hi Amith...
what u said was correct..........but
i just wissh ..that like the video co......the audio company( HMV) was also informed and in the music album credits anu had used arr's name insted of his fr those songs....'coz they r not copies or inspirations.....but were redubs on the original track by ARR ......and if the music company knew of this ....it shudve been ethical enough to do the need ful ...i e include ARR's name in th ecredits....so to me it all smells of foul play...and a hyppocritic step such as sincere thanks does not sound sufficient to a fan like me.....its about time the music industry woke up shaken and stirred and did something about issues like these ...rather than take out inane albums like anmol ratan ( @$%#%) anu malik!!! what say????
ps:-And please someone clear the mystery off Jhoom ke dil ne pukara...like it was done for hum dum pyara( vishwa vidhata).
chill.
jagdeep singh.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Amith wrote....
Amith Chandhran <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Subject: Re: anu malik.......god give him peace!!!
According to some media reports that I'd read around 1994 - 1995,
Mahesh
Bhatt (Director of remade Hindi film 'The Gentleman') had earlier
approached
AR Rahman to remake the music for the said Hindi film. AR, having many
projects on hand down south, denied the offer. Later the director and
producers 'Geetha Arts' made up their minds to team up with Anu Malik.
It
was Anu Malik who suggested that some Tamil songs should be used in
Hindi
too. Since AR was getting famous in Mumbai too, the director decided to
take
the proper permissions from AR Rahman, Shankar, and the Audio
companies.
Accordingly, they took the permissions from director and composer. HMV
took
the audio copyrights from Pyramid, and the songs were made in Hindi.
Its all
done legally.
In 1996 or so, I saw the Hindi movie on VHS, and was surprised to see
this
in the credits: 'My sincere and special thanks to Mr. AR Rahman for
letting
us reuse 4 Tamil songs.' - Anu Malik. This was something different,
because
Anu Malik never accepted that he copies someone's tunes. He would
always
keep saying that he's 'inspired' from other composers' work.
Anyway, its still enigma which is original tune for 'Jhoom Ke Dil Ne
Pukara'
sung by SPB and Chithra in the Hindi version. It doesn't sound like a
Anu
Malik work.. No, please, never!!
But in all, as you said, he really needs brain and some peace!
Love, amith..
Subject: Re: anu malik.......god give him peace!!!
According to some media reports that I'd read around 1994 - 1995,
Mahesh
Bhatt (Director of remade Hindi film 'The Gentleman') had earlier
approached
AR Rahman to remake the music for the said Hindi film. AR, having many
projects on hand down south, denied the offer. Later the director and
producers 'Geetha Arts' made up their minds to team up with Anu Malik.
It
was Anu Malik who suggested that some Tamil songs should be used in
Hindi
too. Since AR was getting famous in Mumbai too, the director decided to
take
the proper permissions from AR Rahman, Shankar, and the Audio
companies.
Accordingly, they took the permissions from director and composer. HMV
took
the audio copyrights from Pyramid, and the songs were made in Hindi.
Its all
done legally.
In 1996 or so, I saw the Hindi movie on VHS, and was surprised to see
this
in the credits: 'My sincere and special thanks to Mr. AR Rahman for
letting
us reuse 4 Tamil songs.' - Anu Malik. This was something different,
because
Anu Malik never accepted that he copies someone's tunes. He would
always
keep saying that he's 'inspired' from other composers' work.
Anyway, its still enigma which is original tune for 'Jhoom Ke Dil Ne
Pukara'
sung by SPB and Chithra in the Hindi version. It doesn't sound like a
Anu
Malik work.. No, please, never!!
But in all, as you said, he really needs brain and some peace!
Love, amith..
M a k e a D i f f e r e n c e !!!
Free antispam, antivirus and 1GB to save all your messages
Only in Yahoo! Mail: http://in.mail.yahoo.com
Explore, Experience, Enjoy A.R.Rahman - The Man, The Music, The Magic.
Only at arrahmanfans - The definitive A.R.Rahman e-community.
Homepage: http://www.arrahmanfans.com
To Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
YAHOO! GROUPS LINKS
- Visit your group "arrahmanfans" on the web.
- To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
- Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.
