So here's a somewhat lengthy response to your inquiry about ranid taxonomy.


David,

Your not at all "way behind." Exactly which name should be used is in a state of flux right now and is a fairly contentious issue in the amphibian taxonomy community. Basically, in presenting their results of a large phylogenetic analysis of amphibians, Frost et al (2006; Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History) advised a huge number of taxonomic changes including placing Rana sylvatica and many other New World ranids in the genus Lithobates. Other New World ranids, including Rana aurora were retained in Rana. Similarly, Nearctic Bufo, including Bufo boreas, were placed in the genus Anaxyrus. These are only two of dozens of taxonomic changes suggested. There was no explicit rationale given for making these changes. In some cases larger taxa were split up with groups of species being assigned to new genera (e.g. for many ranids and bufonids), and in other cases names were sunk and subsumed into other genera (e.g. Dicamptodon was placed into Ambystoma even though both were well supported and recovered as sister taxa, a long recognized relationship). All of this was done in a phylogenetic context so that the taxa would reflect evolutionary relationships, but this could also have been done in such a manner as to make the fewest name changes possible and maintain taxonomic stability (I few this as a far more responsible and informative approach.). Most of Frost et al's suggested changes are subjective and not necessitated by their phylogentic results. This is the major objection to the Frost et al taxonomy: most of the name changes are unnecessary if your goal is to have your taxonomy reflect evolutionary relationships.

That said, technically Frost et al did nothing wrong in making these suggested changes; though I would argue it was extremely irresponsible. Authors can pretty much make any suggestions they want about taxonomy. It is then up to the community to decide whether to accept or reject these suggestions. For those changes that are not necessary to reflect evolutionary relationships, I believe that they should not be used as generic ranks. These new names are disconnected from the previous literature and from the understanding of most users of taxonomy. A major goal of taxonomy is to promote communication among users, and Frost et al's suggestions do the opposite. There's a great discussion of this point on the AmphibiaWeb site maintained by the Museum of Vertebrate Zoology at UC Berkeley:

http://amphibiaweb.org/taxonomy/index.html

So instead of using them as generic names, most of these recommendations can be treated as subgenera. Then folks interested in taxonomic details can use these subgeneric names (e.g. Rana (Lithobates) sylvatica) and the rest of the community can continue to use the historically consistent and stable names.

So I hope that provides a general synopsis. The take-away message is that there isn't a clear solution. It will likely be multiple years before the taxonomy settles down, but in general most of the unnecessary changes are likely to be ignored. The AMNH website obviously shows the changes since it is maintained by Frost, but most of the amphibian taxonomy community seems to be opposed to these unnecessary changes. Multiple groups are working on responses to the Frost paper for their group of interest. And conveniently for you, there is already some info in the literature about how to deal with the New World Rana. Hillis (2007, Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 42:331-338) makes a number of the same points I discussed above and recommends that New Wolrd Rana, including Wood Frogs be retained in Rana. So for reports, pubs, etc, you can state that you follow the taxonomy presented in Hillis (2007) in using Rana sylvatica.

Feel free to contact me if you have any questions,

Greg





Hi all,

I'm looking for some feedback on the "new" Latin name for wood frogs;
I've been advised of a change from Rana sylvatica to Lithobates
sylvaticus.

So, I'm wondering about this taxonomic change; does this reflect an
actual and accepted change in name and genera, or is this work of some
fringe taxonomists, and not likely to be accepted? The name change is
reflected on the American Museum of Natural History website under the
supervision of Darrel Frost (see
http://research.amnh.org/herpetology/amphibia/index.php).

Maybe I'm just way behind and am the only one who was unaware this
change has already occurred.

Thanks!


Dave

David F. Tessler
Regional Wildlife Biologist, Nongame Program
Alaska Department of Fish and Game
Division of Wildlife Conservation
333 Raspberry Road
Anchorage, Alaska  99518
Phone: (907) 267-2332
Fax: (907) 267-2433
Email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Web: http://www.wildlife.alaska.gov/index.cfm?adfg=nongame.staff


--
Gregory B. Pauly
Section of Integrative Biology
One University Station #C0930
University of Texas
Austin, Texas 78712
(512) 471-5302 lab
(512) 471-3878 fax

Reply via email to