I don't have access to the article, unfortunately, but here's the news
article (below) that came out after the report.

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Blain Anderson
Biologist - GIS Specialist
National Park Service
240 West 5th Avenue
Anchorage, Alaska  99501
907.644.3577
` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` `


             Roundup Highly Lethal to

           Amphibians in Natural Setting,

           Finds University of Pittsburgh

                     Researcher

          Some species totally eliminated

         PITTSBURGHâThe herbicide RoundupÂ

         is widely used to eradicate weeds.

         But a study published today by a

         University of Pittsburgh

         researcher finds that the chemical

         may be eradicating much more than

         that.


         Pitt assistant professor of

         biology Rick Relyea found that

         RoundupÂ, the second most commonly

         applied herbicide in the United

         States, is âextremely lethalâ to

         amphibians. This field experiment

         is one of the most extensive

         studies on the effects of

         pesticides on nontarget organisms

         in a natural setting, and the

         results may provide a key link to

         global amphibian declines.


         In a paper titled âThe Impact of

         Insecticides and Herbicides on the

         Biodiversity and Productivity of

         Aquatic Communities,â published in

         the journal Ecological

         Applications, Relyea examined how

         a pondâs entire communityâ25

         species, including crustaceans,

         insects, snails, and

         tadpolesâresponded to the addition

         of the manufacturersâ recommended

         doses of two insecticidesâSevinÂ

         (carbaryl) and malathionâand two

         herbicidesâRoundup (glyphosate)

         and 2,4-D.


         Relyea found that Roundup caused

         a 70 percent decline in amphibian

         biodiversity and an 86 percent

         decline in the total mass of

         tadpoles. Leopard frog tadpoles

         and gray tree frog tadpoles were

         completely eliminated and wood

         frog tadpoles and toad tadpoles

         were nearly eliminated. One

         species of frog, spring peepers,

         was unaffected.


         âThe most shocking insight coming

         out of this was that RoundupÂ,

         something designed to kill plants,

         was extremely lethal to

         amphibians,â said Relyea, who

         conducted the research at Pittâs

         Pymatuning Laboratory of Ecology.

         âWe added RoundupÂ, and the next

         day we looked in the tanks and

         there were dead tadpoles all over

         the bottom.â


         Relyea initially conducted the

         experiment to see whether the

         Roundup would have an indirect

         effect on the frogs by killing

         their food source, the algae.

         However, he found that RoundupÂ,

         although an herbicide, actually

         increased the amount of algae in

         the pond because it killed most of

         the frogs.


         âItâs like killing all the cows in

         a field and seeing that the field

         has more grass in itânot because

         you made the grass grow better,

         but because you killed everything

         that eats grass,â he said.


         Previous research had found that

         the lethal ingredient in RoundupÂ

         was not the herbicide itself,

         glyphosate, but rather the

         surfactant, or detergent, that

         allows the herbicide to penetrate

         the waxy surfaces of plants. In

         RoundupÂ, that surfactant is a

         chemical called polyethoxylated

         tallowamine. Other herbicides have

         less dangerous surfactants: For

         example, Relyeaâs study found that

         2,4-D had no effect on tadpoles.


         âWeâve repeated the experiment, so

         weâre confident that this is, in

         fact, a repeatable result that we

         see,â said Relyea. âItâs fair to

         say that nobody would have guessed

         Roundup was going to be so lethal

         to amphibians.â

_______________________________________________
CNIPM-L mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://lists.uaf.edu:8025/mailman/listinfo/cnipm-l



                                                                                
                                             
                      [EMAIL PROTECTED]                                         
                                             
                      .gov                     To:       [EMAIL PROTECTED]      
                                        
                                               cc:                              
                                             
                      04/11/2005 02:46         Subject:  Re: [akherps] FYI: 
Article on Roundup and toxicity if applied       
                      PM PST                    directly to water.              
                                             
                                                                                
                                             





Thanks for sending this Blain.  i have forwarded this to folks @ SEACC
working on the pesticide forestry issue here.  Do you have access to the
full journal paper?

thanks!
-ddr
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Deborah D. Rudis
Environmental Contaminants Biologist
US Fish & Wildlife Service
Ecological Services Field Office
3000 Vintage Blvd. #201
Juneau, Alaska  99801

907/780-1183   fax 907/586-7154
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
'When one tugs at a single thing in nature, he finds it attached to the
rest of the world.'   John Muir

                                                                           
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]                                                    
 Sent by:                                                                  
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]                                                To 
 rg                                [email protected]                     
                                                                        cc 
                                                                           
 04/11/2005 08:16 AM                                               Subject 
                                   [akherps] FYI: Article on Roundup and   
                                   toxicity if applied directly to water.  
    Please respond to                                                      
   [email protected]                                                     
                                                                           
                                                                           
                                                                           
                                                                           
                                                                           





THE IMPACT OF INSECTICIDES AND HERBICIDES ON THE BIODIVERSITY AND
PRODUCTIVITY OF AQUATIC COMMUNITIES

                           By Rick A. Relyeaa,
                   Department of Biological Sciences,
                             101 Clapp Hall,
                        University of Pittsburgh,
                        Pittsburgh, PA 15260 USA

The full abstract can be found at:
http://www.esajournals.org/esaonline/?request=get-abstract&issn=1051-0761&volume=15&issue=2&page=618


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Here's a reply from a couple of individuals (credentials and affiliations
unknown) to this article:

Re: New study on Glyphosate toxicity (Global, Planet Earth)
From: Debra Nelson ([EMAIL PROTECTED])

(Debra forwarded an email with contributions from various weed scientists,
commenting on a recent study by a University of Pittsburgh biologist Rick
Relyea who found that applying RoundUp to a tank containing amphibians
killed them.)

Robert Szafoni noted: "It was very gratifying to see so many folks respond
to this with the correct observation that the researcher tested a herbicide
in a manner for which it is not listed - Round-up over water.  The study
even noted that the surfactant was far more lethal to the amphibians than
the active ingredient. This is the second time in the last two years that a
"new" study showed herbicide impacts to amphibs by testing products in an
inappropriate manner. Bottom line...read and follow the label."

Debra Nelson noted: "There is good reason to be sure you use the "aquatic
approved" version of herbicides when applying around water!"

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Blain Anderson
Biologist - GIS Specialist
National Park Service
240 West 5th Avenue
Anchorage, Alaska  99501
907.644.3577
` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` ` `

Reply via email to