Hi Martin,

"Fairness" appears incidental to RFC 7020 and the NRPM; in the
discussion of ARIN-2026-4 I argued against taking the principle of
fairness out of Section 6 and putting it in Section 1, because some
policies like §4.10 are inherently unfair (for certain definitions of
fairness).

The PDP §1.4.1 does call for "Fair and Impartial Number Resource
Administration", but reading the context, it seems clear to me that
policy proposals should limit ARIN's discretion in how to enforce
policy---i.e. it says the rules must be imposed fairly, rather than the
rules must be fair.

Now, transfers and the waitlist both require a needs-based
justification---yes we know Mike thinks very little of this, at least
in part because it complicates the business of trading IPs---but the
material change for end users of sending reclaimed addresses to the 4.10
pool is that small operators must convincingly deploy IPv6 and we
prevent transfers of new allocations directly from ARIN. And for
operators who cannot justify under 4.10 AND hold less than a /20 in
aggregate, they are still left with 3 options:

1) purchase on the transfer market, justifying need to ARIN;
2) lease from their ISP or some other organization; or
3) figure out how to qualify for 4.10 space.

At present, I suspect that (1) and (2) will actually be much cheaper for
organizations than (3): a /24 leases for about $2000/a and sells for
about $7000, based on the best data I can readily get. This is an
absolutely *trivial* cost compared to the capital investment in
equipment and connectivity involved in running even a small network, and
substantially less than the annual rent and power for a rack at an IXP.
The straw man of a "little guy" isn't running on a 6509 he found on the
side of the road, and if he is, IPs cost less than his power! The needs
justification requirement presumably helps deflate prices of the
transfer market, by raising the bar required for speculative address
purchases, and the organizations actually able to purchase addresses
speculatively are almost certainly aware that doing so hurts their
customers' ability to use their services.

It is unfortunate that none of the people actually *using* the waitlist
have chimed in on the mailing list about what getting rid of the
waitlist would mean to them. I do not know what that means, but it does
not give me a lot of confidence in there even being a non-strawman
argument for keeping the waiting list.

        Eric C. Landgraf
        Virginia Tech

On Oct 28 19:21, Martin Hannigan wrote:
> Mike,
> 
> I don’t need AI to make post slop for me on this issue. “Uniqueness and
> conservation" isn't the whole mission. RFC 2050 and the NRPM introduce fair
> distribution alongside conservation and aggregation as goals, and needs
> based assessment has always been a “rule” for fairness. Not just an
> efficiency rule. (rathole alert)  If ARIN were only a directory it wouldn’t
> be issuing resources.
> 
> Warm regards,
> 
> -M<
> 
> 
> 
> On Wed, Oct 28, 2026 at 18:09 Mike Burns <[email protected]> wrote:
> 
> > Hi Marty,
> >
> > Forgive me for using your post as my example. I got the answer below my
> > signature from AI, as I am interested in a larger discussion about the
> > inevitable ingression of AI into policy development.
> >
> > Nonetheless, I do stand by its argument. Giving out free /22s is not going
> > to change any economic situation, and the IPv4 market has moved the debate
> > into a different realm.
> >
> > RIRs are for uniqueness and conservation. Not for equalizing little guys
> > and big guys. And these days, price offers more conservation than anything
> > else.  But as I also said, the waiting list is small potatoes, and it is
> > actually functioning quite well.
> >
> > Although there was that subject for the lunch table…
> >
> > Regards,
> >
> > Mike
> >
> >
> >
> > Hi Martin,
> >
> > Yes, I think that became an important rationale for it: giving smaller
> > organizations access to IPv4 without requiring them to compete in the
> > transfer market with much larger buyers.
> >
> > But I don't think that necessarily argues for maintaining the waiting list
> > indefinitely.
> >
> > We already exclude organizations holding more than a /20 and limit
> > waiting-list distributions to a /22. If the objective now is to make the
> > remaining recovered IPv4 serve a public-policy purpose rather than simply
> > enter the market, 4.10 seems to me the better destination.
> >
> > It preserves non-market access to scarce IPv4, but ties that access
> > directly to IPv6 deployment.
> >
> > So I agree with the equity concern. I am questioning whether the waiting
> > list remains the best mechanism for addressing it.
> >
> > Regards,
> >
> > Mike
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > *From:* Martin Hannigan <[email protected]>
> > *Sent:* Wednesday, October 28, 2026 5:55 PM
> > *To:* Mike Burns <[email protected]>
> > *Cc:* Eric C. Landgraf <[email protected]>; [email protected]
> > *Subject:* Re: [arin-ppml] ARIN 58 Table Topic - If the Waitlist didn't
> > exist, what would?
> >
> >
> >
> > Mike,
> >
> >
> >
> > Wasn’t the point of the waitlist equity with the big $corp big $$budgets?
> > Competition and fairness?
> >
> >
> >
> > Thanks,
> >
> >
> >
> > -M<
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > On Wed, Oct 28, 2026 at 16:43 Mike Burns via ARIN-PPML <[email protected]>
> > wrote:
> >
> > Hi Eric,
> >
> > I think we agree on the cleanest solution.
> >
> > I encourage you to draft a proposal to deal with returned addresses in a
> > manner that doesn't perpetuate the waiting list.
> > It is an opportune moment, with the list having recently received a
> > substantial allocation and the decks somewhat cleared.
> >
> > In the long run, this is small potatoes.
> > I think establishing a cutoff date, grandfathering the current list, and
> > allowing it to wither on the vine would be the best approach.
> >
> > I don't think the failure to reach consensus in the past is much of a
> > barrier.
> >
> > Regards,
> >
> > Mike
> >
> > -----Original Message-----
> > From: ARIN-PPML <[email protected]> On Behalf Of 'Eric C.
> > Landgraf'
> > Sent: Wednesday, October 28, 2026 1:37 PM
> > To: [email protected]
> > Subject: Re: [arin-ppml] ARIN 58 Table Topic - If the Waitlist didn't
> > exist,
> > what would?
> >
> > On Oct 28 13:12, Mike Burns wrote:
> > > ARIN is not a charity; that would not be consonant with its purpose.
> > >
> > > Moving the proceeds one step away does not eliminate the conflict. If
> > > the police direct ticket revenue to a foundation they created or
> > > selected, the incentive problem has not disappeared; it has merely
> > > been moved.
> > >
> > > I do not support the blurring of incentives between institutional
> > > self-enrichment and enforcing the law equally. So why do this with
> > > ARIN, even at the one remove you propose?
> >
> > An alternate framing: this is equivalent to when your county or town
> > auctions off property (thru a 3rd party) to pay back-tax on it. In many,
> > perhaps most cases, we can't find the deeded "owner" of the resource, there
> > is no entail, and someone forgot to pay their RSP fees for some length of
> > time: as ARIN, we want to recover those fees.
> >
> > Under that framing, do we have a real conflict of interest? Does the
> > facilitator take all the proceeds after the RSP fees and transfer fees are
> > paid, or does ARIN get a fixed return if there's a profit?
> >
> > I tend to agree with you that getting rid of everything that isn't
> > effectively 4.10 space is probably the cleanest solution, since needs
> > justification under 4.10 is still extant with the extra provisio that you
> > have to be deploying IPv6. But as you noted, that did not reach consensus
> > at
> > the time it was last proposed, so there is value in exploring other
> > potential policies.
> >
> >         Eric C. Landgraf
> >         Virginia Tech
> > _______________________________________________
> > ARIN-PPML
> > You are receiving this message because you are subscribed to the ARIN
> > Public
> > Policy Mailing List ([email protected]).
> > Unsubscribe or manage your mailing list subscription at:
> > https://lists.arin.net/mailman/listinfo/arin-ppml
> > Please contact [email protected] if you experience any issues.
> >
> > _______________________________________________
> > ARIN-PPML
> > You are receiving this message because you are subscribed to
> > the ARIN Public Policy Mailing List ([email protected]).
> > Unsubscribe or manage your mailing list subscription at:
> > https://lists.arin.net/mailman/listinfo/arin-ppml
> > Please contact [email protected] if you experience any issues.
> >
> >
_______________________________________________
ARIN-PPML
You are receiving this message because you are subscribed to
the ARIN Public Policy Mailing List ([email protected]).
Unsubscribe or manage your mailing list subscription at:
https://lists.arin.net/mailman/listinfo/arin-ppml
Please contact [email protected] if you experience any issues.

Reply via email to