On Jul 6, 10:24 am, "Christopher Van Kirk"
<[email protected]> wrote:
> I think the lawyer that Mark Murphy posted makes a more compelling argument
> for resistance. The Lodsys model depends on many businesses yielding without
> a fight. If Lodsys faces an uphill battle with every single patent
> assertion, they'll make a loss on each one and we'll be rid of them in no
> time at all.
>

I am not convinced of this strategy and it could be counterproductive.
Responding to the Lodsys letter threatening a fight tells them two
things: a) you won't cooperate and b). You must have money and
therefore you are worth suing.

So far, having to fight several developers at once doesn't seem to
phase LodSys at all. They've filed suit against seven developers in
one court case, and they seem to be able to add and subtract
defendants at will. Apple is trying to intervene in the suit and they
still aren't phased.

The Groklaw people may be real lawyers but I see several flaws in
their suggestions.

1. Reexamination is stated by them as taking zero money. I have found
no evidence that that is true. If someone finds how to do that for
free, please post. But the estimates are $20,000-$30,000 and would
take two to three years. In the meantime, you would still have to pay
the costs of fighting LodSys if they decide to sue you. Not free. Not
even close.

2. Seeking a declaratory judgement in whatever district, as they
suggest, sounds great but it isn't free. It also means you have a
*100%* chance of being in a lawsuit against Lodsys. They will fight it
and countersue. Four companies have sought declaratory judgements, and
Lodsys has caved on none of them. Some are currently spending money
arguing over where Mark Small lives.

Negotiating a license right away as Mr. Mueller suggests isn't the
only option either. I talk to the Villain CEO who had wanted to band
together with other iOS developers. He's heard from a dozen other
people but they are waiting to see what LodSys does. In the meantime,
what are they doing? Nothing. They've let the 21 days expire.

LodSys has probably sent hundreds of letters and has actually started
a lawsuit against seven developers. If it wins this case, I expect
they will send followups ("when may we expect payment?"). If they
lose, and the patent is invalidated, we can probably just laugh it
off. I hope they lose.

Seeking reexamination, getting declaratory judgements, and finding
prior art are all good ideas, and should be done. I don't feel like I
need to start a new court fight in order to do them. If I have a
beautiful piece of prior art, I should probably send it to someone who
is already fighting.

Still, the best advice is to consult with a lawyer. But if that lawyer
advises me to fight and hasn't promised to work for free, then I would
seriously question their judgement and/or motives.

Nathan

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google
Groups "Android Developers" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
[email protected]
For more options, visit this group at
http://groups.google.com/group/android-developers?hl=en

Reply via email to