When The Pussycat Dolls shot to worldwide fame after they released their dance hit "Don't Cha," perhaps above and beyond the other group members, critics and fans adored Queen Doll Nicole Scherzinger.
Now, four years later, it seems that the group's lead vocalist receives more negative criticism than support. On sites like YouTube and other message board forums, countless of "fans" accuse Nicole of constantly providing lead vocals while other vocally talented members, most notably Melody Thornton, rarely, if ever, sing. But why does that still surprise people? When the group originally signed their record deal, Nicole was specifically given the role of lead singer. At no point were Thornton, Jessica Sutta, Ashley Roberts, Kimberly Wyatt or ex-member Carmit Bachar given equal status in the group. So yes, while the name Nicole and The Pussycat Dolls may be more suitable, I have yet to hear the other Dolls complain that they are just merely background dancers to Nicole. And let's face it, neither of the other members have any reason to complain. They knew what their role would be right from the gecko. On numerous occasions and in several interviews, founder Robin Antin emphasized that she wanted The Pussycat Dolls to comprise of a leader singer and backup members. No shock there whatsoever. Yet, Nicole continuously gets lashed for fulfilling her rolea job that I do not think the other members could live up to. Melody has an outstanding voice but it is not as strong or versatile as Nicole's. Nicole's vocals are more seductivea key ingredient that makes the PCD so successful. However, should Nicole ever want to quit the group, Melody is the only other member that has the potential to succeed as the lead vocalist. When it comes to physical appearance, Jessica, perhaps, is even more naturally beautiful than Nicole. However she is not nearly as secure as her and the natural confidence Nicole exudes cannot be taught. Ashley and Kimberly are, in my view, the group's best dancers. But that's just it. Both ladies are dancers above singers. Thus, they do not have the entire package to bring the same commercial success to the group if either provided the lead vocals. And while I will admit that the other group members are the reason why The Pussycat Dolls are still loved by fans, Nicole is the reason why the group is still topping music charts. Unlike the other members, Nicole penned some of the group's best hits. Without her, the group would have a difficult time surviving. But I will also admit that even Nicole has her own flaws. I am still puzzled on how it's possible for Nicole to butcher and mispronounce the words to "Jai Ho." When A. R. Rahman correctly sings the words in the remix only to have Nicole belt "Jay Ho" right after, pains me. Who taught her how to read? But like I said. Even Nicole has flaws. But I still love her. http://www.andpop.com/2009/04/11/rant-n-rave-nicole-scherzinger/
