At 4:48 PM -0600 1/27/06, Ram Sarangapani wrote:
C'da,
I saw what Himen da was addressing. many feel that things like Valentine Day are popular Because its a western import. 'Go West, young man, go West' is as valid today as it was decades ago.
Ram:
*** I realize that, and have sympathy for Himen-da's angst.I do
too. Not so much for going 'west' but for a ridiculous fixation
on everything that 'seem' western.
But my question here is about assertion of a false and prudish
notion that Indians are somehow above the sensual, that it is
morally aberrant to
the " Indian heritage", which is shrouded in "
austerity", ( read hidden, surreptitious, suppressed).
We are the old folks now. But remember how we were :-)? And I
would submit, that barring the few and rare libidinously challenged,
we were all the same.And I would bet a rupee that our previous
generations were hardly any different. I was personally a victim
of having been falsely accused ( obviously because I did not learn how
to keep my mouth shut and play goody-two-shoes) and forced to defend
myself in an inquisition ( an inquisition magnet--my life's story!) by
the moral police at IIT-KGP-- conducted by none other than the
Director himself, no doubt on the basis of snitching by somebody whose
'austere' sensitivities were offended by some kids cavorting at Digha
beach. And yours truly wasn't even close to the revellers. Talk about
doubly deprived! The only consolation was my department Chairman, an
enlightened man, who mumbled something about 'dirty-old-men'
meddling with what is none of their business. He was ticked off
because he too was asked for explanations, probably for
dereliction of dictatorial duties, since the accused were all from his
department.
The moral of the story ? The standards applied to judge
desi-modesty are figments of idle imaginations. History proves
otherwise. Just because something is hidden does not mean it is not
there or unnatural. In fact the suppression of normal and civil
outlets produces far more corrosive effects as are amply evident in
desi-society.
c-da
Indian's and others in the sub-continent, Taiwanese/Singapore etc also are very quick to embrace western culture and sometimes at the expense of their own.
Now, to your questions:
>>----It is rather unfortunate that the Saint Valentine's Day is misunderstood in many parts of India as >>something western, something sensual, something alien to the idea of austerity, an essential >>trait in Indian heritage.
>Is it an accurate statement, or is at an attempt at revising history, intentionally or out of ignorance?
>>----and a celebration of sensuality..
>Is it un-Indian in the historical context as we are led to believe ?
I think SV day is Western (German, I think), its commercial and all that.
Is it alien to Indian Heritage?
I think it is - inspite of the fact that one may find numerous examples of Indians (and others) being prententious about sex. Many portray themselves as prudes, but could be just the opposite outside.
But why do people have to pretend? - because Indian society and heritage does look down upon open displays of sexual freedoms. In that sense, something like SV day is alien.
But I do not see the harm in it - its good for business, cards, flowers etc, etc. It also gives a wider choice to consumers who wish to spend money on such things.
>>----and a celebration of sensuality..
I don't know about this. Even in this country, I don't think the spirit is in celebrating sensuality.
--Ram
On 1/27/06, Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
Ram:
The question is whether these are a part of India's cultural history ?
And if they are, how do you relate them to HT's opening paragraph:
>----It is rather unfortunate that the Saint Valentine's Day is misunderstood in many parts of India as something western, something sensual, something alien to the idea of austerity, an essential trait in Indian heritage.Is it an accurate statement, or is at an attempt at revising history, intentionally or out of ignorance?
>----and a celebration of sensuality..
Is it un-Indian in the historical context as we are led to believe ?
c-da
At 1:15 PM -0600 1/27/06, Ram Sarangapani wrote:
C'da,
>But what about Konarak, Khajuraho and the debauchery of the gods as recorded in the >mythologies/scriptures fit in ?
Again these too are art forms. One has to also take into account that value systems have changed a lot since those times.
For example, the Spartans were very much at ease with homosexuality, the Greeks, Romans were famous for their orgies. I would guess the same has been the case with Konarak/Khajuraho.
If these got into Hindu scriptures (which I am not it has), I would say that the scriptures just depicted what was considered 'normal' (not deviant) in those days.
If the Bible or other religious texts only included Christians being thrown to the lions, but excluding the debauchery that existed in Rome, shows that the authors may not have wanted to depict reality. An important point being that the Bible has been rewritten/edited many times and thus catering to the views/opinions of the time (King James as opposed to the Old Testament).
again my just my thoughts.
--Ram
On 1/27/06, Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
You may be right on those two counts Ram. I have to make some distinction there.
But what about Konarak, Khajuraho and the debauchery of the gods as recorded in the mythologies/scriptures fit in ?
c-da
At 11:32 AM -0600 1/27/06, Ram Sarangapani wrote:
C'da,
> ** Where did the Kama-Sutra come from?
> ** Or the culture of Yoni Pujas and the pervasive worshipping
> of Shiva's you-know-what?
Isn't there a difference between brazen displays of sexuality and those that in art form?
The Kama-Sutra, I suppose is recognized as an art form. Compare it to Michelangelo or other European art forms, I don't see much difference in which art is viewed.
With reference to Hindus praying to the Gods represented by ... whatever,
from what I understand, the Shiva ........ is NOT so much a brazen representation of a sex object but more spiritual and for praying to the Gods for human preservation, procreation, health etc.
Just my thoughts
--Ram
On 1/27/06, Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
While I am with Himen-da on his revulsion with the abject commercialism associated with this particular imported day of celebrations in India, once again I have questions about attempts to deny and revise history:
** Where did the Kama-Sutra come from?
** As a student of architecture I had the -- um-- opportunity
( or do I have a singularly impure body/mind?) of ogling the
eye-popping sculpture depicting mass orgies of debauchery by
desis of a distant past ( pardon my propensity for alliteration
this morning) at the Sun Temple at Konarak, not too far from
that holiest of holy Hindu sites--Bhubaneswar. Is that a desi-heritage
, or was it yet another result of some phoren invaders military
or corporate or religious or cultural, despoiling them desi-minds ?
** Or the culture of Yoni Pujas and the pervasive worshipping
of Shiva's you-know-what?
** What is the basis of the entire Tantric movement--faith,
art, literature?
** And the glorified and recorded debauchery of the gods and
goddesses as widely recorded in Hindu mythology?
** What is the basis of the Kamakhya temple's origin? Need I
repeat it here in mixed company?
Echoing uncle scrooge, I say, bah humbug! It is an eruption of Victorian
puritanism and attempts at hiding what could not be hidden.
:-)
At 11:40 PM -0500 1/26/06, Himendra Thakur wrote:
MISUNDERSTANDING St. VALENTINE'S DAY
An article by
Himendra Thakur [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Boston, Massachusetts, USA
It is rather unfortunate that the Saint Valentine's Day is misunderstood in many parts of India as something western, something sensual, something alien to the idea of austerity, an essential trait in Indian heritage. Various Hindu activist groups have adopted tough plans to attack any celebration of St. Valentine's Day in India.
The distortion of the real meaning of St. Valentine's Day was possibly initiated by an irresponsible "Bollywood" movie star who thrived in Indian movie business of copying everything from America (like they copied the name "Hollywood" just as a token of their intellectual bankruptcy.) They twisted the St. Valentine's Day into a celebration of sensuality. The first victims were adolescents, highly vulnerable to anything new. Some multinational companies (MNC) of India too eager to sell their products are now spending millions of their advertisement dollars to promote Valentine's Day as a free-sex disco party targeted to the rising tempo of sensuality among adolescents. Even the government tourism departments appear to be caught in the same business by sponsoring "love-parks" to increase their profit dollars, ironically required by the new policy of running the Indian government as a commercial enterprise.
The idea behind these commercial disco parties where MNCs peddle free-sex sensuality to celebrate Valentine's Day is exactly what Saint Valentine tried to stop 1737 years ago. He was beaten and beheaded on February 14, 269 AD under the orders of Roman Emperor Marcus Aurelius Claudius Gothicus, also known as Claudius II.
Forgetting the stoic teachings of his ancestor Marcus Aurelius (121-180 AD), Emperor Claudius II (214-270 AD) placed himself in a big hurry to expand his empire. He needed a large army. He allured new recruits with wine-women-wealth, which they would be able to loot in the occupied territories. Thinking that unmarried young men would make better soldiers, the Emperor banned all marriages. "You want women? You want sex? Join my partyS you'll get all" appear to be a modern disco-party equivalent of what was said by Emperor's recruiters 1737 years ago.
An old Christian monk named Valentine (he was not declared as a Saint at that time) decided to work against the Emperor's ban on marriage. His argument was simple: young people would give their lives to defend their motherland. But, just to fulfill Emperor's craving to subdue other countries, they would not give up plans of their lives which were much more precious than wine-women-wealth. Joy did not depend upon the quantity of wine consumed. Happiness could not be purchased with ill-gotten wealth. Love was much superior to debauched sexual sensuality.
Valentine secretly solemnized the marriages of those young couple who wanted to marry in violation of Emperor's orders. Marriage was love culminated into commitment: and a set of promises : that we would be together, taking care of each other "till death do us part."
Very soon Valentine was caught by the Roman soldiers. He was thrown into the dungeon. When he was waiting for his death, the young couples married by him used to come to see him, and cry. Apparently, the jailer helped these young people to see him. They were consoled and cheered by the doomed man. They were surprised that he was happily ready to die for the truth. The jailer's daughter took care of the old man. When the last day came and soldiers dragged him away to the chopping block, he quickly scrawled a note on a crumbled piece of paper and gave it to the jailer's daughter "From your Valentine!" That was the first Valentine Card. The date was February 14, 269 AD.
No wonder in America today fathers give Valentine Cards to their daughters. Brothers, sisters, aunts, uncles give Valentine Cards to each other. The idea is to uphold pure love as the highest treasure of humankind. As the bedrock of a family, the institution of marriage is the climax of love and commitment between a man and a woman.
The institution of marriage, and not free-sex sensuality, was the strong undertone of St. Valentine's martyrdom. Instead of disco parties, these MNCs could have organized mass marriage of young couples in India without pomp and show and dowry on the Valentine's Day and call it Bahu Divas (Daughter-in-laws' Day) as a tribute to real family values. In fact, "Antarjyoti" a social organization in India, has been celebrating St. Valentine's Day every year since 2004 by holding "Bahu Divas" as a mark of respect to the institution of marriage. By felicitating a daughter-in-law as grihalaxmi (wealth of the family), they uphold the value of marriage and value of family. In India, a village is considered as an extended family. Every daughter-in-law is seen as the wealth of the village, gramalaxmi. Verily this makes her deshalaxmi, wealth of the country, because she brings the future generation.
In addition to the social significance, it must be admitted that, for a successful marriage, the prerequisite is love and commitment between the couple. A marriage must not be ruined by considerations of race, caste, financial status, dowry, or premarital sex. Purity of the body is a strong basis of commitment.
On December 1, 2005, on World AID Day, I attended a rally in Durban, organized by Arya Pratinidhi Sabha of South Africa, against the epidemic of AID. I was appalled to hear about the tragedy of the AID epidemic in that country. It appears that the problem is horrific also in India. It was reported that all the physical approaches to contain the epidemic have failed so far. The only answer is purity of the body. It seems humankind will be facing extinction unless all countries accept the principle of the purity of human body as a statutory idea. A strong vow of love and commitment for marriage will convince the adolescents and future generations to keep the body pure.
The MNCs who are promoting free-sex in their disco parties in India are pushing the humankind towards extinction which they do not mind as long as they make their money. They can be stopped only by the younger generation who must understand the correct meaning of St. Valentine's Day S love and commitment for marriage.
This is truly the Indian tradition.
[End]
_______________________________________________
assam mailing list
[email protected]
http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org
_______________________________________________
assam mailing list
[email protected]
http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org
_______________________________________________ assam mailing list [email protected] http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org
