Re: 'Islam and Pluralism'-A debate: My second response to Mr. Halim.
http://www.bangladesh-web.com/news/view.php?hidDate=2007-02-23&hidType=OPT&hidRecord=0000000000000000151956 Thursday February 22 2007 20:48:35 PM BDT <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> By Syed Kamran Mirza, USA <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> "One man's faith is another man's delusion"—By Dr. Anthony Storr (1920-2001). This is my reply to Mr. A.H. Halim, Bangladesh, to his response posted in NFB on February 12, 2007. Many thanks for your kind response to my critiques of your article on Islamic pluralism. I must appreciate your desperate quest of convincing me that Qur'an is not a book of contradictions and inconsistencies! With full respect to your opinion I beg to differ with you 100%, but at this response I will not highlight my disagreements about Quranic contradictions; I will leave it for our future discourse. In this response, I will rebut very selectively some of your points/comments that you have presented to my attention. I will name your points as "Issue" which will follow my response. Issue: "Qur'an says anybody who does not believe in Islam (Jews, Christians, Hindus, Pagans, and non-believers) are spiritually unclean and not necessarily bodily un-clean"!!! My response: According to you—Qur'an or Allah speaks not about bodily un-cleanness, rather Allah speaks about so called spiritual un-cleanness. That is, anybody who disbelief "Islam" is bound to be unclean and worst creatures and destined to go to hell! What an incredible symbol of Islamic tolerance and pluralism! Anybody who disbeliefs Islamic theory of God and religion is "Unclean and worst creatures"! This is, of course, as per your choice of interpretations by famous Islamic scholars! Now, let us judge by conventional logic. I hope you are an intelligent, educated, compassionate and tolerant human being to say the least. I am hoping that you will definitely agree with my analogy here. We all know and agree 100% that religions in general are sets of belief system (blind-faith) followed by X-numbers of humans. We have hundreds of various religions and cults. At least we can take some of these major organized religions (Hinduism, Judaism, Christianity, Buddhism, and Islam) for our discussion here. We also know that, believers or followers of one religion do not believe the very theme of other religion or religions at all. Had it been untrue then there would have been only one religion exists in the whole world. The ultimate truth is—"one man's faith is another man's delusion" as said by Dr. Anthony Storr. You will also agree with me that devout Muslims do not believe what devout Christians do believe, and vice-versa. Same is the case with Buddhism, Hinduism and Judaism of course. Now, according to your ridiculous theory or, excuse of Quranic Tafsir by some renown Islamic scholars—a Muslim who does not believe Christianity is "unclean"; a Christian who does not believe in Islam is "unclean"; a Jew who does not believe in Hinduism is "unclean" and of course, a Hindu who does not believe in Islam is "unclean and worst creatures indeed, at least spiritually, as your scholars claimed! How would you like if a devout Hindu calls you "unclean and worst creature" for the same reason? What proof or proofs do you have that your religion is the only truth? Like all others, your belief system also standing on the ground of simple blind-faith having myriads of superstitions and logical absurdities and nothing else! Same is all other religions. Even, those so called "un-believers" also a believer in a sense that they believe that all those organized religions are false because they (organized religionists) believe in 100% unproven superstitious imaginary God. This is also a kind of 'belief system' civilized world should recognize and respect. So, who can say who is unclean or clean? Could you tell me Mr. Halim? Issue: "Holy Quran must be read by the help of various Quranic interpretations by some famous Islamic scholars. And I have quoted mostly part of verses of the Quran which has confused matter further." My response: So, according to you holy Qur'an can not be read and understood by the gullible Muslims unless he/she can first memorize Quranic interpretations done by all those so called Islamic scholars! Is not Allah says in Quran that, "I made Qur'an very clear, simple and easy and written in Arabic (44:58, 54:22, 54:32, 54:40) so that Muslims (Arabs of course) can understand very easily?" Please listen what Merciful Allah says in Qur'an: " But We have indeed made the Qur'an easy to understand and remember: then is there any that will receive admonition? (54:22); and "We have made it a Qur'an in Arabic, that ye may be able to understand and learn wisdom (43:3)". Allah emphatically declared that He made Quran very easy so that Muslims can understand very easily. No where in the Quran Allah says that my words must be read with the help of Quranic interpretations and commentaries! Quranic Interpretations and Tafsirs have been invented by some wishful educated Mullahs only to hide Quranic absurdities and contradictions. In fact, Quranic verses are mostly simple to understand and any elementary student can understand very easily. Could you show us where in the Quran Allah instructed pukka Muslims to read Quran with the help of tafsirs or interpretations? In fact, Allah asked Muslims to believe Quran's literal meaning and clearly forbade any interpretations of Allah's eternal divine words. Quranic verse: 3:7—clearly prohibited to accept anybody's interpretation of Allah's eternal words. Please read this verse below: (Quran-3:7)— "He it is Who has revealed the Book to you; some of its verses are clear and decisive, they are the basis of the Book, and others are allegorical; then as for those in whose hearts there is perversity they follow the part of it which is allegorical, seeking to mislead and seeking to give it (their own) interpretation. but none knows its interpretation except Allah, and those who are firmly rooted in knowledge say: We believe in it, it is all from our Lord; and none do mind except those having understanding." Now, what you have to say to us about this above verse Mr. Halim? Besides, if the Holy Quran (the ultimate guidance for Muslims) was so difficult to understand, then what was the purpose of giving such a difficult book by Allah? Of course, non-Arab Muslims can not understand meanings of Qur'an simply because they don't know Arabic and they are just parroting Qur'an without understanding a single word. One way it is good that because of the fact that gullible Muslims do not understand what they are reading, we have less numbers of Islamic terrorists (al-Qaeda jihadis) than the Arab nations. My citation of Quranic verse was complete to give ultimate messages of those verses and was never confusing to the readers. Any sane Quranic readers will agree with me that, each Quranic verse is independent and contains complete message, and normally has no connection to the next verse, with rare exception. Mostly the next verse deals with completely a separate issue. What I cited was enough to give the ultimate message by the verse, and giving entire remaining verse will never change the meaning of "killing unbelievers" into "kissing unbelievers" isn't it Mr. Halim? So, this is only a lame excuse! Issue: Quran have "peace time verses" and "war time verses"!!! My response: Every devout Muslims and all gullible Muslims do believe the book of Quran as the "Eternal and infallible words of Allah" which are good and applicable until the judgment day (doom's day). Where in the Quran Allah says that following verses are "peacetime or wartime" verses? Could you show us just one verse like that? I will not accept any tafsir or interpretation for this. You have to show us verse from Allah. Where in the Quran Allah says—do not apply these verses now because I sent these when my favorite Prophet was busy fighting (peacefully?) with Pagans/ non-believers? Or, following verses are now "out of context"? How your so called interpretation can change the Quranic word "to kill" into "to kiss", could you show us the "mechanism" Mr. Halim? Finally, please give us some clue why those pukka Muslims, I mean, those al-Qaeda jihadis of Osama-bin-laden (OBL) should believe your damage-control interpretation? Finally, when Allah clearly and emphatically says, "Quranic words are easy to understand by any Muslims and do not interpret to misguide (Quran-3:7)" how and under what authority some educated hypocritical Muslims could say that, "Quran is very difficult and must be read with the help of interpretations?" Say, I buy your ridiculous logic of so called "peacetime" or "wartime" verses in Quran. Now, could you tell us why Muslims are parroting (reciting during prayers) these heinously hateful and cruel wartime verses, at least five times a day, around the globe? What purpose these cruel verses accomplishing now and why innocent children of Madrasshas are routinely poisoned by these ill teachings? Why those heinous verses are not removed from the Qur'an? We have past 1400 years with this book of Quran and still we do not understand this simple book. Only Allah knows when Muslims will understand this book of Qur'an clearly! Issue: "There is no disagreement even among the non-Muslim scholars that Islam rejects forced conversion." My response: This is indeed an absurd claim by you. Historically, from the very inception, Islam was propagated by wars, intimidation and force conversion. Conversion of the entire mankind into Islam is the main slogan of Islam, period. This issue needs much elaboration and I don't think I have that scope here now. I will leave it for our future discourse, if you agree. Only thing I will assure you that I can easily prove that you are dead wrong in this, and truth is Islam never rejects conversion; rather Islam loves conversion business. Do you know what is the main objective of Tablig-e-Jamat? Ask any Tabligi Muslim about it. Here is the Allah's decree for mankind which will tell all truth and nothing but the truth about the motive of peaceful Islam: Quran-3:85- "If anyone desires a religion other than Islam (submission to Allah), never will it be accepted of him; and in the Hereafter He will be in the ranks of those who have lost (All spiritual good)." Mr. Halim, you please tell us what is real truth about Islam? Can you give us real interpretation of the above Quranic gem for us? Issue: "If non-Muslim populations in some countries have shrunk because of their migration or conversion to Islam, how Islam can be blamed?" My response: This above quote by you is not only incorrect but it is cruelest in sense and adds salt in the wounds of non-Muslims. Mr. Halim, it is universal truth that mother land or land of birth is most favorite to any human being in the whole world. No human being wants to leave his/her motherland without any valid "reason" or "compulsion". 'Reason' is simply an economic factor because of which people migrate, such as, I myself left my mother land for better future, but still I greatly miss my motherland-Bangladesh. 'Compulsion' is force expulsion, i.e. inhabitants have no alternative but to desert their homeland due to circumstances created by the fellow majority of their own countryman. You can not claim and justify that Hindus from Pakistan and Bangladesh left for India for better economy! Had they left for Europe or USA, you could claim that. There is no scope to discuss this issue in details but in short, I can assure you that, Hindus or any minority inhabitants from Muslim majority nations leave/desert their motherland due to horrific oppression of all kinds. In my own village there were 20% Hindus and neighboring 2/3 villages there were 30-40% Hindus, and local bazars, and schools were run by them, which I still remember. I have witnessed how these Hindus were systematically driven from their lands of their fore-fathers by horrific oppressions and intimidations. Even, very recently in 2001 after the 4-party Jote Govt. came to power—world witnessed horrendous oppression of Hindus, which we read hundreds of articles in the internet. Muslims not only can not tolerate any minority of other religions; they even can not live peacefully with Muslim minorities (Shiite and Qadyani), and clear evidences you can see what is going on in Pakistan and Iraq today. By the way, it is not just some countries (you said), in fact, it is the same picture in 100% of Muslim majority nations. But it is quite opposite in non-Muslim majority nations of the world. Look just in India where minority Muslim population is rather growing. Muslims even can not integrate with the host nations of their migrating countries either. Islam is never a religion of pluralism and Qur,an speaks it very clearly. Mr. Halim I gave you many hateful verses in my first critique but you did not say anything about these verses. These verses (9: 73, 8: 39, 9: 29, 47: 4, 4: 89, 9:111, 2: 216, 8: 12, 9: 5 and 9: 39.) definitely and utterly contradicts verses Allah sent when Prophet Muhammad had only about 75 followers in Mecca and was very weak in power; and those few so called peaceful verses that you are trying to feed people (in order to erase myriads of hateful verses) are also out of context you are citing. All hateful verses came in Medina when Prophet Muhammad became mightier with his plenty of jihadis to fight those hapless Pagans (Islam called them un-believers) who also were believers in their own Gods (Polytheists). But Islam did not respect or tolerated any other religions. Please read them again and tell us—do you still believe Islam is a religion of tolerance and pluralism? Quran-3:85- "If anyone desires a religion other than Islam (submission to Allah), never will it be accepted of him; and in the Hereafter He will be in the ranks of those who have lost (All spiritual good)." Quran-5:51- "O ye who believe! Take not the Jews and the Christians for your friends and protectors. They are but friends and protectors to each other….." and also read the following (9: 73, 8: 39, 9: 29, 47: 4, 4: 89, 9:111, 2: 216, 8: 12, 9: 5 and 9: 39) verses and please tell us Islam is a religion of tolerance and pluralism! Let me ask just 3 (three) questions to Mr. Halim: Could you tell us if you consider Osama-bin-laden (the al-Qaeda Guru) a pukka (pure) Muslim? If not, could you give us five points supporting why OBL is not a good Muslim? Could you tell us if any divine God should ask human to kill another fellow human? My conclusion remains the same that Quran is replete with contradictions and absurdities which I would like to debate with you in future. When Allah Himself teaching devout Muslims that Pagans are "unclean" (9:28); non-believers are the "worst creatures" (98:6); and abode of non-believers are in the hell fire—how in the world Mr. Halim can possibly claim that "Islam is a religion of pluralism"? Can you show us one single verse from Quran that says: "You respect other religions and also non-believers alike and live together peacefully?" Mr. Halim, I hate to say that, educated and intelligent people like you have already submitted your intelligence and norms for the sake of your blind-faith in Allah and Muhammad, and that is why you fail to see the truth about Islam and Qur'an. Fact of the matter is the religion Islam is not only a religion of intolerance; rather it is the religion of isolation. Almost 100% of Islamic nations and Muslim majority countries today are having their minority populations either rapidly shrinking or even evaporating in numbers. Not only that—Muslims are unable to integrate as the immigrant in the host countries around the world indicating that Muslims by nature do not believe in Pluralism. Literature: 1.The Holy Qur'an, Translated by A. Yousuf Ali, Published by Amana Corporation, Brentwood, Maryland, 1983 xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx One can read Syed Kamran Mirza's writings in the following sites: http://www.mukto-mona.com/Articles/skm/index.htm http://www.faithfreedom.org/Author/SKM.htm BB
_______________________________________________ assam mailing list [email protected] http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org
