All my lisps finished, reports are updated. The summary remains the same. The lisp tested:
abcl-1.2.1-fasl42-linux-x86 abcl-1.3.0-fasl42-linux-x86 abcl-1.3.1-fasl42-linux-x86 abcl-1.3.2-fasl42-linux-x86 ccl-1.10-r16196-f96-linux-x86 ccl-1.8-r15286m-f95-linux-x86 ccl-1.9-r15756-f96-linux-x86 clisp-2.49-unix-x86 cmu-snapshot-2014-01__20e_unicode_-linux-x86 cmu-snapshot-2014-05-dirty__20e_unicode_-linux-x86 cmu-snapshot-2014-12___20f_unicode_-linux-x86 ecl-13.5.1-unknown-linux-i686-bytecode ecl-13.5.1-unknown-linux-i686-lisp-to-c ecl-15.2.21-ee989b97-linux-i686-bytecode ecl-15.2.21-ee989b97-linux-i686-lisp-to-c sbcl-1.0.58-linux-x86 sbcl-1.1.11-linux-x86 sbcl-1.1.16-linux-x86 sbcl-1.2.6-linux-x86 Best regards, - Anton 13.07.2015, 17:52, "Anton Vodonosov" <avodono...@yandex.ru>: > 13.07.2015, 05:01, "Robert P. Goldman" <rpgold...@sift.net>: >> I'm afraid I've forgotten: would you please send out the results URL(a)? > > Ah, sorry, you were not CC'ed. > > Faré contacted me for help when he wanted to run cl-test-grid > tests himself, and we ended up testing that version (d70a8f8). > > The reports for the current version (c3f7c73) are below. > > The summary is that I see no errors caused by new ASDF. > > The only regression you may be interested in is "COMMON-LISP:TYPE-ERROR : > value NIL is not of the expected type STRUCTURE." > occurring on CCL 1.8. > > It happens because (I think) new ASDF restores special variable values > after .asd file is loaded. > > CCL 1.8 initializes *PRINT-PPRINT-DISPATCH* to NIL, causing > (SET-PPRINT-DISPATCH ...) to fail with this error, unless > somebody initialized *PRINT-PPRINT-DISPATCH* e.g. by > (COPY-PPRINT-DISPATCH NIL) > > This is CCL bug #784 (and duplicated as #960). > > The file ~/quicklisp/dists/quicklisp/software/nst-4.0.2/ext/defdoc/defdoc.asd > uses this workaround. But with new ASDF, when one of it's fasl files is loaded > (nst-4.0.3/ext/defdoc/lisp/core/output.lx32fsl), *PRINT-PPRINT-DISPATCH* is > nil. > I.e. the workaround has no effect. > > The reports: > > Full diff https://common-lisp.net/project/cl-test-grid/asdf/asdf-diff-47.html > > As you see, there are many "improvements" on old lisps just because > many systems use new ASDF features not provided by the ASDF version > shipped with those old lisp impls. > > For convenience, here is the diff report including only the tests > which fail on new ASDF: > https://common-lisp.net/project/cl-test-grid/asdf/asdf-diff-48.html > > I marked by yellow notes the failures I think not necessary to consider. > > Some tests are still running, I will report as they finish. > > Best regards, > - Anton > >>> On Jul 12, 2015, at 20:34, Anton Vodonosov <avodono...@yandex.ru> wrote: >>> >>> 10.07.2015, 12:20, "Anton Vodonosov" <avodono...@yandex.ru>: >>>> 10.07.2015, 06:06, "Faré" <fah...@gmail.com>: >>>>> Dear lispers, >>>>> >>>>> we're ready to bless ASDF 3.1.4.25 as release 3.1.5, and now is a good >>>>> time to test it before it's too late. Anton, do you have time and/or >>>>> resource for a run of cl-test-grid? >>>> >>>> Yes, I've started the tests. >>> >>> Some lisps are finished already: >>> >>> abcl-1.3.2-fasl42-linux-x86 >>> ccl-1.10-r16196-f96-linux-x86 >>> ccl-1.8-r15286m-f95-linux-x86 >>> ccl-1.9-r15756-f96-linux-x86 >>> clisp-2.49-unix-x86 >>> cmu-snapshot-2014-01__20e_unicode_-linux-x86 >>> cmu-snapshot-2014-05-dirty__20e_unicode_-linux-x86 >>> cmu-snapshot-2014-12___20f_unicode_-linux-x86 >>> ecl-13.5.1-unknown-linux-i686-bytecode >>> ecl-13.5.1-unknown-linux-i686-lisp-to-c >>> ecl-15.2.21-ee989b97-linux-i686-bytecode >>> sbcl-1.0.58-linux-x86 >>> sbcl-1.1.11-linux-x86 >>> sbcl-1.1.16-linux-x86 >>> sbcl-1.2.6-linux-x86 >>> >>> So far I see no difference from the git version d70a8f8 >>> we tested recently (off the mailing lists). >>> >>> Other (elder) lisps are still running. I will report as they finish. >>> >>> Best regards, >>> - Anton