HTTP://WWW.STOPNATO.ORG.UK
---------------------------

from
The New York Times
Fri, March 7, 2003

http://www.nytimes.com/2003/03/07/opinion/07KRUG.html?ex=1048151858&ei=1&en=35296f4371abcc32

Let Them Hate as Long as They Fear
By PAUL KRUGMAN 

  "Why does our president condone the swaggering and
contemptuous approach to our friends and allies this
administration is fostering, including among its most
senior officials? Has 'oderint dum metuant' really become
our motto?" So reads the resignation letter of John Brady
Kiesling, a career diplomat who recently left the Foreign
Service in protest against Bush administration policy. 

  "Oderint dum metuant" translates, roughly, as "let them
hate as long as they fear." It was a favorite saying of the
emperor Caligula, and may seem over the top as a
description of current U.S. policy. But this week's crisis
in U.S.-Mexican relations - a crisis that has been almost
ignored north of the border - suggests that it is a perfect
description of George Bush's attitude toward the world. 

  Mexico is an enormously important ally, not just because of
our common border, but also because of its special role as
a showcase for American ideals. For a century and a half
Mexico has - often with good reason - seen its powerful
neighbor as an exploiter, if not an outright enemy. Since
the first Bush administration, however, the United States
has made great efforts to treat Mexico as a partner, and
Mexico's recent track record of economic stability and
democracy is, and should be, a source of pride on both
sides of the border. 

  But Mexico's seat on the U.N. Security Council gives it a
vote on the question of Iraq - and the threats the Bush
administration has made to get that vote are quickly
destroying any semblance of good will. 

  Last week The Economist quoted an American diplomat who
warned that if Mexico didn't vote for a U.S. resolution it
could "stir up feelings" against Mexicans in the United
States. He compared the situation to that of
Japanese-Americans who were interned after 1941, and
wondered whether Mexico "wants to stir the fires of
jingoism during a war." 

  Incredible stuff, but easy to dismiss as long as the
diplomat was unidentified. Then came President Bush's
Monday interview with Copley News Service. He alluded to
the possibility of reprisals if Mexico didn't vote
America's way, saying, "I don't expect there to be
significant retribution from the government" - emphasizing
the word "government." He then went on to suggest that
there might, however, be a reaction from other quarters,
citing "an interesting phenomena taking place here in
America about the French . . . a backlash against the
French, not stirred up by anybody except the people." 

  And Mr. Bush then said that if Mexico or other countries
oppose the United States, "there will be a certain sense of
discipline." 

  These remarks went virtually unreported by the
ever-protective U.S. media, but they created a political
firestorm in Mexico. The White House has been frantically
backpedaling, claiming that when Mr. Bush talked of
"discipline" he wasn't making a threat. But in the context
of the rest of the interview, it's clear that he was. 

  Moreover, Mr. Bush was disingenuous when he described the
backlash against the French as "not stirred up by anybody
except the people." On the same day that the report of his
interview appeared, The Financial Times carried the
headline, "Hastert Orchestrates Tirade Against the French."
That's Dennis Hastert, the speaker of the House of
Representatives. In fact, anti-French feeling has been
carefully fomented by Republican officials, Rupert
Murdoch's media empire and other administration allies. Can
you blame Mexicans for interpreting Mr. Bush's remarks as a
threat to do the same to them? 

  So oderint dum metuant it is. I could talk about the
foolishness of such blatant bullying - or about the
incredible risks, in a multiethnic, multiracial society, of
even hinting that one might encourage a backlash against
Hispanics. And yes, I mean Hispanics, not Mexicans: once
feelings are running high, do you really think people will
politely ask a brown-skinned guy with an accent whether he
is a citizen or, if not, which country he comes from? 

  But my most intense reaction to this story isn't anger over
the administration's stupidity and irresponsibility, or
even dismay over the casual destruction of hard-won
friendships. No, when I read an interview in which the U.S.
president sounds for all the world like a B-movie villain -
"You have relatives in Texas, yes?" - what I feel, above
all, is shame. �� 
_________________________________________
Copyright 2002 The New York Times Company
http://www.nytimes.com/

=====
LMNOP
http://lmno4p.org
"No War for Oil!"



__________________________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Tax Center - forms, calculators, tips, more
http://taxes.yahoo.com/

---------------------------
ANTI-NATO INFORMATION LIST

==^================================================================
This email was sent to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

EASY UNSUBSCRIBE click here: http://topica.com/u/?a84x2u.bdn7KI.YXJjaGl2
Or send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

TOPICA - Start your own email discussion group. FREE!
http://www.topica.com/partner/tag02/create/index2.html
==^================================================================

Reply via email to