Hi All, The way I see it, again my humble opinion, the folks joing ULFA (around late 80's)were looking for a career in politics. Looking at ex-Chief Minister Prafulla Mahanta and his followers, they made that a career just as a student all the way by agitating and finding their jobs. However their choices of career came at the expense of lives and hence civilization.
Now the past two generations are following in their foot steps. There are other careers in addition to political positions. Besides, there can be only one Chief Minister, and I repeat, there will be no "Prime Minister of Assam," in all of the agitators' life times. That is a bold predication! It is therefore highly recommended that we as intellectuals support civilization in Assam and the only anti-civilized group that I find in Assam are those who are not studying and developing their brains and minds. Instead they are learning to flex their muscles only to be consumed. I really feel strongly about the stand that a discussion board such as this should take. That should be for evolutionary purposes. Revolution is not needed in a country which already is democratic. Before one argues for anti-democratic ways of solving problems in Assam, I would like to know what is the end product of the government system? How can we expect a bunch of high school dropouts hiding in the mountains and not knowing anything about civilization can bring in civilization to Assam, which is part of already a democratic constitution. Are these the sons and daughters of the Ahom kingdom? The logic baffles me. -Bipin ------------------ Civilization and Its Enemies : The Next Stage of History by Lee Harris Editorial Reviews >From Publishers Weekly Harris seems to have burst on the scene with a series of articles in the Hoover Institution's Policy Review. These articles, according to the publisher, created a tremendous buzz, and they form the basis of this book, arguing that in the aftermath of September 11, America must regard itself as the legitimate defender of world civilization. Because Americans are so highly civilized, Harris maintains, they "forget" the realpolitik truths of enmity and barbarianism, and he has come to sound the alarm. Western "liberal left" intellectuals mislead, Harris says, by mistakenly dignifying al-Qaeda as political activists instead of dismissing them as a gang of ruthless "fantasists" who don't share any of our assumptions about how the world should work. Generally ignoring the lessons of other countries' experiences of terrorism, Harris dwells instead on the failures of WWI-era liberal internationalism and on the fantasist ideologies of Hitler and Mussolini. Seeking throughout to boost the notion of American cultural superiority, he turgidly presents Greek and Roman models of social stability that he claims inform the civilizing "team player" patriotism of Americans, as opposed to the weaker structures of tribal loyalty of the "old world." Stale assertions apart, Harris is suspiciously defensive when deriding a nebulously drawn figure of the contemporary Western intellectual, whom he sees as sustained by dreamy cosmopolitan utopianism. Choosing not to engage much with such thinkers, Harris instead tries to hoist them by their own postmodern petard. His reasonable-sounding dismissal of the [pst-Enlightenment reign of reason and his assumption that his reader, an American, can be rallied through a potted education in civilization prevent this deeply rhetorical extended essay from accomplishing much true intellectual work. Copyright � Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. Product Description: Forgetfulness occurs when those who have been long inured to civilized order can no longer remember a time in which they had to wonder whether their crops would grow to maturity without being stolen or their children sold into slavery by a victorious foe....They forget that in time of danger, in the face of the enemy, they must trust and confide in each other, or perish....They forget, in short, that there has ever been a category of human experience called the enemy. "That, before 9/11, was what had happened to us. The very concept of the enemy had been banished from our moral and political vocabulary. An enemy was just a friend we hadn't done enough for yet. Or perhaps there had been a misunderstanding, or an oversight on our part -- something that we could correct.... "Our first task is therefore to try to grasp what the concept of the enemy really means. The enemy is someone who is willing to die in order to kill you. And while it is true that the enemy always hates us for a reason, it is his reason, and not ours." So begins Civilization and Its Enemies, an extraordinary tour de force by America's "reigning philosopher of 9/11," Lee Harris. What Francis Fukuyama did for the end of the Cold War, Lee Harris has now done for the next great conflict: the war between the civilized world and the international terrorists who wish to destroy it. Each major turning point in our history has produced one great thinker who has been able to step back from petty disagreements and see the bigger picture -- and Lee Harris has emerged as that man for our time. He is the one who has helped make sense of the terrorists' fantasies and who forces us most strongly to confront the fact that our enemy -- for the first time in centuries -- refuses to play by any of our rules, or to think in any of our categories. We are all naturally reluctant to face a true enemy. Most of us cannot give up the myth that tolerance is the greatest of virtues and that we can somehow convert the enemy to our beliefs. Yet, as Harris's brilliant tour through the stages of civilization demonstrates, from Sparta to the French Revolution to the present, civilization depends upon brute force, properly wielded by a sovereign. Today, only America can play the role of sovereign on the world stage, by the use of force when necessary. Lee Harris's articles have been hailed by thinkers from across the spectrum. His message is an enduring one that will change the way readers think -- about the war with Iraq, about terrorism, and about our future. ----------------------- Reviews ... This is an important book that is well worth reading. Many of the author's arguments and insights are provocative, often, in my view, true, and even when doubtful still worth pondering. I would summarize his argument like this: civilization in the West has been so successful that it has blinded us to what is necessary to create such a civilization in the first place, and what may be necessary from time to time to defend it, i.e., ruthlessness. The story of Western Civilization is the story of how ruthlessness was harnessed by male gangs for a larger public good. Ancient Sparta, whose male population spent almost their entire lives preparing for war, is the foundational example for this claim. What I called blindness, the author calls forgetfulness, and clearly his purpose is to remind us that civilization requires violence and conflict both as a necessary pre-condition, and in the face of an utterly ruthless enemy. Some will object that if we are as ruthless as our enemy, an enemy guided by what the author calls a `fantasy ideology,' then we are no better than they; but the author responds that ruthlessness in the service of civilization is morally superior to ruthlessness in service of a fantasy ideology whose purpose is to destroy civilization. In this sense, 911 was a purely symbolic act of destruction since there was never any tangible goal that could be realized within the confines of our enemy's fantasy ideology. It was purely destructive. The author's argument is developed mostly by reference to well-known political thinkers such as Plato, Rousseau and especially Hegel, as well as certain historical analyses of events or peoples such as the Spartans mentioned above. The tone of the book is slow and deliberate, but it still moves along quickly. As original and interesting as Mr. Harris can be, there are times when he steers perilously close to truism and clich�. His presentation of the ideas of Plato, Rousseau and Hegel, are all accurate as far as they go, but nevertheless, superficial. Other thinkers who have clearly influenced the author are never mentioned including most obviously, Machiavelli, Hannah Arendt and Carl Schmitt. Much as Eric Voegelin is rightly criticized for attributing far too much historical significance to a tiny heretical Christian sect, the Gnostics, so too Lee Harris can be criticized for attributing far too much importance to ancient Sparta. One may be able to see the phenomenon that the author wants to examine in an extreme case like Sparta, but Sparta is not at all a typical case. It simply did not have the kind of historical influence on the future of Western civilization that the author suggests. The issue of forgetfulness is also problematic. I take his claim to be that we have not only forgotten what was necessary to create civilization, but we have forgotten that we have real enemies in the world. I just don't think either is really the case. Students in school today dwell almost obsessively on the horrors of the past, on slavery and the mistreatment of native Americans, for example. Like Philoctetes obsessing over his festering wound, far from forgetting the horrors of the past, they are drilled into us. What we don't learn is the lesson, or at least we don't raise the question, whether our ability to examine the past in this way is built upon the very acts we condemn. As for foreign enemies, it has only been about 15 years since the collapse of the Soviet Union, and fifty since the end of W.W.II. Most people know that we have had foreign enemies even in the recent past. The problem is what do we do about them and here I think the pragmatism of Americans that the author rightly praises is part of the problem. Our tendency is to think all conflicts can be compromised if we just roll up our sleeves, meet the other side halfway, and prepare to give a little to get a little. Some have turned this traditional pragmatic approach into an abstraction that must apply in all cases so we assume it applies to our enemy as well. But if our enemy divides the world into the righteous and the infidel, and in his eyes we are the infidel, and if he believes that he has not just a right, but a positive obligation, to kill us, then there is nothing to compromise and no agreement will ever be possible. It is very difficult to give up the pragmatism that civilization cultivates when you confront an enemy who seeks your destruction. The author's discussion of intellectuals, though I think it has some truth to it, over-generalizes. Yes, intellectuals tend to develop abstract models, and yes, they are often surprised to discover that the real world just does not always go along. But intellectuals are usually pretty smart, at least the ones I know are, and they know that this is a danger. Most also know that just because it sounds good in the classroom, that does not mean it will work in the real world. It might be fair to say that since W.W.II, we have developed our own fantasy ideology around the abstract pragmatism I mentioned above, and that some intellectuals played an important role in this. The tendency to over-generalize, however, is another pit-fall that the author does not always manage to negotiate. What is perhaps most admirable about the book is the author's willingness to follow his argument wherever it goes without regard for political posturing. It may well be, as some critics have noted, that the book fits more easily into a conservative framework, but there is never any sense that the author starts out to write a conservative tract. He simply follows his mind where it leads him. In any case, there are claims in this book which will offend just about everyone including many conservatives. At the end, though, we expect some practical advice on how to proceed once we recognize that we have an enemy who can only be dealt with ruthlessly. What are we to do exactly? The author mentions the Iraq War a few times in passing and seems to have opposed it, but why? Does not this war cultivate precisely the kind of ruthlessness we need to defeat our enemy? There are many paradoxes at work in this book. It is both original and insightful while at the same time superficial and almost trite. It is modest and measured in tone, yet its purpose is to reveal the value, and indeed the necessity, of ruthlessness. It is a theoretical work which claims, correctly in my view, that we ought to take our bearings from practical activity. Some of these paradoxes can be understood in the sense that the author's aim is to lift the veil of civilization so as to reveal the unpleasant truths underneath. But outwardly many of us accept the veil even though inwardly we know about the unpleasant truths it conceals. Maybe that partially explains the paradoxical tone of the book. It tells us truths, truisms even, that we already know but keep concealed in polite company. If someone declares himself our enemy our outward self wants to understand why and negotiate, even as our inward self knows that at least in this case, no negotiation is possible which means killing them before they kill us (i.e. being ruthless). As I said, this is a serious book written by a serious thinker, and notwithstanding my own criticisms, it is well worth reading. Was this review helpful to you? (Report this) -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Customer Reviews Avg. Customer Review: Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers. 72 of 76 people found the following review helpful: may change the way you think, February 26, 2004 Reviewer: Marvin S. Cohen (Arlington, VA USA) - See all my reviews This book is a rare combination of common sense, depth of thought, breadth of knowledge, originality, and analytical and logical sophistication. Harris writes well, and at times humorously, but (with the possible exception of the first chapter), this is not a predigested easy read. The first chapter offers a stimulating interpretation of the motivation of the perpetrators of 9/11; the attack was less a means to an end (e.g., strike terror in the US population as a means to cause US withdrawal from the Middle East) , than a theatrical demonstration, for the benefit of other Muslims, that Allah favors the triumph of Islam and the fall of the Great Satan. "Fantasy ideologies" are able to thrive because of the decline of political realism in states whose existence and wealth has not been earned by their own effort, but are (ironically) protected by the current international order. The central theme of the book, however, is the concept of the enemy: why enemies must be overcome in the founding of a civil society as well in its maintenance, why rational self-interest cannot explain the origin of social order (contrary to Hobbes and many others), and why the category of the enemy itself tends to be forgotten or dismissed by successful societies. Such societies also forget the ruthlessness that was historically required to achieve their success and which, Harris argues, is also required for their continuing survival. By the same token, the enculturation of a non-rational, intuitive sense of shame and a similarly instinctive sense of trust are necessary for the suppression of internal violence, hence the survival, of all societies, including liberal ones. Harris defends and carries out what I would call a naturalistic approach to social and political theory, which gives priority to careful study, analysis, and interpretation of actually existing societies and their origins. The opposite approach, developing an abstract ideal concept and comparing existing societies to it, inevitably finds the real world to be hopelessly defective. Starting with abstractions can be dangerous, too, since it obscures what has been accomplished up to the present and therefore what we stand to lose, fails to recognize and even disparages essential elements of social survival, and diverts attention from what might actually be accomplished in the future. Harris addresses problems from multiple angles, e.g., a counterintuitive historical analysis of the contribution of ancient Spartan society to Western freedom, convincing arguments against European political theorists from Rousseau to Marx, discussion of the role the Protestant conscience played in providing a social infrastructure for modern Western society, a defense of objective criteria in the comparison of cultures and what different cultures might learn from one another in a more hardnosed approach to multiculturalism, and a critique of the abstraction bias that is a built-in threat to the plausibility of academic thought. One of the real pleasures of this book is the sense of being in the company of an author who has set out to tackle weighty matters with integrity, thoughfulness, humility, and commitment. Harris' recommended cure for intellectualist biases includes confrontation with reality and with competing ideas. I think he has been quite successful in both. Marvin Cohen Was this review helpful to you? (Report this) 96 of 101 people found the following review helpful: Absolutely Must Reading, January 31, 2004 Reviewer: Dr. Jonathan Dolhenty (Port Orford, OR United States) - See all my reviews The catastrophic event that has come to be known simply as 9/11 was unique in American history. We had been brutally attacked. But by whom? Not by another country, as we soon discovered. Not by some vile dictator or head-of-state, as we later discovered. So who? Who was the enemy? Then, of course, came the question: Why were the World Trade Center and the Pentagon attacked in the first place? Why would someone deliberately, maliciously murder thousands of ordinary, innocent people? "Civilization and Its Enemies" is an attempt by Lee Harris to answer these and other questions. The work is a brilliant analysis of the current geopolitical situation and how it came to be what it is. More significantly, it provides an insight into the historical precipitates and intellectual foundations and foibles which may account for the 9/11 tragedy. "The subject of this book," says Harris on the opening page, "is forgetfulness." Modern civilization has forgotten how it became civilized in the first place; it isn't knowledgeable of the long period of cultural evolution involved; and it doesn't remember the tremendous amount of labor, cultural and intellectual, that went into the development of civil society. Moreover, modern civilization has forgotten about a category called "the enemy." This concept of the enemy -- someone who is willing to die to kill another -- had been discarded from our moral and political discourse. And that fact, according to Harris, has left modern civilization vulnerable to attack by those who are the enemy of civilized society. This is an interesting thesis and, at first glance, may appear to be an implausible explanation for the 9/11 tragedy which was, according to the author, an end in itself and not a means to some other political or social end. Many contemporary observers may find this latter statement problematic since we are so accustomed to thinking in terms of warfare as a means to an end. Harris suggests that our ordinary understanding about what wars are and why they are fought is not applicable to the current conflict with terrorism. The nature of the game, so to speak, has changed and so has the enemy, and 9/11 was a manifestation of that change. So, who is this enemy and what is his intent? How did civilization get itself into this situation where it became so vulnerable to this enemy? What is the historical backdrop? What were the social and cultural influences? Who or what is really responsible? What can modern civilization do, if anything, to protect itself? Harris's discussion of these questions takes the reader on a tour through the development of civilization from antiquity to the present day, forming the framework with which he analyzes our current dilemma and providing a rationale for his conclusions. One of the most interesting of his discussions has to do with what Harris calls "fantasy ideology" and the related "transformative belief." He also points out the difference between abstract reasoning and concrete reasoning and discusses the "fanaticism" of abstract thought, important elements in the presentation of his argument. His concept of fantasy ideology is familiar to me because, while I use a different term to describe the phenomenon, it appears to be a subcategory of what I have called "intellectual insanity" in my own writings. Modern intellectuals are particularly susceptible to this type of thinking, which eventually leads them into the irrational abyss of moral and cultural relativism, epistemological subjectivism, metaphysical idealism, politicism, and scientism. Harris does more, of course, than just provide us with the historical background and intellectual underpinnings which have led to our present situation. He deals with the practical matter of our current conflict with "the enemy," giving us his prescriptions about how we should meet and confront the problem in the very real context within which we have to deal with it. Many intellectuals, especially those in the academic enterprise, will recoil at some of his suggestions. But the problem we face today, the author says, is this: "The ideals that our intellectuals have been instilling in us are utopian ideals, designed for men and women who know no enemy and who do not need to take precautions against him." These utopian ideals are dangerous because they are out of touch with the situation as it really is. The new enemy of civilization does not play his "war" game according to the rules we are used to; indeed, as far as he is concerned there are no rules at all. Our intellectuals and those who influence our social and political policies must come to realize this. Our old categories of thought and analysis will no longer suffice. And this brings Harris to what may be his most controversial conclusion as far as the academic intellectuals are concerned. Only the United States can play the sovereign in today's world. And if the use of force is necessary to defend civilization, then America will have to use it. At the same time Harris realizes the responsibilities involved in this type of action and points out the necessity, and dilemma, of being ruthless in the defense of civilization while not succumbing to ruthlessness itself. However, because it has produced, over a long period of time and through many sociopolitical conflicts, a practical design for solving and settling problems without resorting to massive ruthlessness, the United States is the only nation which can do the job required if civilization is to be defended and the enemy defeated. This is an important book that every American citizen should read. It should be required reading for our college and university students who are so desperately in need of intellectual guidance through the realities of the current geopolitical conflict which puts civilization itself in jeopardy. My only criticism of the book is that Harris needs to recognize there are some intellectuals around who don't subscribe to utopian fantasies and the fanaticism of abstract thought. I like to think I'm one of them. _______________________________________________ Assam mailing list [email protected] http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam Mailing list FAQ: http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html To unsubscribe or change options: http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam
