I think it belongs to ARR, Gulzar and Sukhwinder in that order. After ARR's Music, it is the simple and catchy phrase JaiHo and its strong meaning is the one which made an impact at Academy Jury. Sukhi sung very well, but really what the jury is looking is creative music and influencial words. Without discounting any of Sukhi's talent..
--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "Jahanzeb Farooq" <jahanzebti...@...> wrote: > > > Gulzar Saab would also like make mention of Sukhwinder who sang > the Oscar-winning song Jai ho. No one else is mentioning him. He > is an integral part of Jai ho. Of course, Rahman is the most > important part of the song. But after that Sukhwinder and I are > also important components in the song. > > i completely agree. poor Sukhwinder is completely being ignored. come > on people he is the main singer of the winner song, give him some > importance. after ARR composed the song, this is he who rocked it and > made it what it is today. he deserves much. and as i said already, ARR > should have mentioned/thanked him while receiving the award. i think > he forgot. i must say after ARR the person whom this song belongs the > most is Sukhwinder. > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Prakash Balaramkrishna > <prakysnaky@> wrote: > > > > http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/Entertainment/Ek-Oscar-Lo-Ek- > Muft-Gulzar/articleshow/4187879.cms > > > > With > > all the bouquets my home has literally become 'Gulzar'. The > Rahman-Gulzar jodi > > can truly be captioned > > Gulzar More Pics > > Jai > > ho.â > > > > Speaking on A R Rahmanâs two > > Oscars, Gulzar Saab chuckles mischievously. âItâs like the > song I > > wrote for Guru for him Ek lo ek muft. He got one Oscar and then > the other > > one was a bonus. Happily Iâm part of the second > > one.â > > > > Gulzar Saab was not in Los > > Angeles when the double Oscar for Slumdog Millionaire including > one for a > > song Jai ho written by the poet-extraordinaire was > > announced. > > > > In fact he wasnât even > > watching the Oscars when the Oscar for Jai ho > > announced. > > > > âForget about me. I feel > > very proud of > > Rahman ... always have always will. I think Rahman brought a change > to Indian film songs, > > and for years. He gave a new form to the film song. This > recognition at the > > Oscars proves that he has made a world of difference to the > Hindi film > > song. Otherwise classical Indian music was always known globally > even before > > the fim song.â > > > > Gulzar Saab reminisces on Rahman. > > âI started noticing his pathbreaking numbers when he did his > first > > score with me in Dil Se. But even before that he was doing > pioneering work. > > When I heard the announcement for his first Oscar I got a lump > in my > > throat. It was enough for me. I got up and left the room. I > didnât > > know my song Jai ho won the Oscar. My son-in-law Govind came > and hugged > > me and said, âItâs won a double Oscar . One for your > > song.â > > > > Gulzar Saab feels the double Oscar > > is a benchmark for our cinema. âIt makes Indian cinema a part > of > > world cinema, just like there are Asian awards that make us part of > Asian > > cinema. Oscars certainly put us under a global gaze. Since the > Oscars are > > American our Indian films never before went into mainstream > categories. Slumdog > > Millionaire has opened up doors for our cinema > > .â > > > > Gulzar Saab is also very proud of > > the Oscar given to Resul Pookutty for sound mixing. âRahmanâ > s > > Oscar we all expected. Iâm happy to be part of his second Oscar. > But > > Resulâs recognition is a breakthrough for all technicians in > Indian > > cinema.â > > > > Gulzar Saab would also like make > > mention of Sukhwinder who sang the Oscar-winning song Jai ho. > âNo > > one else is mentioning him. Heâs an integral part of Jai ho. Of > course, > > Rahman is the most important part of the song. But after that > Sukhwinder and > > I are also important components in the > > song.â > > > > So why wasnât he at the > > Oscars ceremony? > > Because,â > > Gulzar Saab deadpans, âI didnât have a black coat and no > lawyer > > was willing to lend me a size that fitted. I was too nervous to > attend > > without a black coat.â > > > > Press him a little further he comes > > out with the truth, âMy right shoulder got hurt while playing > tennis. > > I pulled a muscle two weeks ago. Iâm going through therapy. Iâ > ve > > a tennis tournament on March 1. Hopefully, my physiotherapist will > allow me. > > Iâll play even if I lose. But I didnât want us to lose at the > > Oscars.â > > >