Except for recent AT and Sentinel news indicating to the
negative, I have seen no such earthquake preparedness plan.
The recent AT Editorial by Sarma da ( Barada Sarma) questioning
the wisdom of not going ahead with high rise structures at Guwahati
using Japanese or California technology raised my hackles as you must
have noticed. Some recent reports in Assam newspapers validated points
I raised. Not that they were original discoveries on my part, they
were widely recognized by thoughtful people in Guwahati for
decades. It is just that their concerns and voices do not get the
exposure they deserve.
Indian Govt. has indeed developed a primer on earthquake oriented
simple design manual, easily understood even by a non-technical
person, for residential structures. My old buddy Brig. Satish
showed it to me in Delhi last January. I thought it was well
developed, (by the Corps of Engineers of the Indian Army I
thought,could be wrong about that) even though not comprehensive by
any means.
What I don't know is who it has been distributed to. I don't
recall seeing it anywhere in Assam.
As a part of my own professional development as a practicing
architect, I went and visited California to see what they were doing
to retrofit and otherwise prepare for future /quakes after the Loma
Priata event. As you would remember we sit near a bad fault here
at St. Louis. The New Madrid fault 150 miles from us produced the
largest earthquake in the continental USA I believe. The California
measures are probably the most comprehensive, outside of Japan.
One of the least paid attention to but preventable causes of
injury and even death in a quake is to anchor non structural
items down in a building. In the Loma Priata event, the most injuries
came from falling objects, like ceilings, light fixtures, furniture,
items in cupboards. Or shifting equipment such as almirahs,
refrigerators, washing machines etc.
However the concerns in Assam buildings would be different. One
of the worst will be all the 'chhajjas' the window overhangs. Poorly
braced on unbraced structures would be another.
Ambulances and fire tenders will not be able to get to buildings,
even if they are available. Upper stories of high-rises are already
out of reach of Guwahati fire-brigade equipment. There are no fire
hydrants in high rises if I am not mistaken. Besides, without water
pressure they would be of little use even if existing. There is no
drinking water even in some Guwahati high-rises. So in Gurgaon and
Delhi too.And there are no street hydrants in most parts of
Guwahati--if at all.
A Sentinel editorial complained of single elevator
high-rises. But that is the last thing one should take in a quake,
because the first casualty of a quake would be a stalled elevator. Few
high-rises have more than one staircase. So if one is blocked by
falling debris, the residents would be sitting ducks, both in a quake
as well as a fire.
It is a big subject and begs a lot of attention.
Finally your leading question:
>"--Knowing full well that the residents of Assam
are living in a danger zone, >shouldn't they themselves come up
with a Preparedness Plan, in stead of waiting >for someone else
(like GOI) to do it for them?"
Would you like to take a wild guess on that? Or do I need to
raise more hackles by suggesting some explanation for it:-)?
At 11:13 AM -0800 1/1/05, Dilip/Dil Deka wrote:
I also was wondering about the usefulness of a Quake Warning. Warnings for Flood, Hurricane, Tornado or Tsunami are based on tangible precursors and give the areas within striking distance sufficient time to take measures. Such warnings have saved many lives in Louisiana and Florida during Hurricane season.
What are the residents of Assam going to do given the warning that an earthquake is likely to happen in the next 10 (?) years? Leave Assam and seek less earthquake prone areas in India? Or start sleeping outdoors from now on? It is already established that Assam sits on a geological fault and irrespective of warnings, measures need to be taken to mitigate the dangers to life in an earthquake.
Is there an Earthquake Preparedness Plan for the bigger cities like Guwahati? There wasn't one when I lived there forty years ago.The number of multistoreyed residential buildings and the density of such buildings that I noticed during my recent visit to Guwahati tell me that there isn't one even now. The narrow alleys that lead to the concrete buildings will be impassable for rescue operation if disaster strikes. Knowing full well that the residents of Assam are living in a danger zone, shouldn't they themselves come up with a Preparedness Plan, in stead of waiting for someone else (like GOI) to do it for them?
Does anyone in this net have more information on this subject?
Dilip
Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
Hi Santanu,
Happy New Year to you and yours.
Scare, scare! Panic, panic!
Thanks for the forewarning though ( BTW, is there such a thing as
afterwarning too ---in Upper Assamese there is: It goes something
like "H--ar pisot pw--r bisara)?
Now the big question here is whether to count this one, since it
comes from an US University's scientific staff, or discount it as
another set of earthquake seers' gamble, scare-mongering, prudent
warning, whatever?
But this time it gets a little more complicated than say, the Terra
Watch group's or Rabolu's red-planet or that perennial predictor of
perdition -- whatshisFrenchfacename -- Nostradamus' (?) forecasts of
doom.
Why I say that is that there is ample evidence of 'quakes after
concerted series of seismic activity in fault ridden areas. It is!
also well observed that big quakes do seem to be cyclical in nature.
Both of those patterns fit Assam's situation.
What has however not been established by anyone that I know of ( not
that it means anything--I am no geologist or seismologist, just an
interested observer
of the phenomenon holding a high degree of respect for the forces
involved), is either the predictability in a reasonable time frame
or a reasonably accurate epicenter location or a magnitude.
Which leaves us about as wise as we have been so far. We know there
will be a big 'quake sometime in the future, somewhere around Assam,
but we don't know how soon or how late, where or how big, just like
we know we will confront death in exactly the same way as well.
All we could therefore do, is be aware of it,take prudent measures to
reduce damage and scope out measures to ameliorate its effects when
it happens and most importantly avoid highly risky undertakings that
would put large populations in harms way.
Making moves to north-central USA or the UK will be grossly
premature at this time is how I would view it. Appropriate Pujas
couldn't hurt. Declaring govt. holidays on account of impending doom
is well documented thruout India and should not be ruled out.
Enterprising educators might take advantage of the reforms of the
last decade or so that Rajib told us about and establish a private
University of Predictive Sciences with a dedicated chair in the
Faculty of Fakery funded with NRA/NRI wealth, hopefully in the NE, or
at least outside of the South.
c-da :-)
At 10:57 AM -0600 1/1/05, Roy, Santanu wrote:
>http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/977960.cms
>
>_______________________________________________
>Assam mailing list
>[email protected]
>http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam
>
>Mailing list FAQ:
>http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
>To unsubscribe or change options:
>http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam
_______________________________________________
Assam mailing list
[email protected]
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam
Mailing list FAQ:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
To unsubscribe or change options:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam
_______________________________________________ Assam mailing list [email protected] http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam
Mailing list FAQ: http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html To unsubscribe or change options: http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam
