Alpana:

>Okay, but do we want the ten year olds to try to do that?
>By God, NO!



*** That is a lovely expression of your goodness. We can certainly take
collective pride of the fact that such a nice person is a member of our
list :-).

But what does that have to do with the price of tea in Taiwan?







>With your same logic (that India doesn't care about Assam), who should take
>the initiative to stop this violence and let our kids live a normal life,
>India or Assam?

*** Are you taking issue with a statement that YOU made up, namely :"--that
India doesn't care about Assam" ? *I* never made a statement like that. I
don't charge India of not caring for Assam. I charge that Delhi is
incapable of managing its own affairs, much less those of the far-flung
territories like Assam. I charge that India does not have the political
will to run the nation's affairs in a manner that would lead the country
out of a half century of mismanagement, corruption and anarchy. I charge
that India's acts of omission and commission gave rise to Assam's
insurgency that has riven our society for over two decades and that India
is UNWILLING to  engage in a sincere effort to find a POLITICAL soulution
the problems of Assam and the NE.

I do not recognize India's need to CARE about Asssam, or be kind to her. It
is Assam's responsibility to take care of herself, and India's to get out
of the way. And if it is unwilling to get out of the way, then to undertake
the kind of REFORMS that would benefit not just assam but the entire
country.

Why can't India do that A? And why don't people like you clamor for it? Is
it because they too realize India's impotency and fractiousness, or are
they just smug about the status quo? Or is it a paranoia that incapititates
their ability to reason , for fear that doing so would legitimize the
insurgencies?

Think about it and give us some help with these, instead of opening a
debate on the  price of tea in Taiwan :-).


c-da

*************************************************************************
This is for Anjan:


> *** Assam is NOT the arms-bazaar. It is countries like Thailand, Myanmar.
> But take a wild guess WHY there is such a market.
> Could this be stopped?
> My belief is YES.It is the Indian Govt. who can put a stop to it anyday it
> chooses to, just like it could have for two decades in the past. But it
> won't.

+++Isn't this the same as saying that the US can stop drugs from entering
the country from the drug cartels, but it won't; also that they could easily
flush out the Al Qaida and what-have-yous, but they won't because they are
all good for the democratic process and the arms trade etc..



*** Different issues Anjan. It is one thing to deal with drugs, a substance
that caters to physical pleasures. Like sex. But the insurgencies are a
result of long festering social, cultural and economic alienation. It has
taken nearly four centuries for India to open a dialog with the Nagas. Is
that justifiable?

But sooner or later it will come to that for Kashmir, for the rest of the
NE. It is in INdia's best interest to do it NOW, instead of living thru
another few centuries of bloodletting.


c

*************************************************************************


At 9:23 PM -0600 12/7/02, Alpana Sarangapani wrote:
>> *** Any firearms can be operated by a ten year old A. All you need is a
>> trigger finger. It does not make those arms any worse than those can be
>
>Okay, but do we want the ten year olds to try to do that? Do we want Assam
>to be like Lebanon from the 70/80's? and today's Israel, etc.? By God, NO!
>
>> My belief is YES.It is the Indian Govt. who can put a stop to it anyday it
>
>With your same logic (that India doesn't care about Assam), who should take
>the initiative to stop this violence and let our kids live a normal life,
>India or Assam?
>
>
>
>
>----- Original Message -----
>From: "Chan Mahanta" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>To: "Alpana Sarangapani" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>;
><[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>Sent: Saturday, December 07, 2002 9:03 PM
>Subject: Re: NE militants - from the Hindustan Times
>
>
>> >That is understood. But is that worth at all, to put the whole state -
>the
>> >lives of millions of people in jeopardy - and make your homeland the
>> >"world's busiest arms' bazaar"? where weapons are "are cheap and easy to
>> >operate even by children as young as 10 years old."? -- tell me, C'da.
>>
>>
>>
>> *** Any firearms can be operated by a ten year old A. All you need is a
>> trigger finger. It does not make those arms any worse than those can be
>> operated ONLY by adults.
>>
>>
>> *** Assam is NOT the arms-bazaar. It is countries like Thailand, Myanmar.
>> But take a wild guess WHY there is such a market.
>>
>>
>> Could this be stopped?
>>
>>
>> My belief is YES.It is the Indian Govt. who can put a stop to it anyday it
>> chooses to, just like it could have for two decades in the past. But it
>> won't.
>>
>> Is that right?
>>
>>
>> c-da
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> At 7:19 PM -0600 12/7/02, Alpana Sarangapani wrote:
>> >Hi C'da:
>> >
>> >> ** Imagine, if that had been done, as in the Kashmir, Punjab, Rajasthan
>> >> borders--Assam's disaffectiuons  would not have  the levels they did to
>> >> begin with. But then the NE is disposable, has always been. Would that
>> >same
>> >
>> >That is understood. But is that worth at all, to put the whole state -
>the
>> >lives of millions of people in jeopardy - and make your homeland the
>> >"world's busiest arms' bazaar"? where weapons are "are cheap and easy to
>> >operate even by children as young as 10 years old."? -- tell me, C'da.
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >----- Original Message -----
>> >From: "Chan Mahanta" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>> >To: "Alpana Sarangapani" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>;
>> ><[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>> >Sent: Saturday, December 07, 2002 6:04 PM
>> >Subject: Re: NE militants - from the Hindustan Times
>> >
>> >
>> >> I have no problem believing the main idea of the story.
>> >>
>> >>
>> >> > "Most of the militant outfits have offices in foreign countries under
>> >the
>> >> > banner of some human rights groups or other vague organisations  with
>> >> >support
>> >> > from forces inimical to India's interests," the commander  said
>> >requesting
>> >> > anonymity.
>> >>
>> >> ** But paragraphs like the above, leaves me wondering how much of these
>> >> dispatches are based on fact and how much on handouts of miltary press
>> >> releases.
>> >>
>> >> The unnanamed commander left the unnamed 'human rights' or 'other vague
>> >> orgs.' so incisively clear that it boggles the mind.
>> >>
>> >>
>> >>
>> >> >>"The
>> >> >> only way to check the flow of illegal arms reaching the hands of
>the
>> >> >> underground outfits is to fence the international borders and
>> >intensify
>> >> >> security vigil in the area."
>> >>
>> >> ** Imagine, if that had been done, as in the Kashmir, Punjab, Rajasthan
>> >> borders--Assam's disaffectiuons  would not have  the levels they did to
>> >> begin with. But then the NE is disposable, has always been. Would that
>> >same
>> >> attitude fly as relates to Kashmir, Punjab, Rajasthan--tell me A?
>> >>
>> >> c-da
>> >>
>> >>
>> >>
>> >>
>> >>
>> >>
>> >>
>> >>
>> >>
>> >>
>> >> At 4:45 PM -0600 12/7/02, Alpana Sarangapani wrote:
>> >> >    > India's porous and mountainous northeastern frontiers, bordering
>> >> >Myanmar and
>> >> >> Bangladesh, have become one of the world's busiest small  arms'
>> >bazaars,
>> >> >> feeding insurgencies and rebellions across South  Asia.   Out of all
>> >the
>> >> >>"rumors" and stories that we  hear, this is one of the most
>devastating
>> >> >>stories I have read about our simple  little 'Xwonor Oxom' where our
>> >near
>> >> >>and dear ones still live.    Please read on and see how you feel..how
>> >> >>people can  become so heartless and foolish at the same time:   >
>> >> >>Northeast militants seeking arms deals in SE Asia
>> >> >> Syed Zarir  Hussain (Indo-Asian News Service)
>> >> >> Guwahati, December 7
>> >> >>
>> >> >>  A number of separatist groups in northeast India have opened up
>front
>> >> >>  companies in Southeast Asia to serve as a smokescreen for their
>agents
>> >to
>> >> >> seek arms deals, officials said Saturday.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> "Quite a  large number of militant groups operating in the northeast
>> >have
>> >> >> floated  front companies in Thailand and other Southeast Asian
>cities
>> >for
>> >> >>  purchasing weapons from gunrunners," a military commander engaged
>in
>> >> >>  counter-insurgency operations in the northeast told IANS.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> "This  was revealed by some important rebel leaders arrested by
>> >security
>> >> >>  forces in the region recently."
>> >> >>
>> >> >> The frontline militant groups  said to be operating incognito in
>> >Southeast
>> >> >> Asian cities include the  outlawed United Liberation Front of Asom
>> >(ULFA),
>> >> >> the United National  Liberation Front (UNLF) and the National
>> >Liberation
>> >> >> Front of Tripura  (NLFT).
>> >> >>
>> >> >> Top leaders of the National Socialist Council of  Nagaland (NSCN),
>> >until
>> >> >> recently a banned group, have for years been  operating from Bangkok
>> >and
>> >> >> other Southeast Asian cities.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> "Most of the militant outfits have offices in foreign countries
>under
>> >the
>> >> >> banner of some human rights groups or other vague organisations
>with
>> >> >>support
>> >> >> from forces inimical to India's interests," the commander  said
>> >requesting
>> >> >> anonymity.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> India's porous and  mountainous northeastern frontiers, bordering
>> >> >>Myanmar and
>> >> >> Bangladesh,  have become one of the world's busiest small arms'
>> >bazaars,
>> >> >> feeding  insurgencies and rebellions across South Asia.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> "The  international borders along the northeast have always been a
>> >> >>  gunrunner's paradise with illegal arms consignments arriving via
>> >> >>Bangladesh
>> >> >> and Myanmar almost regularly," Mizoram Chief Minister Zoramthanga
>said.
>> >> >>"The
>> >> >> only way to check the flow of illegal arms reaching the hands of
>the
>> >> >> underground outfits is to fence the international borders and
>> >intensify
>> >> >> security vigil in the area."
>> >> >>
>> >> >> Zoramthanga was  a top militant leader of the outlawed Mizo National
>> >Front
>> >> >> before the  outfit surrendered in 1986 and entered the political
>> >mainstream.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> The region's separatist groups have long purchased arms from the
>port
>> >town
>> >> >> of Cox's Bazaar in Bangladesh.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> Most of the  weapons, including AK-47 and AK-56 assault rifles,
>> >mortars, 40
>> >> >> mm  rocket launchers, pistols, revolvers and grenades, come via the
>> >Arakans
>> >> >>  -- a mountainous area in Myanmar -- from parts of Thailand and
>> >Cambodia.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> The arms consignments are often routed by sea through the Bay of
>Bengal
>> >to
>> >> >> its destination in the Arakan forest, which is across Mizoram,
>before
>> >> >>making
>> >> >> their way to the 30-odd rebel armies operating in the  region.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> The Arakan Army, the armed wing of the Myanmarese  National United
>> >Party of
>> >> >> Arakan (NUPA), fighting a long war with the  Myanmarese junta,
>controls
>> >the
>> >> >> hilly tracts and it is through them that  the weapons are dispersed
>to
>> >the
>> >> >> many rebel groups in India's northeast  through porters.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> The UN has also expressed concern over  proliferation of smuggled
>> >> >>weapons in
>> >> >> South Asia, including India's  northeast.
>> >> >>
>> >> >> "Small arms are the weapons of choice in many of the  small regional
>> >> >> insurgencies in Pakistan, Kashmir, Sri Lanka, or rebel  movements in
>> >> >> northeastern India," a spokesman for the South Asia  Partnership,
>which
>> >> >> analyses regional security, said at the UN "The  weapons are cheap
>and
>> >easy
>> >> >> to operate even by children as young as 10  years old."
>> >> >>
>> >> >> Intelligence officials in the region have confirmed  the presence of
>> >> >> sophisticated range of weapons with militant groups in  the
>northeast,
>> >> >> including surface-to-air missiles.
>> >> >>
>> >> >>
>> >> >>
>> >> >>
>> >> >>
>> >> >>
>> >> >>
>> >> >>
>> >> >>
>> >> >>
>> >> >
>> >>
>>



Reply via email to