HI EVERYBODY,
OK THERE ARE MANY PROBLEMS REGARDING OPINIONS HERE...SOME ARE SAYING THAT
GURU IS ONE OF THE BEST AND SOME ARE SAYING THAT HE WASTED $15(HA HA)..WE HAVE
TO ACCEPT BOTH..I AGREE THAT SOME OF THE SONGS IS NOT USED WELL AND SOME IS NOT
NEEDED...WELL THE DIRECTOR WILL HAVE HIS OWN OPINIONS ON HOW TO USE THOSE SONGS
,WHAY THE SCENE SHOULD BE LIKE THIS AND NOT LIKE THAT....FOR ME ITS A DIFFERENT
MOVIE ALL TOGETHER....ONE SHOULD NOT EXPECT EVERYTHING TO BE
PERFECT,BEST,FAMOUS AND BRILLIANT....THERE ARE SOME GOOD THINGS AND SOME BAD
THINGS WILL HAPPEN.....A MOVIE CAN BE HIT AND FLOP...U CAN STOP THAT .ITS THE
NATURE OF THIS FILM INDUSTRY...
AR RAHMAN CAN STAND ALONE FOR HIS MUSIC...REMEMBER BOMBAY...MANY PEOPLE HAVE
NOT SEEN THE MOVIE TILL TODAY...BUT THE SONGS ARE HIT TILL TODAY...WHY....THE
MOVIE WAS BANNED...AND HOW COME THE SONGS ARE HIT....
FOR ME GURU HAVE VERY GOOD SONG BUT ITS NOT A GOOD ALBUM...BUT BOMBAY WAS A
VERY GOOD ALBUM...MANY LIKE TO COMPARE ALL MANI RATNAM'S MOVIE TO
UYIRE(DILSE)..I STILL DONT KNOW WHY...BOTH ARE TOTALLY DIFFERENT MOVIE...ONE
CANT EXPECT THAT GURU MUST HAVE A CHAIYA CHAIYA KIND OF SONG....YUVA'S SONGS
ARE BRILLIANT AS WELL....
AND FROM TODAY WE MUST NOT GET ANGRY WITH OTHER WEBSITES SUCH AS
REDIFF...INDIAFM AND OTHERS FOR THEIR REVIEWS OR CRITICS ON OUR AR
RAHMAN...BECOZ WE OURSELF ARE DOING IT..,
MANY DIDNT LIKE GURU...I UNDERSTAND WHY...BUT U SHOULD UNDERSTAND THAT ITS A
TYPICAL MANI RATNAM'S MOVIE.....JUST LIKE SHANKAR'S TYPICAL MOVIE WHICH ALWAYS
BECOMES HIT AND VERY NICE TO WATCH....ITS A MANI RATNAM'S MOVIE....WE CAN ONLY
EXPECT EXTRAODINARY SONGS FROM THIS MANI ARR COMBINATIONS...LET THEM CONTINUE
THEIR TRADITION...MAYBE LAJJO IS A MODERN MOVIE WHICH WILL HAVE MODERN SONGS AS
WELL THEN U GUYS WILL KNOW WHO IS AR RAHMAN....
TILL THEN ITS OK TO COMMENT BUT NOT FIGHTING EACH OTHER IN OUR OWN
GROUP...SOMEBODY WILL BE VERY HAPPY AND LAUGHING...
STAY UNITED FOR AR RAHMAN...ONLY HE HIMSELF WILL BE ABLE TO CREATE MAGIC.JUST
LIKE GURU SONGS...NOBODY ELSE WILL BE ABLE TO GIVE SONGS SUCH AS AR RAHMAN GAVE
FOR GURU...THEY(OTHER MUSIC DIRECTORS) KNOW THAT FROM THE BEGINNING...AND THEY
KNEW WHO OR WHAT IS AR RAHMAN AND HIS MUSIC...
I HAVE NO INTENTION TO HURT ANYBODY AND IF HAVE DID THEN I AM REALLY
SORRY...ITS FOR RAHMAN'S LOVE
JAI RAHMAN...
ramana chandran <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
oh come on arr fans are not supposed to be like this watever he
is done for guru he is done it in a classy way and u jus cant expect lose
control songss for guru u see it has to be how it should be not like how u
expect............ reply
----- Original Message ----
From: riyaz ahamed <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Wednesday, January 17, 2007 6:45:58 PM
Subject: Re: [arr] Guru - Fails Miserably ( utter failure)
i agree with u rafeeq, he should come out from 1980's sytle music
[EMAIL PROTECTED] com wrote: hii every body
itwas nice to hear that there are all type of fans for ARR and MR.
members in this groep has the ample rights to oppose or support admire or
critisise
ARRs work. Its not a healthy argument that those who critisise ARR an Mani
Ratnam should go out of the group.
Guru is an average movie to put it in simple.
theres nothing to say it was awsome or fantastic. the music including BGM was
not to the expectation. not even comparable with dilse or KM. or even yuva.
Our boss need a change . Like shanker to introduse harris , Mani sir also to
make some changes.
Anwer, 36 china town etc did well in the industry with music for their CDs
hav a good sales in market. ARRs music is not nowadays impressing the average
listeners other than our group.
am I right,,if wrong so sorry
plsssss reply
Tamil Pakkam <tamilpakkam@ gmail.com> wrote:
What are u guys talking about waste of $15 and time........
........Please dont make evryone in the group angry ..........so tell me which
was better movie that was released recently that is comparable to Guru........
......
On 1/16/07, Kalimuthu V <kalimuthu.v@ lgsoftindia. com> wrote:
I also agree with you in 1, 3 (Esp. Lahari song), 6, 7,8,9.
Music could have been much better. Nothing impressive in BGM!
ARR is, perhaps, tired of giving best for Mani but not getting any
appreciation for his efforts. Most of his work in KM (Tremendous songs), Uyire
(Excellent songs & BGM) went unnoticed.
As Mani mentioned in his recent Tamil interview, he should give it a try with
his friend IR for his next movie.
It might give a break for Mani as well as ARR.
From: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com [mailto: [EMAIL PROTECTED] com] On
Behalf Of s_sundarr_2000
Sent: Tuesday, January 16, 2007 5:02 PM
To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com
Subject: [arr] Guru - Fails Miserably
hi,
this is my personal opinion abt guru. I watched it last sunday paying
(wasting) 15$.
I did not like the movie @ all. The things i hated in the movie are:
1.unnecessary episode of vidya balan/maddy, am sure mani wanted a
movie to run for 2.45 hrs, with the original script it was only for 2
hrs, then he thougth to include this.
2. aish is not convincing in her role, look so thin and acting is jaded.
3. songs r unnecessary and placed badly in the movies. mayya (2 stanza
was cut r probably pushed to background) is not necessary, immediately
followd by barso re (again 2nd stanza pushed to background - except
for few lines). ay hairathe does come in bits and pieces, tera bina is
not fully picturised and fails to create a impact on screen as it was
on trailers and audio's. yammo yammo was okey and baazi laga - highly
unnecessary.
4. rajiv menons work was alrite and nothing that gr8.
5. rahman's bgm was okey, he used a lot of songs pieces in the bgm as
they were not used by mani properly.
6. so many scenes in rain, barso re, whenver abhishek addresses his
staff, prathap pothan episode. why does mani waste so much water when
there is so much scarcity in chennai. the point is rain is not reqd.
agreed in 1st song of mouna ragam but why repetedly here?
7. moves @ a liesurely pace and doesn't pick up anytime
8. abhishek does all his acts and justifies in 4.5 min saying .5 min
is profit, naah it did not work. where did gandhi come in? who asked
abt his past to the panel that 2 shirts/15000 rupees stuff? they were
asking reasons and justifications for his act?
9.where did mithun disappear in the end?
only gud thing was abhishek acting. rahman's songs fails to create an
impact on screen, it was very gud in audio and i was jumping.!
better luck next time mani ! probably lajjo is more in terms of period
again who knows?
waste of time and money!
############ ######### ######### ######### ######### ######### THIS EMAIL
MESSAGE IS FOR THE SOLE USE OF THE INTENDED RECIPIENT(S) AND MAY CONTAIN
CONFIDENTIAL AND PRIVILEGED INFORMATION. ANY UNAUTHORIZED REVIEW, USE,
DISCLOSURE OR DISTRIBUTION IS PROHIBITED.BEFORE OPENING ANY ATTACHMENTS
PLEASE CHECK FOR VIRUSES AND DEFECTS.IF YOU ARE NOT THE INTENDED RECIPIENT,
PLEASE NOTIFY US IMMEDIATELY BY REPLY E-MAIL AND DELETE THE ORIGINAL MESSAGE.
############ ######### ######### ######### ######### ######### #
---------------------------------
Access over 1 million songs - Yahoo! Music Unlimited.
---------------------------------
Want to start your own business? Learn how on Yahoo! Small Business.
---------------------------------
Expecting? Get great news right away with email Auto-Check.
Try the Yahoo! Mail Beta.
---------------------------------
Need a quick answer? Get one in minutes from people who know. Ask your question
on Yahoo! Answers.
