C'da
> *** Your confusion arises out of the way you framed
> your question.
> Question is whether it was an oversight, or
> unfamiliarity with the
> origins of the ULFA movement--why and how it began,
> or out of a
> deliberate choice :-).
I would think we both had the same history lessons as
to the reasons of ULFA's emergence and struggles for
an independent Assam. There may be nuances here and
there, but in the end we all know why, who, what, and
when of the issues. Granted your take may be a whole
lot different than mine as to 'who is responsible' or
the blame for the problems.
I asked the questions from a different prespective
altogether. The fact is the GOI will never put the
question of 'independence' on the table. They have
always approached the problem to be dealt with
'within' the confines of the constitution. This PM or
any other will never consider a discussion based on
those conditions.
Given that, where do we stand? Where do the people of
Assam stand? If the Center does not agree, will
violence be the order of the day? Is that the ultimate
choice? Those are the hard questions that the people
of Assam must make.
My question again is, framed in another way, will
continued violence get Delhi to come to the table to
discuss independence? Or, will only the way of
violence get people in power to listen to demands?
This much seems to be true, if neither the GOI nor the
ULFA give up their stance then its unlikely that Assam
will see peace in the near future. It is extremely
unlikely that the GOI will work outside the
constitution on this one. The GOI has the wherewithal,
the tenacity and the money to wage an endless battle
and the insurgents will also keep doing their bit.
Sadly, the people of Assam are the ones to receive the
short end of the stick.
We can go on a 'fault finding' mission till we go blue
in the face, but the problem will not be solved until
and unless we see the practical implications of today,
on tomorrow.
During the independence movement, there were many
(Indian and British) who thought that the British hold
on India was legitimate, legal and even better for
Indians. Gandhi won, mainly because of one good
reason: For the most part his movement was a peaceful
movement, and the British could not fight
non-violence, and they lost. Unfortunately, that
cannot be said of the movement by the insurgents. If
all along this had been a peaceful movement, they
would have garnered more support not just from other
Assamese, but also worldwide.
BTW: you haven't answered any of the questionz that
has come up.
Ram
--- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> Ram:
>
>
> > >I am little confused. Does this mean that if we
> have a
> >situation where a few people perpetrate terror &
> >violence in the state, then the Center has to start
> >discussing sovereignty?
>
>
> *** Your confusion arises out of the way you framed
> your question.
> Question is whether it was an oversight, or
> unfamiliarity with the
> origins of the ULFA movement--why and how it began,
> or out of a
> deliberate choice :-).
>
>
> *** But if you are genuinely unaware, do tell. I
> will try to explain
> with what *I* learned, right here in Assam Net over
> the last eight
> years.
>
> c-da
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> At 7:07 AM -0800 11/7/04, ram Sarangapani wrote:
> > > "I have taken the initiative for peace only on
> >>humanitarian ground, honouring the sentiment of
> the
> >>people of Assam who do not want violence in the
> >>State," she said.
> >
> >I am little confused. Does this mean that if we
> have a
> >situation where a few people perpetrate terror &
> >violence in the state, then the Center has to start
> >discussing sovereignty?
> >
> >I guess such scenarios can be extended to any
> number
> >of situations. What about the ethinic divisions
> within
> >Assam, the Bodod, Miris and other groups? There is
> >violence there too. Then, shouldn't all such groups
> >get a 'hearing'?
> >
> >The basic precepts of such demands should be one of
> >legitimacy? Are these demands legitimate in the
> first
> >place? Does this mean that every period of violence
> by
> >insurgents must be met by bowing down to their
> demands
> >(legitimate or not)?
> >
> >Yes, peace is an ultimate goal that everyone wants.
> >But what is the price? Will peace come to Assam if,
> >and only if, the demands of insurgents are met?
> >Who speaks for the silent majority of Assamese who
> do
> >want to stay within the union and also live in
> peace?
> >
> >What happens if the Ulfa become the rulers of
> >tomorrow, and other ethinic groups want to break
> away
> >from an Assamese stronghold, will they just give
> away
> >those parts to keep the 'peace'.
> >
> >I have all the respect for Dr. Goswami, but in this
> >respect, I must say, her prescription is not a
> >solution, but will in all likelyhood create more
> >problems.
> >
> >>she said she would mobilize public support if the
> >>Prime Minister gave her the go ahead.
> >
> >This statement seems to say, that one has to
> >'mobilize' public support for the insurgents'
> demands.
> >Obviously, such demands do not have public support,
> >but she is going to use her standing to make it
> >palatable.
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >--- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> >
> >> I am proud of Dr. Goswami, a lady with courage
> and
> >> conviction.
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >> >"If I do not get an appointment with Dr Singh
> >> within the next 15
> >> >days, I will come >to the conclusion that the
> >> Government has no
> >> >sincerity in restoring peace in the >State,"
> she
> >> said.
> >>
> >>
> >> Can't wait to see what comes of it.
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >> I'll wait for a fortnight: Mamoni
> >>
> >> By a Staff Reporter
> >> GUWAHATI, Nov 6: Noted Assamese writer and
> >> Jnanpith Award winner Dr
> >> Mamoni Raisom Goswami has said that she would
> wait
> >> for another
> >> fortnight to get an appointment with Prime
> Minister
> >> Dr Manmohan
> >> Singh to convey the ULFA's desire to come to
> the
> >> negotiation table.
> >> "If I do not get an appointment with Dr Singh
> within
> >> the next 15
> >> days, I will come to the conclusion that the
> >> Government has no
> >> sincerity in restoring peace in the State," she
> >> said.
> >>
> >> Talking to The Sentinel over telephone from New
> >> Delhi, she said that
> >> Assam Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi had taken
> >> responsibility to fix an
> >> appointment with the Prime Minister. "I
> understand
> >> that a Prime
> >> Minister is a very busy person. The issue I have
> to
> >> raise before the
> >> Prime Minister is also important for the
> restoration
> >> of peace in
> >> Assam," she stated.
> >>
> >> It is worth mentioning here that the noted
> >> litterateur had prepared
> >> a draft proposal in consultation with senior
> >> professors of Delhi
> >> University, which has been approved by ULFA's
> >> 'commander-in-chief'
> >> Paresh Barua, for submission before the Prime
> > > Minister. But she is
> >> awaiting an appointment with Dr Singh for nearly
> a
> >> month.
> >>
> >> Saying that there was no legal hurdle in
> discussing
> >> sovereignty with
> >> the insurgent group, Dr Goswami said that
> >> discussing the issue and
> >> acceding to it were two different matters. "I
> have
> >> taken the
> >> initiative for peace only on humanitarian
> ground,
> >> honouring the
> >> sentiment of the people of Assam who do not want
> >> violence in the
> >> State," she said.
> >>
> >> Asked if she would take the initiative in
> creating
> >> public opinion to
> >> start a peace process with the insurgent group
> for
> >> greater interest
> >> of the State, she said she would mobilize
> public
> >> support if the
> >> Prime Minister gave her the go ahead.
> >>
> >> "ULFA 'c-in-c' Paresh Barua contacted me this
> >> morning and expressed
> >> concern over the Government's lack of interest
> in
>
=== message truncated ===
__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Check out the new Yahoo! Front Page.
www.yahoo.com
_______________________________________________
Assam mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam
Mailing list FAQ:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
To unsubscribe or change options:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam