Now, this is a novel concept. Is there any country where negative political vote is practised?
Counting Negative Vote would be similar to customer surveys that we see in USA where the response could range from, "strongly agree", to "strongle disagree" with various shades in between and numerical value attached to each.
What would be the ramification in a political process?
Dilip
================================================================
Guwahati, Sunday, February 6, 2005
EDITORIAL
Right to cast �definite negative vote�
� Pranab Kr Saikia
Recent reports says that the Election Commission has supported the said petition which enable the voters to say that none of the candidates in the fray were worth his or her vote. Keeping the fact in mind, the Election Commission had already written to the Centre, once in 2001 and 2004, suggesting amendments to the Representation of People Act as that provision could be made in the ballot papers and the electronic voting machines allowing casting of negative vote by a voter. The two ! above written steps taken by the Election Commission definitely shows its noble motive to bring in positive changes in the electioneering process of our country. All walks of people, therefore, need to hail the Commission and support it in its endeavour.
The Bench of the Supreme Court comprising Chief Justice RC Lahoti and Justice GP Mathur also must be appreciated for asking EC counsel S Muralidhar to bring on record materials pertaining to provisions on negative vote adopted in other countries so as to assist the Court in forming an opinion on the issue. This act of the SC also shows its intention to see all the pros and cons of the issue and only then give its verdict. The same act of the SC further shows its judicious nature.
Looking into these facts, one will only conclude that whatever verdict the Supr! eme Court gives after studying all the relevant materials provided by the Election Commission, the practical conditions and other sources, will be the most rational and correct one.
But that is just a plain truth, a simple truth. It is the greatest need of the hour that we go deep into this truth and examine the minutest sediments in relation to the present condition of our country where we have been turned into helpless and mute spectators whereas the most heinous of culprits are capturing the Assembly and Parliamentary seats without any difficulty whatsoever but with very beautiful smiles.
The question before the Supreme Court now is whether to give its verdict in favour of the petition or not. Here, most people may want the SC to go in favour of giving the said right to the voter. That right, if given by the SC will only mean not adding any figure to any of the candidates in fray. Th! e meaning of this is nothing more than not casting one�s vote at all. What then ultimately is the beneficial outcome? And if this whole exercise means just not casting one�s vote, how shall anyone be motivated to go to the polling booth, stand in the queue for hours under various climatic conditions and ultimately come back giving nothing or getting nothing except the black mark on the index finger?
It is an excellent idea for the Supreme Court to ask the EC counsel S Muralidhar for relevant materials pertaining to the said subject. Detailed and in-depth study of all relevant and available materials will really place the SC in good standing before it goes to declare its verdict. But the present situation of the country demands much more than that. The demand of the hour is not just to judge whether a voter should be given the right to cast a negative vote whereby none of the candidates in fray gets any benefit, but the right to cast a �definite negative vote�. That is to say, ! she/he should have the right to cast the negative vote to a particular candidate who she/he feels may do more wrong and destruction than anything right or constructive. Because it is a fact that today most of the candidates are scoundrels. We are often put in a situation where we have to choose one among such scoundrels. Hence, it will be much better if we are given the right to cast our negative vote to the worst among these scoundrels whereby we can contribute in the substraction of a vote from the lot she/he gets. This way, we can at least prevent the worst from getting elected if we can not choose anyone good to cast our vote for.
To enable the voter to cast such a �definite negative vote� there should be proper provision in the ballot paper. Against the names of the candidates in fray, there should be printed two columns instead of just one that is customary. The first column should be meant �for votes� or �positive votes� whereas the second column should be meant for ! �against votes� or �negative votes�. Similarly, there should be two markers � one in black ink and the other in red ink. The black should be meant for the positive votes and column whereas the red should be meant for the negative votes and column. The number of negative votes a candidate gets, the same should be substracted from his scored votes. This system is sure to contribute a lot in getting cleaner people elected. Such a system will also go a long way in bringing the maximum number of voters to polling booths to exercise their franchise. Because a big problem a voter faces today is to choose the best from �no good� and hence she/he rather prefers to stay away from the system unable to decide whom to vote for.
To conclude, this has to be said that the process that has been started by People�s Union for Civil Liberties, aided by the! Election Commission and now under consideration of the Supreme Court, need to be dealt more specifically. Only that will make it meaningful and bring in the desired result. Instead of making a provision for just a general negative vote violating the code of secret ballot, provision should be made for a more specific or definite negative vote maintaining the code of secret ballot as is done in case of positive vote. Of course, serious discussions and debates on the topic by maximum number of people all over country is sure to produce the best result.
_______________________________________________ Assam mailing list [email protected] http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam
Mailing list FAQ: http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html To unsubscribe or change options: http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam
