> In other words are you suggesting that "Autonomy" in
> stead of "Sovereignty" should be included in the
> agenda of GOI-ULFA talks? I'd say that makes sense
> if ULFA has the mandate to speak on behalf of Assam.

I am certainly NOT suggesting that ULFA represents
Assamese or what is best for Assam. I am not sure if
they have the locus standi and am not sure they have
the mandate.  You may be right that the people are
basically wanting all this to end and are as you say
"it appears to me that the people of Assam are looking
:at the "talks" as a solution to the ULFA problem"

If that is true. it is indeed sad. No people should
have to take such decisions because they just want to
get the monkey of their backs.

--Ram


The case for Autonomy is something that the GOI should
actually start thinking. Autonomy not just for Assam
or Kashmir but for all states. That way every state
will be responsible for their own progress to a great
extent.


--- Dilip/Dil Deka <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> "The best option I think is for states to get
> together
> and urge the GOI for more autonomy for states. The
> modalities could then be worked out. In fact the GOI
> has said they are willing to discuss autonomy in
> Kashmir. This all-or-nothing stance will only lead
> to
> a near total destruction of basic structures for
> development/growth that exist in Assam."
> --------------
> 
> In other words are you suggesting that "Autonomy" in
> stead of "Sovereignty" should be included in the
> agenda of GOI-ULFA talks? I'd say that makes sense
> if ULFA has the mandate to speak on behalf of Assam.
> From my recent visit to Assam, it appears to me that
> the people of Assam are looking at the "talks" as a
> solution to the ULFA problem, to bring the leaders
> from underground and to assimilate them. The people
> I talked to are not even looking at the talks to
> solve Assam's deeper problems by means of autonomy
> or something else. Above all they have not appointed
> ULFA to speak on their behalf.
> 
> Dilip Deka
> 
>  
> 
> 
> ram Sarangapani <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> Dear C'da,
> 
> > But still I would admit, I was too strident with
> my
> > language, and I remain contrite for it. With you,
> >with Ram, with Alpana and even with Rajib :-).
> > I realize that more than anything else, my
> > intemperate choice of words and phrases raised the
> >hackles it did.
> 
> 
> I hope you give us due credit in understanding some
> of
> the problems in the NE. Atleast in my case (and I
> suspect others too), your response raised the
> hackles
> NOT becuse it was strident or harsh, but more so
> because you completely avoided answering Barua's
> question and simple set it aside as being too broad
> or
> immaterial/immature.
> Please tell us why you think it is immaterial or
> immature? Are such comparisons bad or is it that you
> really do not have an answer?
> 
> What I was looking for in your response was solid
> arguments against (or for) Barua's question 'Why the
> NE states are lagging behind?). A simple answer that
> brushes it under the carpet as being inconsequential
> is NOT attacking the problem at all.
> 
> >You have been arguing that even if Assam got
> >sovereignty they are unfit to govern 
> >themselves ( as opposed to say India who is fit)
> and
> >other such opinions.
> 
> The bottomline here is that there are a group of
> people in Assam who think they could do a better job
> of governance than Delhi. But just wishful thinking
> like this does not cut it. People who support such a
> stance should be able to answer a few questions
> first.
> 
> If the GOI will NOT give independence to Assam (a
> very
> likely scenario) on a silver platter, what then?
> 
> Are the Assamese willing to go on for another 25
> years
> of insurgents fighting superior Indian forces and
> the
> resulting unstable conditions? Is that what is in
> store for Assam? 
> 
> Its one thing to be passionate and to preach from
> afar, but its, I am sure totally different for the
> people (insurgents, common folks, soldiers etc) to
> keep dragging this to no end and against all odds.
> 
> The best option I think is for states to get
> together
> and urge the GOI for more autonomy for states. The
> modalities could then be worked out. In fact the GOI
> has said they are willing to discuss autonomy in
> Kashmir. This all-or-nothing stance will only lead
> to
> a near total destruction of basic structures for
> development/growth that exist in Assam. 
> 
> -- Ram
> 
> 
> 
> 
> --- Chan Mahanta wrote:
> 
> > OK Rajen, finally we are at the gates of the big
> > Kahuna of a question 
> > that generated so much angst.
> > 
> > First let me address:
> > 
> > >So you think my question is so simplistic that it
> > is not worth answering even.
> > 
> > *** On the face of it, stripped of CONTEXT under
> > which you raised the question,
> > your protestation of my unfairness implied in the
> > comment above would 
> > be understandable. I would be guilty of making an
> > insensitive and 
> > disrespectful comment about a fellow netter and a
> > friend's question 
> > in a public forum.
> > 
> > And if it were just that, I should and would offer
> > an unconditional 
> > apology, at the very least.
> > 
> > But there was more to it:
> > 
> > Your question's possible answer was designed as
> > another of
> > your arguments against any justification
> > for the ULFA insurgency
> > and the complicity of the people of Assam
> > in it. You have been
> > arguing that even if Assam got sovereignty
> > they are unfit to govern
> > themselves ( as opposed to say India who is
> > fit) and other such
> > opinions.
> > 
> > (>If Assamese do not have the courage to stand up
> > for justice, how one
> > can even think of an >independendent Assam?
> > That is why I said, Assamese
> > are probably not fit for democracy. Do you
> > >think Assamese nature will
> > change overnite?)
> > 
> > 
> > Which is fine, we all have opinions about all
> kinds
> > of things. And
> > none of us here are for stifling such views,
> unless
> > they are
> > patently offensive in some manner or other.
> > 
> > But as I explained to Ram, that one should not be
> > surprised to be challenged
> > when someone is floating as vague or broad-brushed
> > proposition as 
> > yours in pursuit of a hotly debated political
> > position.
> > 
> > 
> > That is the difference Rajen. And that is my
> > defense.
> > 
> > But still I would admit, I was too strident with
> my
> > language, and I 
> > remain contrite for it. With you, with Ram, with
> > Alpana and even with 
> > Rajib :-).
> > I realize that more than anything else, my
> > intemperate choice of 
> > words and phrases raised the hackles it did.
> > 
> > 
> > Stay tuned now for some answers to your question.
> > 
> > 
> > c
> > 
> > 
> > 
> > 
> > 
> > 
> > 
> > 
> > At 12:55 PM -0600 12/30/04, Barua25 wrote:
> > >Chandan:
> > >I asked the question:
> > >Why the South seems to be better disciplined in
> > educational 
> > >institutions in India specially in Medicine? What
> 
=== message truncated ===



                
__________________________________ 
Do you Yahoo!? 
Read only the mail you want - Yahoo! Mail SpamGuard. 
http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail 
_______________________________________________
Assam mailing list
[email protected]
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Mailing list FAQ:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
To unsubscribe or change options:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam

Reply via email to