----- Original Message -----
Sent: Sunday, January 02, 2005 9:54
AM
Subject: Re: [Assam] Educational
Institutions in India
Rajen, Ram and Rajib:
Here is my response to Rajen's leading question:
>Question: Why the South seems to
be better disciplined in educational
>institutions in India specially
in >Medicine?
*** The premise of the question is patently untrue.
Better disciplined than what? Assam, Bihar, Delhi, Bengal,
Andamans?
There were fine medical colleges in India going back a century. The
premier ones were in Kolkata and Mumbai. Later came AIIMS, Chandigarh Medical
College etc. They are not the South. Of course there were good schools in the
South too. I don't remember the name, but one is from Andhra.
These have been there far far longer than Manipal.
And let us look at OTHER educational institutions:
Calcutta University, Presidency College, Jadavpur U., BE College, Delhi
U, MS U in Baroda, Aligarth Muslim U, Benares Hindu U -- and dozens of others
like that have produced some of India's best from over a century ago. Add to
that the IITs, Roorkee U, BIT and others that appeared fifty or more years
ago, none of them were from the South.
Don't they count?
So is it a question of the South and its discipline at the root of the
successes of these institutions? Is there a natural link here?
The question is a contrived one designed to lead to a desired answer.
It was absolutely NOT a question to attempt to gage the conditions of
education in India.
If it was then the wrong question was asked under the wrong
premise.
>Sometime it looks like South India is
more Mainlanland India.
** What on earth is this supposed to mean? Is there such a thing as
a,'mainland
India' and there are those that are 'pabot-goza' India, not quite like
the 'mainland' India?
The whole notion of India at the time of independence was one of
pluralism. Which by definition accepts diversity of its many constituents
without hegemony of one over the other.
The fact that it has NOT turned out that way is a failure of the Indian
experiment. But that is a different matter.
Is this question implying that the South alone has been able to forge the
dream of Indian nationhood, unlike the rest? If so, what is the evidence to
support such a premise? That the Owners of Manipal Institute, who are from the
South opening branches in Nepal and Thailand?
Is this a serious question deserving a serious reply?
>Why they donot revolt against the
domination of the Hindi-wallas?
What does this question have to do with the premise of the question
:
>Why the South seems to be better
disciplined in educational
>institutions in India specially
in >Medicine?
Is it a natural corollary to it? Or is it a convoluted and contrived
attempt
to somehow connect it to the NE's disgruntlement, which Rajib dutifully
complied with and gave his verdict with rahs from Ram and the ever so gentle
applauds from Bhuban Kokaideu :-)?
>The South seem to be progressing
completely ignoring or in spite of the Hindi belt North India. Or is
>the South gradually taking over the North?
If Rajen had the courage of his convictions, he would have asked a
straight forward question. Something like:
*** Assam
complains too much about domination by the Hindi belt
politics. But I
don't believe it is so. Just look at the South.
They are doing
well in spite of the same conditions that they face
from the Hindi belt.
That would have been an intellectually honest proposition, even though it
would be a faulty one. But At least we could have debated that with integrity
instead of in the sly.
c
At 2:40 PM -0600 12/29/04, Barua25 wrote:
Blue
Thoughts:
It seems some
Indian educational institutions are doing great. Take for instance the
welknown : Manipal Medical College. I came to know that they have now
opened brnaches even in Nepal and Thailand and are attarcting lot of
international students.
Question: Why
the South seems to be better disciplined in educational
institutions in India specially in Medicine? What is the secret?
Sometime it looks like South India is more Mainlanland India. Why they
donot revolt against the domination of the Hindi-wallas? Why they donot
hate India like the North East? The South seem to be progressing
completely ignoring or in spite of the Hindi belt North India. Or is
the South gradually taking over the North?
RB