>Why?
>That is because *I* hold the membership of this forum to a higher
standard.
So you judge yourself to be higher standard member
of the forum than the rest of us Nodai-Bhodais? How? By taking the
popular Assamese position of blaming everything on GOI for Assam's
problems?
I sau Hobo Diok.
RB/
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Saturday, January 01, 2005 9:46
AM
Subject: Re: RE: Fwd: [Assam] 25 October
Sentinel report
Rajen:
>Unless you agree to this with your heart and
not just to 'humor me', it is pointless for me response what I would
do
You are asking me to agree that:
You should have known that
the correct Indian approach will be :
(1) By doing all of the
below:
By being abusive to them, by
criticizing them, by fighting against them attempting to defeat them
militarily, by refusing to recognize their
demand.
(2) And showing to do all of
the below:
>By sitting down with them, trying to
reason with them, by trying to present an alternative to their >demand that
both of you might be able to live with.
*** I won't go hair-splitting on an impromptu response you made, just
like most of us do. In other words I won't get into the minutiae of the
detailed meanings of the words and phrases like a lawyer might in a court of
law.
But there are two things to note:
1: You are
making a statement to characterize HOW the Indian
people might respond.
2: But you are
not speaking for yourself here, sharing how YOU would
respond.
You are right about how the "Indian people", whoever they might consist
of might behave:
>By being abusive to them, by
criticizing them, by fighting against them attempting to defeat them
>militarily, by refusing to recognize their demand.
I say might, because just because it has been the policy of successive
Indian Govts., and because they were elected nominally 'democratically', the
policy never was discussed nationally, like few things in Indian
democracy ever do.
The media gave scant coverage, the intelligentsia never stepped in to
voice their considered pinions. They could not care less.
But I will ignore that for the moment. That is not the point I am
pursuing.
I asked Alpana what she would do. It is the same thing as asking what you
would do, under the circumstances. Having observed the futility of pursuing
for a quarter century an unproductive policy, what would YOU recommend?
And let us also not forget that it was in the CONTEXT of Mamoni Goswami's
initiative.
You would NOT respond to that.
When you did, respond, partly, you attributed your support to Mamoni
Goswami with a really confusing explanation. It was not credible. Just ask
anybody, even your most ardent supporters in these debates.
*** It is NOT my approach to discussing an issue or participating
in a debate by speculating on what others might think, or believe.
But I speak MY mind, even at the risk of being unpopular. I explain what
I think or I believe, HOPING that I would encourage others to visit or even
re-visit the issue and exercise critical analysis, and not merely go with the
flow, even though that is very convenient to do, and is an universal
phenomenon.
Why?
That is because *I* hold the membership of this forum to a higher
standard.
Hope I have been clear Rajen.
c
At 8:48 AM -0600 12/30/04, Barua25 wrote:
>*** OK, fine
Rajen. I'll go along with your conclusion, an Indian will do all of that. It
would not speak very highly of this Indian's >intellect, but I will go
along with it, just to humor you.
>My question
would be: What would YOU do Rajen?
Chandan:
Unless you agree to
this with your heart and not just to 'humor me', it is pointless for me
response what I would do. I am the one who is asking the question. If you
agree with me what would you do.I have already seen what you are doing if
you don't agree. Only thing you have not told me why you don't agree with
me.
Rajen
----- Original Message -----
From: Chan
Mahanta
To: Barua25 ;
Alpana B. Sarangapani ; Chan Mahanta
Cc: [email protected]
Sent: Thursday, December 30, 2004 8:19 AM
Subject: Re: RE: Fwd: [Assam] 25 October Sentinel
report
At 12:08 AM -0600 12/30/04, Barua25 wrote:
>Which?
>Take a wild guess
A.
Chandan:
You should have known that
the correct Indian approach will be :
(1) By doing all of the
below:
By being abusive to them, by
criticizing them, by fighting against them attempting to defeat them
militarily, by refusing to recognize their
demand.
(2) And showing to do all of
the below:
By sitting down with them,
trying to reason with them, by trying to present an alternative to their
demand that both of you might be able to live
with.
So that in case of
failure, Indians can say look, we did everything humanly
possible. What more can we do?
*** OK, fine Rajen. I'll go along with your conclusion, an
Indian will do all of that. It would not speak very highly of this
Indian's intellect, but I will go along with it, just to humor
you.
My question would be: What would YOU do Rajen? Don't burden
yourself unnecessarily with what Joe-Blow Indian would do. I wouldn't want
to put anyone in a spot by asking him or her to speak for
others.
But what would YOU do? Would that be YOUR prescription? And
if not what might that be?
Chandan:
Please try to understand your friends and
enemies.
*** I realize it sounds like a desperate plea. But plea for
what? I have lot of friends, but who are my enemies? What do I need to
understand about them? I have no clue about what you are talking of. You
will need to explain.
c
RB/-
----- Original Message -----
From: Chan
Mahanta
To: Alpana B.
Sarangapani
Cc: [email protected]
Sent: Wednesday, December 29, 2004 10:02
PM
Subject: Re: RE: Fwd: [Assam] 25 October Sentinel
report
>In any case, up until now like many of Assam, I
am not convinced that there is >a need for
sovereignty.
That is not the point Alpana. YOU are not demanding
sovereignty and are in rebellion. Does not matter whether you
agree with those who do. But if you want peace you will have to make
it with those who are in rebellion.
And how will you do that?
By being abusive to them, by criticizing them, by fighting
against them attempting to defeat them militarily, or by refusing to
recognize their demand?
Or by sitting down with them, trying to reason with them,
by trying to present an alternative to their demand that both of you
might be able to live with?
Which?
Take a wild guess A.
At 7:42 PM -0600 12/29/04, Alpana B. Sarangapani
wrote:
Okay, C'da. No
argument.
I, too, wanted to share this (pl. see below) with you,
from the report that Jugal and you put together for this
month's newsletter, where it shows what took her to want to bring
the parties together.
"Dr. Goswami was
quite shocked by the Dhemaji bombing incident last year
and
wanted to bring the two parties to the conflict, the ULFA and
the Government of India,
together to the negotiating table in pursuit of a negotiated,
political settlement."
http://assam.org/newsletter/december2004.pdf
To some, it might seem like a pleading for peace in
desperation: For God's sake, give them whatever and let this
mindless killing of innocent people (including of children) be
stopped.
In any case, up until now like many of Assam, I am
not convinced that there is a need for sovereignty. The state
getting more money, freedom to do business, like the states in
the US, but Assam, a country? Do we want to be like Bhutan, Nepal or
Tibet? What about Bangladesh and Myanmar, erstwhile Maan-dexh?
If that happens, historically, not just to the most popular
year of Yandabu 'xondhi' (treaty), but it could go back beyond that
and there might be another chapter in history called, Maanor Oxom
aakromon, or Bangla-dexor Oxom aakromon (invasion).
>From: Chan Mahanta
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >To:
[EMAIL PROTECTED] >CC:
[email protected] >Subject: Fwd: [Assam] 25 October
Sentinel report on Mamoni Roisom Goswami & the
ULFA. >Date: Tue, 28 Dec 2004 16:10:40 -0600 > >Hi
A: > >This is not exactly the news report that I read
where she said she
>would question the sincerity of the Indian Govt. if
it did not >respond to ULFA's interest in peace talks, but it
was from about the >same time. > >I am not about
to argue with you, F Dilip Deka who spoke to her >personally,
or anyone else about where Mamoni Goswami stands >vis-a-vis
ULFA's cause, but the report below might give you some >idea.
And after you read it, do share which part of it is surreal
to >you
:-). > >c-da > > > > > > > > >>X-Ironport-AV:
i="3.86,104,1096862400"; >> d="scan'217,208";
a="386160625:sNHT21208652" >>X-Originating-IP:
[195.93.33.13] >>X-Originating-Email:
[EMAIL PROTECTED] >>X-Sender:
[EMAIL PROTECTED] >>From: "Bartta Bistar"
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >>To:
[email protected] >>Date: Wed, 27 Oct 2004 06:11:48
+0000 >>X-OriginalArrivalTime: 27 Oct 2004 06:12:02.0519
(UTC) >> FILETIME=[E0211670:01C4BBEB] >>Subject:
[Assam] >> 25 October Sentinel report on Mamoni Roisom
Goswami & the ULFA. >>X-BeenThere:
[email protected] >>X-Mailman-Version:
2.1.1 >>List-Id: A Mailing list for people interested in
Assam from around >>the world >>
<assam.pikespeak.uccs.edu> >>List-Unsubscribe: >><http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam>, >>
<mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >>List-Archive:
<http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/pipermail/assam> >>List-Post:
<mailto:[email protected]> >>List-Help:
<mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >>List-Subscribe:
<http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam>,
>>
<mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >>Sender:
[EMAIL PROTECTED] >> >>Dear
Readers, >> >> >> >>I am pasting
the full text of the above news report below because >>of
the interest it has generated and the importance it carries
for >>the public
good. >> >> >> >>The originator
of Bartta Bistar is not receiving any financial gain >>in
pasting the report in this
mail. >> >> >> >>Yours
sincerely, >> >> >> >>Bartta
Bistar >> >> >> >>Listen to
ULFA�s argument: Mamoni >> >>By a Staff
Reporter >>GUWAHATI, Oct 24: Noted Assamese litterateur and
Jyanpith Award >>winner Dr Indira Goswami, popularly known
as Mamoni Raisom Goswami, >>who is trying to create an
atmosphere for talks with the outlawed >>United Liberation
Front of Asom (ULFA), today said that she was >>sympathetic
to the outfit�s causes and added that the rebel
group�s >>sovereignty argument should be listened to during
the talks process >>to find out a permanent solution to the
vexed insurgency problem in >>the
State. >> >>Talking to The Sentinel over telephone
from New Delhi, Dr Goswami >>said, "I am sympathetic to the
causes the ULFA have been fighting >>for the past 25 years.
Whether they would get a sovereign state or >>not is a
different matter, but it should be discussed at
the >>negotiating table." Sovereignty must be included in
the agenda in >>the ULFA-Government talks as it was the
core subject, she stressed. >> >>Stating that she
does not believe in violence, Dr Goswami said that >>it was
unfortunate that no one had come forward since the
inception >>of the ULFA about 25 years back to initiate the
process to bring >>the insurgent group to the negotiating
table. >> >>She said that she would submit a
�written appeal� before Prime >>Minister Dr Manmohan Singh
in the first week of November to start >>parleys with the
ULFA. "Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi has already >>given the
go ahead and is helping fix an appointment with the
Prime >>Minister," she said, adding that an appointment
with the Prime >>Minister is likely in the first week of
next month. >> >>She further said that the same
appeal would be submitted before >>AICC chief Sonia Gandhi.
"I have already prepared a written appeal. >>Noted
political scientist and professor at the Delhi
University
>>Manoranjan Mohanti helped me in preparing the
appeal," she said. >>However, she did not divulge the
contents of the appeal, except >>that it would contain a
plea to hear out the ULFA�s
sovereignty >>argument. >> >>Following
submission of the appeal to the Prime Minister, the
ball >>for talks with the ULFA would lie in the Union
Government�s court,
>>Dr Goswami
said. >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >>Express
yourself instantly with MSN
Messenger! >><http://g.msn.com/8HMAEN/2740??PS=47575>MSN
Messenger Download >>today it's
FREE! >> >>_______________________________________________ >>Assam
mailing
list >>[email protected] >>http://pikespeak.uccsedu/mailman/listinfo/assam >> >>Mailing
list
FAQ: >>http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html >>To
unsubscribe or change
options: >>http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam
_______________________________________________ Assam
mailing
list [email protected] http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam
Mailing
list FAQ: http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html To
unsubscribe or change
options: http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam
|