>To define a standard transliteration which can be used >in a computer programs with MINIMAL learning curve so >that every time a new Assamese font/ transliteration >software is developed the poor user doesnot have to >learn the whole keyboard mapping all over again....

If sincerely the above is your goal, then why for God's sake you are publishing a false set of IPA sound symbols against each Assamese letters when you have been told again and again that these are not Assamese sounds aganist these letters, and thus creating more confusion.

Rajen Barua 

>From: "S Saikia" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>Subject: [Assam] The state of affairs till now on the problem of Transliteration
>Date: Sat, 26 Jul 2003 21:30:30 -0500
>
>This some of the most important discussions i have compiled...
>
>
>
> ASSAMESE TRANSLITERATION
>
>
>PROPOSAL:
>
>I would like to propose the following as time frame for adoption of
>a "standard".
>My ideas are all preliminary and subject to change based on
>comments.
>1) The proposal that we work out here will be placed on some Web
>sites. More Web
>sites the better. We should try to publiicize the effort in in
>newspapers in Assam
>and other Assamese Web sites. I propose that for a period of three
>(?) months,
>other proposals should be accepted. This is the CFP (Call For
>Proposals) period.
>As a proposal is received it is posted in the same Web sites.
>2) All proposals obtained at this time will be discussed for a
>period of 3 (?)
>months. This is the CFC (Call For Comments) period. All comments
>received in any
>format will be posted on the same Web sites. People can send email
>or send letters
>or whatever. We can scan letters and post them on a specific Web
>site and its mirrors.
>3)After this, the proposals will be discussed (where?, I propose
>right here and a
>pre-specified Web site) say for a period of 3(?) months, and then a
>Recommendation,
>Version 1 (i.e., a "standard") is accepted.
>4) However, the Recommendation is always open for debate. Similar
>debates should
>be carried out and future versions accepted every 2-3 (?) years.
>This is essentially
>the process by which every "standard" in the computer world is being
>accepted and updated.
>
>
>Jugal Kalita
>PS: The time periods mentioned above are all my estimates. They can
>be changed.
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>PROPOSED TRANSLITERATION SCHEME:
>
>
>
>In order to overcome the obstacles in the transliteration of
>Assamese words
>I propose the following transliteration scheme mostly based on the
>standard
>devanagari ITRANS transliteration charts. This scheme is not meant
>for use
>in software program just becaue it is too complicated and scores of
>mor
>practical systems can be figured out to do the same ... The
>following is based
>on the sound of the letter in International Phonetic Alphabet and
>its equivalent
>_expression_ in English and can be used to write Assamese words in
>English...
>
>
>VOWELS
>
> Transliteration Suggested Sound/IPA _expression_
>
>1 o .............. Open-Mid Back Unrounded(Inverted a)
>2 aa ............. Open Front Unrounded (Lower case a)
>3 i .............. Close Front Unrounded (Lower case i)
>4 ii or I ........ Close Central Unrounded (Barred i)
>5 u .............. Close Back Rounded (Lower case u)
>6 uu or U ........ Close Back Un-Rounded (Turned m) (???)
>7 rri or ri....... Near- Close Front Un-Rounded (Small Capital I)
>8 e .............. Open- Mid Front Unrounded (Epsilon)
>9 oi ............. Close-Mid Central ROunded (Barred O )
>10 oo ............. Close- Mid Back Rounded (Lower Case O )
>11 ou ............. Close- Mid Back Unrounded (Baby Gamma )
>
>CONSONANTS**
>
>While introducing consonants, we do it by adding the generic form of
>the consonant with the first vowel. Since the first vowel is
>transcribed
>as /o/ instead of /a/ in this table, so all consonant-endings change
>to
>an o-ending..
>
> Transliteration Suggested Sound/IPA Symbol
>
>1 ko ............. Voiceless Velar Plosive (Lower Case K)
>2 kho ............ Aspirated Ka(???????)
>3 go ............. Voiced Velar Plosive (Lower case g)
>4 gho ............ Aspirated ga (????????)
>5 ngo or N^o ..... Voiced Uvular Nasal (Small Capital N)
>6 so ............. Voiceless Aveolar Fricative (Lower Case s)
>7 sho ............ Voiceless Post-Aveolar Fricative (Esh)
>8 jo ............. Voiced Postaveolar Fricative (Yogh)
>9 jho ............ Palatalised ja ( ja^j)
>10 jjnno or niyo .. Voiced palatal Nasal(Left tail N at left)
>11 tto or To ...... Voiceless Aveolar Plosive (Lower case T)
>12 ttho or Tho .... Aspitated Ta (tta^h)
>13 ddo or Do ...... Voiced Aveolar Plosive (Lower case D)
>14 ddho or Dho .... Aspirated Da (dda^h)
>15 nno or No....... Voiced Aveolar Nasal(Lower Case N)
>16 to ............. Voiceless Retroflex Plosive (T with Right Tail)
>17 tho ............ Aspirated ta (ta^h)
>18 do ............. Voiced Retroflex Plosive (Right Tail D)
>19 dho ............ Aspirated da(da^h)
>20 no ............. Voiced Retrofelx nasal (N with right tail)
>21 po ............. Voiceless Bilabial Plosive (Lower Case p)
>22 pho ............ Voiceless Bilabial Fricative (Phi)
>23 bo ............. Voiced Bilabial Plosive (Lower Case b)
>24 bho ............ Voiced Bilabial Fricative (Beta)
>25 mo ............. Voiced Bilabial Nasal (Lower Case M)
>26 yo ............. Voiced palatal Fricative (Curly Tail J)
>27 ro ............. Voiced Aveolar Approximant (Turned R)
>28 lo ............. Voiced Aveolar Lateral Approximant (Lower Case
>L)
>29 wo ............. Voiced RetroflexLateral Approximant(l
>withtail)(?)
>30 xho ............ Voiceless Labiodental Fricative (Lower Case F)
>31 xhho ........... Voiceless Epiglottal Fricative (Small Capital
>H)
>32 xo ............. Voiceless Uvular Fricative (Chi)
>33 ho ............. Voiceless Glottal Fricative (Lower Case H)
>34 ksho ..... ..... Aveolo-palatal Fricative (Curly Tail C)
>35 jyo ............ Voiced Palatal Approximant( Lower case J)
>36 ro(?)
>37 ro(?)
>
>
>
>
>In the above chart there has been quite a few deviations from the
>devanagari
>system. For Example the "sha, shha, sa" have been transliterated as
>"xha,
>xhha, xa" because unlike Hindi or Sanskrit, the "s" in those is
>often
>pronounced as "x" e.g. Axam in assamese instead of Asam in Hindi.
>Also the
>"va" has been transliterated as "wa" in Assamese.
>If a system like the one stated above can be agreed upon by one and
>all,
>then to transcribe Assamese words we just have to replace the
>assamese
>letters with their corresponding english group of
>alphabets..(omitting the
>the "a" in the consonants whne they appear at the end of the word).
>It will
>remove all ambiguity whatsoever on the question of how an assamese
>word s
>hould be written in English.
>The only way the system envisioned can be a success is if people
>debate over
>the transliteration and the sounds of the language until it reaches
>an acceptable
>level of accuracy. The reference to the devnagari script
>transliteration chart
>can be found at...
>>href="">http://www.angelfire.com/linux/tugg/devnagari.html
>The IPA help file which contains the IPA chart and all the sound
>files for individual
>sound for reference can be downloaded from
>>href="">http://www.sil.org/computing/speechtools/softdev2/Downloads2/SatDL2/Release2/setup-ih.exe
>or you can go to the link from
>>href="">http://www.angelfire.com/linux/tugg/devnagari.html
>
>
>
>Syamanta Saikia.
>
>
>
>DISCUSSIONS AND AGREEMENTS:
>
>ON VOWELS
>
>vowel 1:
>
>##1 is there a problem using "o" instead of "a" at the end of each
>letter?
>that is "ko" instead of "ka". to me, "ko" sounds more phonetic.
>.....Saurav da
>
>##2 The assamese sound 'a' as in axam (the Near-Open Central
>Unrounded vowel)
>is unknown to english speakers.... the sounds nearing them are:
>1. the near-open front unrounded...e.g., the 'a' in glass
>2. open front unrounded e.g., the 'a' in path ......which is
>actually the
>Assamese transcribed "aa" e.g., aah (come)
>3. mid central unrounded ....e.g. 'a' in zebra
>From the sound it seems like the assamese 'a' starts from the front
>part of
>the mouth ( I may be mistaken and another sound the open back
>unrounded sounds
>much like it even though it depends a lot on the tongue position of
>the speaker.)
>When spoken with a RP(Received Pronunciation) accent unlike the
>Indian accent the
>English "o" starts at the very back of the mouth. e.g., 'o' in over.
>Moreover in
>the IPA sound files, the 'o' (not the 'o' in english but the /o/
>sound in IPA)
>sounds almost exactly like the 'o' as in ola (get out). >From the
>above it seems
>that the alphabet 'a' better approximates the corresponding Assamese
>sound.So I have
>decided to say axam instead of oxom. But then as I said...... what
>notation u use is
>vastly a matter of opinion....since the 'a' sound is Assamese is not
>available in
>English in any case we have to do a compromise. Neither axam not
>osom is actually
>correct .....it all depends on how we decide to pronounce the 'a'
>and 'o' in
>transliterated literature. ......Syamanta
>
>##3 i accept your arguments. but the purpose of suggesting "o"
>instead of "a" was to
>make native speakers comfortable with the transliteration, not
>foreign speakers. as
>jugal-da pointed out, the "a" makes it uncomfortable. i use
>transliterated assamese
>sometimes in my personal emails. and to me "o" came naturally. i am
>afraid that if the
>native speaker doesnot feel comfortable, he will desist from using
>it, and then there
>will be no need for a scheme anyway. on the other hand a standard,
>widely accepted
>scheme has many advantages......saurav da
>
>##4.. The 'o' u propose is DEFINITELY superior to my paltry 'a'
>while typing for the
>layman... Now there are two things we can do about the 'a'/'o'
>perplexity.... 1. Change
>the original scheme and use 'o' as a Universal Standard. 2. Use 'o'
>in
>"roman-input-to-assmese-font-output" softwares and use "a" while
>writing Assamese words
>in english.. If we use the "o' as an universal standard we might
>face quite a few problems
>....e.g., as Mr. Rabin Deka pointed out .....we will write Chandra
>kanta Bharali or Chondro
>Kanto Bhorali ?? Thats why I guess using 'o' when we r using "roman
>characters as input and
>want to get assamese characters as output" and using 'a' when ' we
>start from assamese
>characters but wanna get roman characters as out put' should be a
>better suggestion
>.... Syamanta
>
>##5 I see one solution where in some contexts, we use "a" and in
>some other contexts,
>we use "o" for the first vowel. Based on the context, the processing
>needs to be uniquely
>done. ... Jugal da
>
>##6 How about the sound of 'a' as in paw, law, etc. Just my 2
>cents... Neep Hazarika
>
>##7 the "o" instead of "a" is important for the casual writer, as
>well as those who
>wants to write naturally (e.g jugal kalita). we should give a
>serious thought to this.
>jugal-da mentions there are some technical difficulties. maybe we
>should try to solve them.
>"Chandra Kanta Bharali" and "condro kanto bhorali" is not a real
>problem, because "condro
>kanto bhorali" is written in transliteration, not in english. there
>is a difference. my
>name would be "xourobh" or something like that. and i have no
>problem with it. my guess is,
>if your transliteration scheme becomes popular, many people will
>prefer to write their names
>in your scheme, and not in the regular english spelling. my guess
>is, we will increasingly see
>"xonjoi", "jugol", "sondon", "xoikia" etc. .. Saurav da
>
>##8 My reason for sticking with /a/ instead of /o/ as the first
>vowel was more phonetic than
>practical. In hindsight I think /o/ is more natural for us and so I
>have replaced /a/ with /o/ .
>As a result, I had to change the old /o/ as in konoba(someone) to
>koonooba. (I am not sure
>how much phonetic or practical /oo/ is and it would be great if
>someone comes up with an alternative).
>Also /aa/ has been changed to /a/. (thanx due to the intial posts of
>rajen da).
>...Syamanta
>
>##9 >As an exmaple, it seems to me, that it is awkard to use "O" for
>the first
>>letter of the Assamese alphabet in transliteration.
>
>Why is it so? Why for example would it sound more right to write the
>word 'odhom' as
>'adhom'? Or for that matter the word 'ohingxa or ohingxaa' as
>'ahimsa'? I also find it
>totally redundant to chase 'dirgho-ee' ' dirgho-u' and the like. I
>can see the problem of
>transliterating a word like 'wroni' ass either 'uroni' or 'ooroni'.
>Neither of the latter two
>are intuitive, while the first is somehat awkard. But is it really
>awkard? The English word
>WHY does not look awkard. Nor does WHETHER or WHIMSICAL. It is for
>this reason that I think
>the solution suggested by Rajen, to use the letter 'w' or 'W' to
>represent the Oxomia 'W'
>sound as in 'wbhwt maat' ( profane word) or 'bhwta or bhWta toraa'.
>There will certainly be
>some cases where it would be not exactly an easy or fluid and
>totally intuitive soultion.
>...C. Mahanta da
>
>
>##10 If we think of 'A' ('O' as in Oxom or Osom, even) being
>equivalent to the english
>letter 'A', because they are the first letters in Assamese and
>English (and on the computer
>keyboard starter line), then it becomes difficult to accept - why
>shouln't our 'Asm' be
>written with the first English letter 'A'?...Alpana baideu
>##11 a: .... ( half open, back) as in 'ba:l'= strength (written by
>Assamese + letter o)
>...Rajen da
>
>
>vowel 2:
>
>##1 + a ..... (open, central) as in 'bap'=father (written by the
>Assamese + letter a)
>.....Rajen da
>## 2
>>+ a ..... (open, central) as in 'bap'=father is the same as my 'a'.
>Your pronunciation is (open central) my suggested is (Open Front
>Unrounded ) actually if
>u did care to look you will see how unnatural it is to make a vowel
>sounds "open central".
>It is so unnatural that NOT even a single dialect in the world uses
>it !!
>##3 Your challenge about the 'a' not being a central, is actually a
>challenge to Dr
>Banikanta Kakoty (Doctorate under Sunity Kumar Chatterjee), Dr Golok
>Ch Goswami and others.
>I have nothing to say as I donot state to be a linguistic.
>.....Rajen da
>
>##4 The following is what I was talking about when I said it bothers
>me when I see too many
>consonants without a vowel in between. A semi-vowel like "w" can't
>take place of a vowel in
>my mind! When I see Chandan da type KHWA, HWPA, DHWAT, LWA, PWRA,
>LOGWA, NWPWA, etc., I cringe!
>Why not type them as the ones after the => instead? They will look a
>lot more "natural" and
>comfortable to most people!
>khwa => khuwa
>Hwpa => hupa
>dhwat => dhuwat lwa => l
>uwa logwa => loguwa
>nwpwa => nupuwa (nwpwa has four non-vowels together making it look
>the strangest so far!)
>
>##5 >I bet he will wonder because he is seeing it for the first
>time. Then of course he will
>know about using W.....
>Let me quote what Dr Golok Ch Goswami, the Assamese linguistic
>stated in favor of usingW in
>Assamese Roman script in a personal letter to me back 1992 when I
>was also in doubt like you
>and asked his opinion.
>This is q quote from that letter:"Barua : ........WOr karone OO, W
>aru WO ei tiniwta kio lage?
>Ei tniwtar thait kewol W lolei bhal hoi. W akhor lole WAB.BO aru WO
>duiwtare kam solibo. Kenekoi
>sawk: byonjon bornor pasote W thakile i WO sor
>bujabo; jene, MWR (my). TWMAR (your),
>BHWLANATH, ityadi. Kintu Sorobornor pasot  ba duta soror majot
>thakile i WO ba WAB.BO dhoni
>bujabo. jene: DEW-BHUT (WO dhoni), DEWE (WAAB.BO dhoni), GAWOR (of
>village>WAB.BO), BWARI (WAB.BO),
>XW~ORON (remembrance), ityadi. " - Dr Golak Ch
>Goswami.(12/24/92).Please note that in bengali,
>the typical Assamese WO sound is not found. They have WO-kar as well
>as the WO akhor. But it sound
>like O'. They write MAGW but say it as MAGO'. Dr Sunity Kr
>Chatterjee; book also state that this W
>phonem in Bengali is pronounced as O as in the word 'bone'. 
>But In Assamese we prounce it a
>deep WO in words : GWHALI, AKWALI, MWR, etc. 
>##6
>>>>A semi-vowel like "w" can't take place of a vowel in my mind!
>>>I >>THINK IT IS IN YOUR MIND.
>I DON"T HAVE ANY PROBLEM. A SEMI VOWEL WE CAN >>SURELY USE AS A FULL
>VOWEL. >I don't think not
>liking the transliteration >"NWPWA", but liking "nupuwa" instead is
>a >personal bias.
>First lets remember what our goal was..."To be able to write
>Assamese and communicate in it in a
>natural way using the Roman keyboard in today's computers. (esp. for
>use by people who know the
>language and just want to converse in it). It has to be intuitive to
>use." For that it is very
>necessary to have a 1-1 correspondence between the alphabets and
>their transliterations.... Now,
>NWPWA = n, + oo (oo-kar....as in joowa...go + p, + oo (oo-kar) +w, +
>a (the second vowel as in aha..
>come in) The problem whether the program will interpret W as the
>generic form of "wo" OR as oo-kar
>(as in after n,) OR as a combination of (oo-kar and w,) as in after
>p, . So we see here that the W
>is being used to interpret 3 different assamese alphabets..... This
>is unacceptable in an automated
>program. Also if we write "nupua" as Jugal da says , how will we say
>kukur (dog) ?? the program will
>interpret u (in kukur)= oo-kar (in nupua). /u/ in place of oo-kar
>will be disastrous..... e.g., jua
>means go (as oo-kar) or gambling(as u-kar)..?? thats why i suggest
>using /u/ as in juwa(gambling).....
>w(as in the generic for of wo the consonant) and oo( as in
>oola.....come out)
>............. Syamanta
>
>##7 Assamese has the letter "wa" ("wabbo") as in "bowa" (meaning
>"flow" or to "weave" as well;
>i would prefer to type it as "buwa" myself). It is composed of the
>following letters/signs in
>Assamese:
>1) the letter "ba",
>2) the sign for o-kar (as in "mor" or "mur" or mine)
>3) the letter "wa" or "wabbo"
>4) the "a" kar. How would Chandan da or Rajen da write it (hopefully
>"bwa")? If that's the case,
>won't 2) and 3) above be confused? Which one of 2) or 3) above is
>"w" in the transliteration expressing?
>Or are you proposing "w" as a single transliteration symbol that
>combines 2) and 3) above, i.e.,
>"o-kar" followed by "wabbo"? If "w" in transliteration stands for
>two characters: 2) followed by 3)
>above, it's essentially a complex way to do things. ....Jugal da
>
>##8 Let's compare Shymanta's and Rajenda's ideas for the 5th and the
>9th vowels. Here are some examples.
>1) dog = kukur (both Shyamanta and Rajen da)
>2) fire == jui (both Shyamanta and Rajen da)
>3) i will sit by fire == moi jui poowam (Shyamanta) moi jui pwam
>(Rajen da)
>4) hug == akoowali loowa (Shyamanta), akwali lwa (Rajen da)
>5) gamble = juwa (both Shyamanta and Rajen da)
>6) go now == etiya joowa (Shyamanta), etiya jwa (Rajen da)
>7) not get it == noopoowa (Shyamanta), nwpwa (Rajen da)
>8) (you) please eat = khoowa (Shyamanta), khwa (Rajen da)
>9) to burn = poora (Shymanta), pwra (Rajen da)
>10) (you) do not eat == nookhoowa (Shyamanta), nwkhwa (Rajen da)
>11) young cow or calf = goru poowali (Shyamanta), goru pwali (Rajen
>da)
>Good points about Shyamanta's proposal
>---------------------------------------------
>Shymanata's maintains 1-1 mapping. Shymanta's proposal has no
>problems with either the vowels
>or the 'wabbo".
>
>Bad points about Shyamanta's proposal
>-------------------------------------------------------
>I don't see any.
>
>Good points about Rajenda's proposal
>------------------------------------------------------
>It seems to me that phonetically speaking, Rajenda's use of "w" is
>intuitive if
>it is directly followed by a vowel, as in "khwa" or "lwa".
>
>Bad points about Rajenda's proposal
>---------------------------------------------------
>A) The use of "w" by Rajenda seems unintuitive when the "w" is not
>followed by
>a vowel as in "nwkhwa" (the first "w" here is not intuitive to me
>because it is
>not immediately followed by a vowel, whereas the second "w" is
>because it is immediately
>followed by the vowel "a"). So, I doubt if the expressive power that
>Rajenda sees in "w"
>comes from a) the "w" itself, or b) the vowel that follows it, or c)
>from a combination of
>"w" followed by the vowel.
>B) The spellings "nwkhwa", "nwpwa" are awkward to me, and possibly
>incorrect according to
>Rajenda's own scheme. A possible correction in Rajenda's
>transliteration?
>------------------------------------------
>Rajenda seems to ignore the trailing "wabbo" in some of his
>transliterations. Maybe, to
>express the last "wabbo" in such words, Rajenda should spell them
>more correctly as "nw khw wa"
>or "nw pw wa". The last "wa" then represents "wabbo" followed by
>"a-kar". In that case, the
>spellings become even more awkward. I wouldn't like to type "nwpwwa"
>or "nwkhwwa" if I had a choice!
>-----
>I like Shyamanta's proposal better because of the considerations
>above unless
>Rajen da comes up with a way to distinguish between the use of "w"
>as a semi-vowel in
>transliteration and the useful Assamese letter "wabbo" in a more
>attractive manner.
>Why should "noopoowa" (in Shyamanta's scheme) should be writen as
>"nwpwa" in your scheme
>and not as "nwpwwa"? Here, "nw" is "no" followed by the w-kar (or
>oo-kar in Shyamanta's scheme),
>"pw" is "po" followed by the w-kar (or oo-kar in Shyamanta's
>scheme), and the last "wa"
>is the wabbo followed by a-kar. .
>.... Jugal Da
>
>
>vowels 3,4,5,6:
>
>
>##1 However, one need to stick to basic Assamese phonetics. + Please
>note that Assamese
>has EIGHT (8) vowel sounds although we have + more letters. Against
>this the English language
>has 22 vowel sounds. Please note that in Assamese HORSO E & DIRGHO E
>, HORSO U & DIRGHO U + etc
>have the same sounds. (Please read Dr Banikanta Kakaoty and +
>others).
>##2 ii or I ........ Close Central Unrounded (Barred i) >
>IN ASSAMESE WE DONOT HAVE A SEPARATE SOUND FOR DIRGHO E. BOTH THE Es
>ARE PRONOUNCED SAME.
>uu or U ........ Close Back Un-Rounded (Turned m) (???) >
>IN ASSAMESE WE DONOT HAVE A SEPARATE SOUND FOR DIRGHO U. BOTH THE Us
>ARE PRONOUNCED SAME.
>I have a separate 'ii' for two reasons...
>1. The baisc idea of transliteration is to establish a one-to-one
>correspondence between a
>letter in the source language to an alphabet(or a group of
>alphabets). So we cannot have any ambiguity
>while translitering. If we have an alphabet in Assamese we MUST have
>an english counterpart so as to
>remove any ambiguity..
>2. I am pretty dumb in this respect but i thought the name Dirgho-e
>implies in itself that the sound
>is supposed to be longer and when i tried to observe the Assamese
>words with that alphabet i thought that
>they sounded/ can be sounded a little longer. Now in other languages
>while elongating a sound from another
>very close sound (esp vowels) what happens phonetically is that the
>sounds starts a little backwards in the
>mouth.....it gives a sense of elongation. For example in Arabic
>alphabet the "ayn" is an elongated form of
>the "Alif" and so the mouth position is same while pronouncing both
>but 'ayn' starts further inside the mouth
>than 'alif'.. and in egyptian the 'h' corresponding to the Hebrew
>"h�" and the "h.a" both are same
>but one is longer than the other and so starts later than the
>other... So I guessed since ' i '
>is the Close Front Unrounded, so Dirgho-e should be Close Central
>Unrounded and when i compared
>the sounds it sounded much like what the dirgho-e is expected to be.
>This is the reason I put two different alphabets. The same
>explanation for the dirgho-u.. >rri or
>R^i ..... Near- Close Front Un-Rounded (Small Capital I)
>>NOW A DAYS THIS LETTER IS NOT WRITTEN IN ASSAMESE LANGUAGE.
>I am not aware of what is going on right now but if you donot
>write"rri" then how will you write
>"rrixhhi"(saint) ?? also there is the rri-kar we have to consider !!
>>IN ADDITION TO THE ABOVE, ASSAMESE HAS THE FOLLOWING TWO ADDITIONAL
>>VOWEL SOUNDS. O' = KO'LA (BLACK) AS OPPOSED TO KOLA (DEAF) E'= BE'L
>>(BELL) AS OPPOSED TO BEL (FRUIT)
>The small comma in o' and e' are not actually new vowels......they
>are called the SUPRASEGMENTALS...
>They are used to experss Tones and word accents..... /o/ mean it is
>flat../o'/ means we have to
>say it at a high level ../o''/ means we have to say it at a higher
>level. Even in english we have o'...
>like seven o' clock... but it doesnot qualify o' or for that matter
>e' to be a new vowel. All the rest
>of your concerns stem from the fact of whether we ahould
>tranliterate Assam as axam or oxom ......and
>I am right hearing from everyone that it should be oxom......but i
>guess it will be better to give this
>thing some more thought..... But in the end there has to be some
>form of accepted standard
>..... Syamanta.
>
>
>
>
>
>vowel 7:
>
>##1
>>rri or R^i ..... Near- Close Front Un-Rounded (Small Capital I)
>> >NOW A DAYS THIS LETTER IS NOT WRITTEN IN
>ASSAMESE LANGUAGE.
>...Rajen da
>
>##2
>
>I am not aware of what is going on right now but if you donot
>write"rri" then how will you write "rrixhhi"
>(saint) ?? also there is the rri-kar
>we have to consider !!
>.....Syamanta
>
>##3 it doesnot have the "ri" sound......i wonder how you are going
>to say "rixhi" !! "ri" is an
>independent monothong and cannot be approximated by any
>vowel/consonant
>.....Syamanta
>
>
>
>
>vowels 9, 11
>
>
>##1
>ai ............. Close-Mid Central ROunded (Barred O )
>THIS IS ACTUALLY A DIPHTHONG. MAY BE WRITTEN AS OI
>au ............. Close- Mid Back Unrounded (Baby Gamma )
>AGAIN IT IS A DIPTHONG. NOT A BASIC VOWEL
>..........Rajen da
>
>##2 it misses the "oi" and "ou" diphthongs even though oi= o + i and
>ou= o + u
>that is why i guess scholars dont think of it as a separate
>vowel but then i guess since it has its own already defined
>characters in assamese.....
>i see no problem in transliterating them ratcher then
>creating an artificial problem by omitting them and then solving the
>problem when
>we encounter them..... o+i will be oi when we write
>down whethe we define it separately or not....
>.....Syamanta
>
>
>
>
>Vowel 10:
>
>##1
>o ............. Close- Mid Back Rounded (Lower Case O )
>MAY BE WRITTEN AS W. THIS SOUND IS NOT THERE IN ENGLISH, NOR IN
>HINDI OR BENGALI
>
>...Rajen da
>
>##2
>
>
>Look at ##8 for vowel 1.....and ##5, ##6, ##7 and ##8 for vowel 2.
>
>
>
>
>
>An online version of the compilation....can be had at
>http://www.geocities.com/assamese_transliteration
>
>
>
>I have compiled the discussions only on the vowels...It is possible
>I have missed a lot of interesting points while rifling through the
>posts....It will be great if someone points them out to me so that i
>can make this compilation complete....
>
>
>Syamanta Saikia.
>
>_________________________________________________________________
>The new MSN 8: smart spam protection and 2 months FREE*
>http://join.msn.com/?page=features/junkmail
>
>_______________________________________________
>Assam mailing list
>[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam


The new MSN 8: smart spam protection and 2 months FREE* _______________________________________________ Assam mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Reply via email to