Axton,

( I hope BMC lawyers ok'ed the use of the libs that were selected....
So I bet a sharp legal mind (or 10) reviewed/approved such decision
long before they shipped the software.)

Not that I am an expert about this stuff...

However, I thought the point of LGPL (vs GPL) was to allow for
commercial tools to use the LGPL code without the need for them to be
GPL'ed. (That is as much a question as a statement.) However that is
only if your commercial code can use the library "as is"(without any
change). If you have to change the library then any changes you make
to the library have to be "LGPL" and contributed back to the LGPL
project. (Well, offered as a contribution. The maintainer of the
project can refuse the changes too.)

REF: http://www.gnu.org/licenses/why-not-lgpl.html
"
The GNU Project has two principal licenses to use for libraries. One
is the GNU Lesser GPL; the other is the ordinary GNU GPL. The choice
of license makes a big difference: using the Lesser GPL permits use of
the library in proprietary programs; using the ordinary GPL for a
library makes it available only for free programs.
"

I think the point is: "The application is then generally a derivative
work of the library. So, the copyright holder for the library must
authorize distribution of the work. The LGPL permits this
distribution."  which I read to mean.... LGPL allows you to use and
distribute the library as part of a derivative work. However, I find
the phrasing more than a bit confusing as to if you also need the
copyright holder's permission as well. I think however the idea is
that LGPL is "permission" to distribute as part of a derivative work.

-- 
Carey Matthew Black
Remedy Skilled Professional (RSP)
ARS = Action Request System(Remedy)

Love, then teach
Solution = People + Process + Tools
Fast, Accurate, Cheap.... Pick two.


On Jan 2, 2008 9:33 AM, Axton <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> ** The 7.1 java api includes the RemoteTea ONC/RPC library, which is
> released in the GNU GPL v2 or later.  The GPL license requires that the
> source of any software that distributes this library have it's source made
> publicly available.
>
> The software in question (oncrpc.jar):
> http://remotetea.sourceforge.net/
>
> http://remotetea.sourceforge.net/javadoc/org/acplt/oncrpc/server/package-summary.html
>
> [EMAIL PROTECTED] /usr/ar/sundev71/api/lib]$ jar -tvf oncrpc.jar
>      0 Wed Aug 22 19:16:16 EDT 2007 META-INF/
>    106 Wed Aug 22 19:16:14 EDT 2007 META-INF/MANIFEST.MF
>      0 Wed Aug 22 19:16:12 EDT 2007 org/
>      0 Wed Aug 22 19:16:12 EDT 2007 org/acplt/
>      0 Wed Aug 22 19:16:14 EDT 2007 org/acplt/oncrpc/
> ...
>
> The classes distributed in oncrpc.jar, which are included with arserver, are
> obviously part of the GPL licensed software.
>
> While all Java classes are dynamically loaded at runtime, directly
> referenced classes are also used at compile time, and thus might be
> considered in violation of the GPL.  Am I missing something here?
>
> Some commentary on the subject:
> http://www.stylusstudio.com/xmldev/200411/post40360.html
> http://www.fsf.org/licensing/licenses/lgpl-java.html
> http://www.gnu.org/licenses/lgpl-java.html
> http://www.debian.org/doc/manuals/debian-java-faq/ch5.html#s5.3.4
> http://www.stylusstudio.com/xmldev/200411/post80430.html
>
> To quote the first link:
> "It has always been the FSF's position that dynamically linking applications
> to libraries creates a single work derived from both the library code and
> the application code. The GPL requires that all derivative works be licensed
> under the GPL, an effect which can be described as "hereditary." So, if an
> application links to a library licensed under the GPL, the application too
> must be licensed under the GPL. By contrast, libraries licensed under the
> GNU Lesser General Public License (LGPL) may be linked to proprietary
> applications.
> ...
>
>
>  The typical arrangement for Java is that each library an application uses
> is distributed as a separate JAR (Java Archive) file. Applications use
> Java's "import" functionality to access classes from these libraries. When
> the application is compiled, function signatures are checked against the
> library, creating a link. The application is then generally a derivative
> work of the library. So, the copyright holder for the library must authorize
> distribution of the work. The LGPL permits this distribution."
>
> Seeking feedback from people that are a bit more knowledgeable on the
> subject.
>
> Axton Grams

_______________________________________________________________________________
UNSUBSCRIBE or access ARSlist Archives at www.arslist.org
Platinum Sponsor: www.rmsportal.com ARSlist: "Where the Answers Are"

Reply via email to