All the songs have been created based on the 7notes only.... So, its not surprising for you to find out some similarities...
ps: similarities and copying hv diff meanings.... 2008/5/23 Gomzy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > Who knows, he might be doing it unintentionally too. I am sure he > wouldnt remember > all of his tunes, cuz he tries to free his mind for the next album. In the > process a tune > might strike which already did , but he wouldnt know. > > I think sometimes this is what happens when there are accusations that he > lifts tunes. > You can see that these lifts are hardly 2-3 secs, but he wouldnt know. > > > On 5/23/08, Gopal Anandan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> >> So the big question remains... why is Boss recycling his own tunes?? >> >> Short of time or as he himself puts it - the enlightenment has driven him >> to these tunes by itself? What do you guys make out of it? >> >> For a non-ARR fan all these songs would still sound new. But for fans like >> you and me - yes.. we've heard this before - oh yes.. wait a minute - isn't >> this similiar to ARR's that album. >> >> You see what I'm getting at? Any comments from all the musicians here in >> the group - cos they can potentially try to musically justify this >> phenomenon. >> >> I'm all ears... >> >> ciao / Gopal >> >> --- On *Fri, 23/5/08, callchandru <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>* wrote: >> >> From: callchandru <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >> Subject: [arr] ADA - My take! >> To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com >> Date: Friday, 23 May, 2008, 1:00 PM >> >> Gulfisha - Singers: Sonu Nigam, Sunidhi Chauhan and Vivian Chaix >> This one is a not a typical ARR tune though the arrangment is very >> Rahmanish. I don't see anything special with this song and not the >> best of ARR by any means. It could easily pass off as something from >> Vishal Shekar/Pritam' s stable. I could hear 'Rangeela' influences. >> Sunidhi Chauhan in a ARR song - First time? If it is, not a great >> song for her to debut with ARR. >> >> Gum Sum - Singers: Sonu Nigam & Alka Yagnik >> A peppy song sung very well by Sonu Nigam and Alka Yagnik. I have to >> say again that the song and the arrangement itself doesn't sound >> completely Rahmanish. Again, a lacklustre song by ARR standards. >> Nothing much to write about it. >> >> Hai Dard - Singer: Udit Narayan >> Here's a song that starts off in a typical Rahman style with Udit's >> soulful singing. It makes you realise that there aren't many pathos >> songs Udit has sung for ARR in Hindi. The evergreen classis 'Ae >> Ajnabi...' from Dil Se was anything to go by, you'd have thought >> there should have been a lot more. But I frankly cannot think of >> much. Udit's comfort in high pitches (Sahaana from Sivaji) must have >> been the decisive factor for ARR picking him to sing this song. >> Udit's voice has a magical element that it can adapt to a pathos >> song as easily as a peppy one. He doesn't have to do much but his >> voice does something to add to the mood of the song. Super! >> >> Hawa Sun Hawa - Singers: Sonu Nigam & Alka Yagnik >> Another Sonu Nigam song. I wonder when was the last time Sonu got so >> many songs in one album of ARR. TLOBS? This one is a lilting >> melodious duet which is Sonu's forte and he just breezes through >> this one like he has done for ARR in the past. The tune in some >> places reminds you of the duets in TLOBS and Zubeidaa. The flute in >> the interludes give the song more haunting feel to it. Super, again! >> >> Ishq Ada - (Male Version) - Singer: Rashid Ali >> Now comes the masterstroke from the genius. The way the song starts >> gets you into its feel right away. The '70s Beatles' beats that >> plays throughout the song gets you into the groove of the song. The >> tune is a very complex one with many layers to it. ARR started with >> a simple basic tune of the song and tries out various permutations >> and combinations of pitch to it. Pure genius. Rashid Ali's singing >> is a mixed bag for me. His voice is very fresh in some places but >> at many places he gets too nasal to my liking. And thats where he >> sounds like a Adnan Sami clone. The accordion and guitar you get to >> hear is so refreshing which is something thats not well used in many >> songs these days. >> >> Ishq Ada - (Female Version) - Singer: Parul Mishra >> The female version of the previous song with minor variations. Parul >> sounds almost like Shreya in this song except when she sings in high >> pitches. She has done a creditable job for a song with a complex >> tune and has more classical touches to it than the one sung by >> Rashid. The tune has a complex mix of low pitch and high pitch >> singing that keeps switching pretty quickly and I wonder how many >> takes it took for the singers to get it right. >> >> Meherbaan - Singer: ARR >> The song starts off with a piano that you could easily mistake for a >> Richard Marx from 80s. And just when ARR starts singing and you hear >> the acoustic arrangement, you realise the obvious. ARR wanted to do >> a 80s soft rock romantic number ala Richard Marx, Elton John. I >> guess he wanted to do it for a long time and this is his way of >> doing it. A fitting tribute! This is one genre that is still >> evergreen especially for those who were in their teens during mid >> 80s and early 90s and were influenced by that hugely popular soft- >> rock genre. I guess ARR is one such. Having said all that, I noticed >> a similarity with 'Ni Sa Ri Sa...' song from Jeans. Anybody else? >> >> Meherbaan (Instrumental) Guitar: Sanjeev Thomas >> A nice song to pick for an instrumental. This would make for a great >> BGM if used well. It can easily pass off as music track from Richard >> Marx / Bryan Adams with such great guitar and piano. >> >> Milo Wahan Wahan Singers: Alka Yagnik & Jayachandran >> Everybody said it and I'll say it again. The song starts off with >> the BGM piece that Rahman used it in the climax of Kannathil >> Muthamitaal (2002 was the time he was scoring for both the movies, >> perhaps). This one is a sad melodious duet between Alka and >> Jayachandran. It is so good to hear jayachandran again after a long >> time and you wonder how he could have been used all this time. The >> humming that Alka does reminds you of 'Evano Oruvan' from >> Alaipaayudhey. ARR right from 'Bombay' has weaved magic with violin >> orchestra when he had to convey a tinge of sadness in the song and >> you can hear that here as well. >> >> Tu Mera Hai - Singers: Chitra, Sukhwinder Singh & Naresh Iyer >> Chitra still sounds the same as she did in Thiruda Thiruda. The song >> has quite a lot of traces of Rangeela and Pukar and those late 90s >> of ARR. Sukhwinder and Chitra is quite a combo for this song for >> their contrasting voices (like Chitra with Daler for RDB). I am not >> sure where Naresh Iyer figures in the song. A throwback to ARR of >> 90s. >> >> Overall it is a very good album though there are numbers like Tu >> Mera Hai, Gulfisha, Gum Sum that gives away the fact that the album >> was done more than 5 years back. Ishq Ada is the experimental track >> and is way ahead of times. It takes the credit of my 'Song of the >> Album' and that along with 'Meherbaan' is my 2 picks of the album. >> >> >> ------------------------------ >> Bring your gang together. Do your thing. Find your favourite Yahoo! >> Group.<http://in.rd..yahoo.com/tagline_groups_9/*http://in.promos.yahoo.com/groups/> >> >> > > -- All the good praise goes to the Almighty http://www.arrahman-online.com
