Called by 4st
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4092: Janet is the Prime Minister.
[2024-07-24] Called by Kate
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4093: the current match state is none
[2024-07-25] Called by Mischief
[2024-07-28] Arguments submitted by Murphy
[2024-07-28] Arguments submitted by ais523
JUDGED CASES (since last CotC update)
=======================================================================
CFJ 4050: ais523 now owns 2 4st stamps.
[2023-10-05] Called by 4st
[2023-10-06] Assigned to Janet
[2023-10-13] Judged FALSE by Janet
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4053: nix is a player.
[2023-10-13] Called by Kate
[2023-10-13] Assigned to 4st
[2023-10-13] Judged TRUE by 4st
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4052: ais523 has 33 ais523 stamps.
[2023-10-09] Called by 4st
[2023-10-09] Assigned to Murphy
[2023-10-15] Judged TRUE by Murphy
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4051: Murphy has 67 points.
[2023-10-05] Called by 4st
[2023-10-06] Assigned to snail
[2023-10-20] Judged TRUE by snail
[2023-10-20] Motion to Reconsider self-filed by snail
[2023-10-20] Judged FALSE by snail
[2023-11-13] Moot tabled by nix
[2023-11-13] Moot tabled by nix
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4060: At the moment I called this CFJ, there exists a valid ballot
submitted by me FOR proposal 9038.
[2023-11-27] Called by Gaelan
[2023-11-28] Assigned to 4st
[2023-12-04] Judged FALSE by 4st
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4055: agorano...@groups.io and m...@agoranomic.groups.io are the
same forum (and thus share a single Publicity switch between
them).
[2023-10-31] Called by ais523
[2024-03-07] Self-assigned by kiako
[2024-03-07] Judged TRUE by kiako
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4064: Goren has created a contract in that message which grants
Yachay some sort of agency over their Stamps.
[2024-03-04] Called by Yachay Wayllukuq
[2024-03-09] Assigned to nix
[2024-03-09] Judged FALSE by nix
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4065: Does "granting" an asset cause it to be received?
[2024-03-05] Called by LegallyBearded
[2024-03-05] Arguments submitted by nix
[2024-03-05] Arguments submitted by Gaelan
[2024-03-05] Arguments submitted by ais523
[2024-03-05] Arguments submitted by LegallyBearded
[2024-03-09] Assigned to 4st
[2024-03-09] Judged DISMISS by 4st
[2024-03-09] Arguments submitted by 4st
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4061: The office of Prime Minister is vacant.
[2024-01-01] Called by Gaelan
[2024-01-01] Arguments submitted by ais523
[2024-03-09] Assigned to nix
[2024-03-09] Arguments submitted by ais523
[2024-03-10] Judged FALSE by nix
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4068: snail was granted a stamp in this message.
[2024-03-10] Called by snail
[2024-03-10] Assigned to ais523
[2024-03-10] Arguments submitted by nix
[2024-03-12] Judged FALSE by ais523
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4071: The quotes message contains at least one game action.
[2024-03-11] Called by nix
[2024-03-11] Arguments submitted by Janet
[2024-03-11] Assigned to ais523
[2024-03-12] Judged DISMISS by ais523
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4066: In the above message, LegallyBearded successfully granted
emself 52 welcome packages.
[2024-03-05] Called by Aris, barring LegallyBearded
[2024-03-05] Favoured by Yachay Wayllukuq
[2024-03-05] Arguments submitted by nix
[2024-03-09] Assigned to Yachay Wayllukuq
[2024-03-12] Judged FALSE by Yachay Wayllukuq
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4067: LegallyBearded has successfully called a CFJ with
substantially the text 'Does "granting" an asset cause it to
be received?'.
[2024-03-05] Called by Aris, barring LegallyBearded
[2024-03-09] Assigned to kiako
[2024-03-14] Judged FALSE by kiako
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4054: It is generally POSSIBLE to alter the holder of the office of
Distributor without objection.
[2023-08-25] Called by Kate
[2023-08-25] Arguments submitted by Gaelan
[2023-08-25] Arguments submitted by Janet
[2024-03-09] Assigned to kiako
[2024-03-14] Judged FALSE by kiako
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4072: There exists an entity that is a Rule with ID number 2687.
[2024-03-12] Called by Janet
[2024-03-12] Assigned to nix
[2023-03-12] Arguments submitted by Gaelan
[2023-03-12] Arguments submitted by snail
[2024-03-16] Judged TRUE by nix
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4074: Agora owns at least 1 stamp
[2024-03-17] Called by nix
[2024-03-17] Assigned to kiako
[2024-03-17] Arguments submitted by Janet
[2024-03-17] Judged TRUE by kiako
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4059: As a result of the 2023 Agoran't Birthday Tournament, Murphy
won the game.
[2023-11-19] Called by snail
[2024-03-09] Assigned to Murphy
[2024-03-17] Judged FALSE by Murphy
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4062: Proposal 9051, as part of its effect, applied a rule change.
[2024-01-28] Called by Janet
[2024-02-15] Arguments submitted by 4st
[2024-02-15] Arguments submitted by Janet
[2024-03-09] Assigned to Gaelan
[2024-03-16] Motion to Extend filed by Gaelan
[2024-03-17] Judged FALSE by Gaelan
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4058: As a result of the 2023 Agoran't Birthday Tournament, snail
won the game.
[2023-11-19] Called by snail
[2024-03-09] Assigned to Janet
[2024-03-17] Motion to Extend filed by Janet
[2024-03-23] Judged TRUE by Janet
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4070: This CFJ exists.
[2024-03-11] Called by nix
[2024-03-11] Assigned to snail
[2024-03-25] snail recused by Arbitor due to lateness.
[2024-03-25] Assigned to nix
[2024-03-25] Judged DISMISS by nix
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4057: As a result of the 2023 Agoran't Birthday Tournament, Kate
and Janet won the game.
[2023-11-19] Called by snail
[2024-03-09] Assigned to ais523
[2024-03-09] ais523 recused
[2024-03-10] Assigned to Kate
[2024-03-16] Motion to Extend filed by Kate
[2024-03-23] Kate recused
[2024-03-25] Assigned to Janet
[2024-03-29] Judged TRUE by Janet
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4069: There exists a Rule 105.
[2024-03-11] Called by Gaelan
[2024-03-11] Assigned to 4st
[2024-03-16] Judged TRUE by 4st
[2024-03-18] Motion to Reconsider tabled by Janet
[2024-03-18] Motion to Reconsider supported by Aris
[2024-03-18] Arguments submitted by Janet
[2024-03-18] Motion to Reconsider supported and group-filed by R. Lee
[2024-03-20] 4st recused
[2024-03-25] Assigned to ais523
[2024-03-30] Judged TRUE by ais523
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4056: Agoran't is ossified.
[2023-11-09] Called by snail
[2024-03-09] Assigned to Yachay Wayllukuq
[2024-03-12] Yachay Wayllukuq recused
[2024-03-16] Assigned to Gaelan
[2024-03-18] Arguments submitted by Janet
[2024-03-20] Arguments submitted by Janet
[2024-04-01] Gaelan recused by Arbitor for lateness
[2024-04-01] Assigned to Janet
[2024-04-01] Judged FALSE by Janet
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4063: Proposal 9055, as part of its effect, enacted a rule.
[2024-02-11] Called by Janet
[2024-02-11] Arguments submitted by ais523
[2024-03-09] Assigned to Kate
[2024-03-16] Motion to Extend filed by Kate
[2024-03-23] Kate recused
[2024-03-25] Assigned to Murphy
[2024-03-31] Judged TRUE by Murphy
[2024-03-01] Arguments submitted by Janet
[2024-04-04] Motion to Reconsider self-filed by Murphy
[2024-04-04] Judged FALSE by Murphy
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
-
CFJ 4078: Rule 2642 has been repealed.
[2024-04-10] Called by nix
[2024-04-10] Assigned to snail
[2024-04-11] Arguments submitted by Janet
[2024-04-13] Judged FALSE by snail
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4073: The quoted message contains a game action.
[2024-03-12] Called by snail
[2024-03-12] Arguments submitted by Janet
[2024-03-12] Arguments submitted by ais523
[2024-03-12] Arguments submitted by 4st
[2024-03-16] Assigned to Yachay Wayllukuq
[2024-03-19] Judged TRUE by Yachay Wayllukuq
[2024-03-19] Motion to Reconsider self-filed by Yachay Wayllukuq
[2024-03-19] Arguments submitted by Aris
[2024-04-23] Yachay Wayllukuq recused by Arbitor for lateness
[2024-04-23] Assigned to ais523
[2024-04-28] Judged DISMISS by ais523
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4075: Yachay CAN cash Promise Q, either by directly cashing it, or
by transferring it from the Library to emself and then
cashing it.
CFJ 4076: I CAN cash the promise 'Awakening'.
[2024-04-07] Called by ais523, linked
[2024-04-07] Arguments submitted by Gaelan
[2024-04-07] Arguments submitted by ais523
[2024-04-07] Arguments submitted by Kate
[2024-04-07] Arguments submitted by ais523
[2024-04-07] Arguments submitted by 4st
[2024-04-10] Assigned to kiako
[2024-04-23] kiako recused
[2024-04-23] Assigned to Murphy
[2024-04-28] Judged PARADOXICAL by Murphy
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4084: Agora is a game of nomic
[2024-05-27] Called by Yachay Wayllukuq, barring 4st
[2024-05-27] Assigned to nix
[2024-05-27] Judged IRRELEVANT by nix
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4085: The CFJ above bars the player currently named 'apathy'
[2024-05-27] Called by Yachay Wayllukuq
[2024-05-27] Assigned to ais523
[2024-05-27] Arguments submitted by nix
[2024-05-27] Arguments submitted by Mischief
[2024-06-02] Judged DISMISS by ais523
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4082: This action failed.
[2024-05-15] Called by wunst
[2024-05-27] Assigned to ais523
[2024-06-02] Judged TRUE by ais523
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4079: I own the Power Stone.
[2024-05-05] Called by ais523
[2024-05-27] Assigned to Murphy
[2024-06-02] Judged FALSE by Murphy
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4080: Elysion is a fugitive of the old law
CFJ 4081: Elysion is still a fugitive of the old law
[2024-05-13] Called by Mischief
[2024-05-18] Arguments submitted by Janet
[2024-05-18] Arguments submitted by juan
[2024-05-18] Arguments submitted by Mischief
[2024-05-19] Arguments submitted by ais523
[2024-05-27] Assigned to snail
[2024-08-12] Judged TRUE by snail
[2024-08-13] Motion to Reconsider CFJ 4081 tabled by Kate
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
CFJ 4086: snail won by noticing the rock garden in the past 30 days.
[2024-06-15] Called by snail
[2024-06-15] Arguments submitted by Janet
[2024-08-13] Assigned to Kate
[2024-08-13] Judged FALSE by Kate
