yes... very true... Even the song KAMMA KARAyile sounds like "ennadi rakkamma un pallakku"... but it is only highly coincidental.Why would he repeat a famous tune at all? --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "theepr" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > As an A.R.R's greate fan I just wonna explain all about the GF 'Katril' > similarities that topic have been taken out by some other our fans group > members.He/She/they have/has said that perticular song containing some > similarities to harish jeyaraj's "patthu viral unakku" song from Arul; > There are some posibilities to think like that but its defeaneatly wrong > however, Most of the guys(I have also seen personally; some have said > there are similarities;wherever the same instrument used) are think > ;some particular beats and Instrumental sounds are as same as;although > they used them in deferent Tones.But actually only the sound of that > particular music scores are reflecting as same. most in case the > 'dholak' Instrument's sound will reflect as same whenever it using by > compositions.In this case also same; Both of the song has used the > instrument 'dhoalk' for percussion/beat.that's all.No more with that two > tracks.the Tones defeneatly deferent.really the two song's particular > 'dholak' beat also not same.Still if u think as same ;I wonna say an > other thing;That A.R.R already most of time has used 'dholak' in some > songs.U can clearly hear that from the song 'Nee than en deshiya > geetham' from the movie 'Paarthale Paravasum'.so,if there any similarity > or imitations it should remember this song (also).If it,In that case; > The song "patthu viral unakku" only contain the similar beat of our > Boss's 'Nee than en deshiya geetham' (this compose earlier than 'Arul') > not Boss's 'Katril'. however, using an same instrument can't be a > copy/similar/ an another think if u have thought about > similarities;defeneatly U should have found out some of the following. I > will say the real similarities or inspiration of 'Katril' song step by > step; 'Katril ohr vaarthai methanthu varakkanden' in this lyrics just > keep mind OR hump it ; the first two words u can find clear similarity > of 'Enge enathu kavithy' from 'Kandukonden kandukonden' also the > particular line 'Bhavan eh Jeevan ' from 'Gopalanuhare ' from 'lagaaan' > ;and now listen the fourth word 'methanthu' it similar to 'suttum villi > sudar' song's second line 'suriya chanthiraro' from 'Kandukonden > kandukonden followingly consider the bit of music coming before and > between that hindi lyrics 'yehey sahirtha(OR else)' it is similar to bit > of music used in 'merarang de' from 'Legend of Bhagat sing' before > it,all should mind ; *nothing is from zero; everthing is from one; day > by day, with time when lot of tones scored ;the compositions is getting > limited. it is Mathamatics,only with a seven (Basic)keys or Raga how > many composition can do? (I leave this up to U all) by the way ,I think > we can't expect an music as very pure in coming up days and we would > never get tired to listen music.up to these kind of issuses I hope boss > one step up than all of U. he is the only genius.we all will enjoy his > grate compositions forever ever.no one barrier it. I was listening God > father Greate music when I wrote this ;I would be listening and u all > Keep enjoying our Boss's unbeatable hit.It is realy like a Big treate. > Buy!!! > Explore, Experience, Enjoy A.R.Rahman - The Man, The Music, The Magic. Only at arrahmanfans.com - The definitive A.R.Rahman e-community. Homepage: http://www.arrahmanfans.com Admin: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Subscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To Unsubscribe: [EMAIL PROTECTED] BGM fest and Potters contest From arsaregama Log on to http://launch.groups.yahoo.com/group/arsaregama Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/arrahmanfans/ <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
