Hats off, Shai. I like you and your post.. I also wish to let ther anti-ARR's out of this group. It would be great, if they, themselves, get out of it. We don't see the quantity (# of fans) but quality.
It is so ridiculous to see various posts posted by so called 'fans'. It really hurts me and ofcourse lot of true Rahmaniacs too. Cheers, Siraj On 10/26/07, hpkdaas <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Hi Shai, > > Very good well done u had bashed up all the critics whichever inside > this group as ARR fans.. Nice and well done. Hats off shai.. > what a write up? wonderful.. > As a fan of ARR u said it better than anybody. > I was been silent for long time and watching out all the mails. > When i read mail something like urs i was very very happy to see such > guys like you... > > Urs lovingly, > Krishna. > > > On 10/25/07, shai shai <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > everytime of a new ar rahman release i will come to the most hated > moment in my life. > > its about some people or maybe i should say fans.. > > > > before any ar rahman's film release there will be some fans > telling 'i cant wait for the song'...please release it > fast......'when is the release'..... > > > > but after the release.........all the words that i can > see :...dissappointing'.....copied.......inspired.....'ar rahman not > at his best....arr should have done better......this songs reminds me > of old IR song....that song sounds like that....' > > > > what is the problem with this group?all of u are demanding > something from one person called ar rahman....all of u are expecting > something individually from one person called ar rahman again....and > sadly all of ur expectations are different al together: > > > > some will expect song like roja > > some will expect RDB kind > > some will expect sivaji and some will expect uyire.....now which > one would arr do > > > > none of u here are a director of the movie > > none of u here are the producers > > none of u here rajini,amir khan or vijay > > none of u have given ar rahman the money to compose songs but > > > > u all are demanding,expecting,advising and giving instructions to > ar rahman on how should he compose....how would i understand this.. > > > > is ar rahman a machine,keyboard or drums for u to expect many > things from him...he is just a humble person playing keyboard,giving > notes and trying very hard to satisfy his fans after AFTER going > through all the demands of the producer,director and actors....with > sleeples nights,tension,stress and all other things....and guess what > are the responses and feedbacks that he will get by reading all those > mails in this group? > > > > the funny thing happening in this group only this group is; > > > > ar rahman fans are the one will :praise him > > :say they are > dissappointed with his music > > :say he copied and he > inspired from other md > > :expect tooo much and > later dissappointed by that > > : critic him > > > > all of this done by ar rahman fans AND NOT OTHER MUSIC DIRECTOR > FANS... > > > > when one from this group tell that ar rahman copied or > inspiredthey must know that they are the one who give information > (rumours) about arr copied to other music director fans...and the > other md fans will be happy to know that and will start bashing > arrahman...and there will be HJ better than rahman,yuvan better than > rahman and all those thing happened bcoz of? again ar rahman fans > themselves....why guys why... > > > > we are the one should defend arr ,praise him...encourage him,give > 10000% support...its ok if u dont do this but please dont do the > other way around > > > > the difference between me and SOME other arr fans is::i sometimes > will cry listening to ar rahman's music and thinking about him BUT > some of u guys could make ar rahman cry ?reading ur mails > > > > > > shai, > > > > not to all the fans BUT some?! > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Avinash: Thu Oct 25 03: 14: [EMAIL PROTECTED], > [EMAIL PROTECTED];;;, ": Avinash :" < > [EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Hi... nice writeup man! Though it is written in a hurry, I loved > and > > agree with your all views!! > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, > "izham_jamal" <izham_jamal@> > > wrote: > > > > > > Hi Dear ARR fans, > > > I always visited this site but i usually dont post reply nor > start > > a > > > new topic.But after i saw some comments made on ATM,i cant stay > > quiet > > > anymore.Since i started visiting this site,whenever a ARR album > > > released,i saw someone WILL post some thing about > > dissapointment.Its > > > a complete nonsense.We have to understand that very2 few songs > > that > > > we like after the 1st hearing.Its a human nature,resistance to > > accept > > > new thing because they used to others,myb something like inertia > > in > > > physics terms.If we analyze ARR songs from those days to now,you > > > hardly will found any similarities between the songs.We often > like > > > the earlier film music by ARR.As time goes when we heard the > songs > > > repeated times in TV or radio,then we will say,'hey this song is > > not > > > bad'.We are too curious waiting for his album,and we will listen > > the > > > new releases with a very-very high expectation which i think is > > not > > > fair to any music directors.Just think if we are not aware of ATM > > > release and one day we heard it on the radio,im sure we will like > > the > > > song. > > > > > > Dear friends,we have to consider that this is a VJ film.We all > > know > > > how VJs film music will be like.Music directors cant simply > create > > a > > > songs,it must caters the need of the director.Even ARR admit it > > when > > > he said i remember "you canot simply said ok we have ARR,the > music > > > gona be chartbuster,directors have to play their part aso to > bring > > > the best out of us(MD)".That is a very true statement indeed. > > > > > > Ok lets talk about ATM.Im not particularly like what we call as > > gana > > > or kuthu songs,so when ARR was signed 4 d movie,i realy wanted to > > see > > > how ARR music gone be,and he didnt dissapoint me at all.I know > > some > > > of us saying about lacking ARR touches on some of the songs,i > can > > > understand their feelings.SO i decided to make a review,not from > > my > > > point of view but from a neutral perspective considerin the > > praises > > > and critics received so far. > > > > > > 1.Ellapughalum > > > -i cant recall a song that sung by ARR and havent become a > hit.Hes > > a > > > gt a gifted voice as well.So far,VJ fans cant live without the > > > song,for them its on of the best.This song dont take much time > to > > > grow on you.Top notch,so energetic and fantastic music.The > critics > > > received about this song is, too much instrument used in the > > > backgrond and have similarities to ARRs Anbe Aauyire, i > > think.Those > > > who think like that,dont worry,it wont take much tile b4 u like > > > it.Rating:9.5/10. > > > > > > 2.Poonmagal Remix > > > -when i heard the sample release,i have to admit im a bit > > > dissapointed as im expecting something like Thothal Poo > > Malarum.After > > > the full song released,i realy appreciate the creativeness of the > > > maker(ARR or assistant),im sure many would agree with me.This > song > > > missing ARR touches,agreed,but we all know ARR not keen on > Remixes > > > and im sure hes a bit dissapointed when asked to remix the song > > and > > > rather asked his assistant to do it.Overall not bad,most people > > gona > > > love it.Rating:8.5/10. > > > > > > 3.Nee Marilyn Monroe. > > > -i personally believe its one of ARR best western type of songs.I > > jus > > > cant get enough with it and my friends feeling the same way.I > rely > > > cant believe its done by ARR.Youthful lyrics and so relaxing to > > > hear.Ok i agree it lacks ARR touches,but who cares,the song is > > > rocking.Music is so beautiful and a good rap aso.The way words > are > > > pronounce are the strong point.Rating:9.0/10. > > > > > > 4.Valayapatti Thavil. > > > -i tot its gona be another kamma karayil(varalaaru) after the > > > sample.But actualy i lost my word,i cant rely classified this > song > > in > > > any category.I think this is the only song i yet to heard any > > critics > > > and loved by almost everyone.This is not my pick of Album but > > still > > > its a very good song.Nothing much to said,the song talk for > > > itself.Rating:9.5/10. > > > > > > 5.Maduraiku Pogadhe > > > -VJ fans are happy but ARR fans are not.All in all folk song.I > > dont > > > realy like this kind of songs,but trust me,i loved it after > > repeated > > > hearings.No MD im sure cant do this type of song,even its a folk > > > song, it has ARR maximum touch in it im sure.If you still dont > > like > > > then just ignore the song.Rating:8.5/10. > > > > > > 6.Kelamal Kayile > > > -My favourite and im sure many have the same taste with me.Some > > are > > > saying it reminds us of Mellisaiye(mr.Romeo),till now i cant find > > any > > > basic to that.The male voice are top class and the female singer > > even > > > weird at times,but were vere quite good.We cant see some > > experiment > > > here,very high pitch of female voice at times that makes us > > > uncomfortable,neverdles,its a great composition by ARR.Superb > > music > > > and different technic.Rating :9.0/10. > > > > > > FRIENDS,WHAT IS CLEAR HERE IS, LOWER YOUR EXPECTATION A BIT AND > > > LISTEN TO THE SONG AS A NEUTRAL YOU WILL AND ENJOY THE SONG AS I > > DID, > > > RATHER THAN CRITICISE IT BECAUSE THIS ALBUM DIDNT DESERVES ANY > > > CRITICS.I DONT RATE ANY SONG A PERFECT 10 COZ NOTHING IS PERFECT > > EVEN > > > IF IT LOOK LIKE IT. > > > > > > (Sory for any grammer or spelling mistakes,i took some time to > > write > > > this as im not a good typer,im hapy if you al can give your tot > > abt > > > this.Thank You.) > > > > > > > > > > > > > __________________________________________________ > > Do You Yahoo!? > > Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around > > http://mail.yahoo.com > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > regards, > > Vithur > > > > A.R. RAHMAN - THE GOD OF MUSIC > > > > > > > > __________________________________________________ > > Do You Yahoo!? > > Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around > > http://mail.yahoo.com > > > > >
