2) Nobody of us know the actual problems of Assam, but (and that is why) we
are discussing and debating WHAT are the problems and HOW to solve
them.(YES/NO)

Chandan:
1) You did not answer my above question. Discussion does not mean 'pretend to know' but discuss to find out by brainstorming or otherwise. We don't pretend, we dont lecture, we dont impose, we discuss to find out taking inputs from various sources, if necessary from Assam. Nobody is trying to dictate that these are the problems, take it or leave it. The idea of the list is to brainstorm.


2) >>4) When KJD refutes and make a different statement for the same situation,
he does it because he perceives it differently (YES/NO)
> Maybe, maybe not. If you need explanations, please ask, and I will > explain.

Your above statement definitely need explanation!!!

Why should a public disagreement on our positions lead to ruining our friendships? Is our friendship built upon an agreement to agree only?

A friend is one with whom you discuss and get support and comfort in everything. A freind is one you can trust. Thus frienships are generraly built on agreement on the major issues. Among friends we may decide agree to disagree on certain points. It is more so in Assamese society. We normally donot make friends with guys who oppose our views. We may threat someone not as enemy but may not treat them as friends either. There is a greay area. (How many core AANA members you see having friends from core ASA group?). I donot consider anybody as enemy only because I donot agree. I donot consider ULFA as my enemy but not as my friends either. There is a difference. Our views affect our friendhsip. That is hunman nature. You and I may be exception. Let us keep it that way.


* I believe, that the GoI's concentrating most significant powers
state in its hands, without the checks and balances of a functioning
democratic governance, in a vacuum of accountability, in an environment
of opacity, has resulted in severe damage to Assam and the NE's
legitimate rights and interests in ways that should not happen
in a federal democratic republic as proposed at independence .

This is defeinitely a controversial area. People will normally agree with the view that Center has more power, that it is equally corrupt and that we need a change. What people may not agree, and where you may need supporting proofs and evidence with fact and figures, with your view that the present GOI policy is specifically biased towards NE only and not to other states.


* I also believe,from observations spanning decades, that India is
unable, or unwilling, or both--to institute radical reforms to
restore the essential institutions of democracy to a functioning,
        dependable state.

This is a highly controversial statement. Without any background supporting evidences, I donot agree to the above views. Basically I donot seem to understand what you are trying to say or mean. My bottomline question is even if your statement is correct, what does it mean? What you are trying to mean?


* Therefore, the only possible means left for those who wish to
institute such reforms is by way of establishing sovereign or
autonomous democratic governments.

You cannot use the word 'therefore' here, because the earlier statenment is not agreed upon or proved. Again you cannot lump Soveriegn and Autonomy together. In order to decetralize power, I , and I believe many others, will agree for more power in the hand of the states or an Autonomous Assam. Soveregn means a separate country. I personally believe that a Soevergn Assam will be like going from 'frying pan to fire' and should not be pursued at any cost. For me to believe otherwise, you need to argue with evidence and facts and figures.

* I also believe that some parts of Indian democracy has
        proven to be grossly defective, and have become a serious
        handicap to effective governance. Therefore, should Assam ever
        be able to fashion its own democratic government, either as an
        autonomous entity within a reformed Indian Union, or as a
        sovereign nation, it must change those. Again I am convinced it
        cannot happen under the existing Indian system.

This again another very controversial abd debatble topic. Without explanation, I donot know what to make of such statement. If you can show me what are those 'defective parts of Indian democracy' are which are 'serious handicap' to effective governance and why these cannot be changed under present Indian system. Again the bottomline question is even if I agree with everything you are saying, what solution you propose? If you are saying that the existing Inaidna system need to be radically changed, how do you propose to change it? That is the bottom line question. Are you going to TELL GOI to radically change.? By waging a WAR or HOW or you WISH that it will change?


You are entitled to your opinions Rajen. I can TELL the Indian Govt. to reform its democratic institutions forthwith. But is it going to happen? And how is it going to happen? It would help if you explain the whys and hows of your beliefs. Otherwise we would be expected to accept it because you say so. I am sure you don't expect that.

These are our opposing views. I don't want you to accept my views as I also do want to accept yours without conviction. I agree to that. For my part I am ready for discussion to prsent my views. Your should also be ready to present yours.


And to wish ULFA away maybe a good way to assert your own piety, your own goodness. I know many of us have done that. But such wishfulness only underscores their naivete.

I consider ULFA as a handicap to solving Assam's problems. I donot see how they are helping. I consider ULFA insurgency just as another problem for Assam to be put into the list of problems for solution. Question is whether you consider ULFA as such or not.


My last question: What do the above have to do with your LISt of Assam's PROBLEMS?

The idea of the list was to brainstorm with inputs from every quarter to evolve a comprehensive list of genuine problems. Was not that the first assumption of our discussiion to find out the problems and discuss the problems?. See my first response.


Thanks
Rajen


----- Original Message ----- From: "Chan Mahanta" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: "Barua25" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "ram Sarangapani" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Alpana B. Sarangapani" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Cc: <[email protected]>
Sent: Sunday, February 06, 2005 11:48 AM
Subject: Re: [Assam] Re: How We see Things



Rajen:

At 10:50 AM -0600 2/6/05, Barua25 wrote:
Chandan:
I don't know how to convince you what I am saying. You don't seeem to get
it. I am not trying to lecture, but let me try another way: Please tell me
which LINE ITEM you don't agree so that we can identify the GAP in our
understanding.
1) Let us say I, you, Ram. KJD. Rajib all in the net are observers. (YAS/NO)

*** I speak for myself only, and for me YES.

2) Nobody of us know the actual problems of Assam, but (and that is why) we
are discussing and debating WHAT are the problems and HOW to solve
them.(YES/NO)

*** If we DON'T know what they are, or we realize we are not in a position to know what all those might be, or what Assam thinks or believes they might be,
then why do you pretend that we can pin ALL of THEM down and offer to help Assam with solutions?


That is fine if you wish to do the exercise. It is fine if others participate. I have no problems with that. But WHY must or should *I* take that seriously, or think of it as something useful, and be charged with WHATEVER, when I choose not to participate ?

3) When you make certain statement in the net, you make it because you
percieve a sitaution that way. (YES/NO)

Yes.

4) When KJD refutes and make a different statement for the same situation,
he does it because he perceives it differently (YES/NO)

Maybe, maybe not. If you need explanations, please ask, and I will explain.


5) Now when we find from time to time that there is major differences in our
perceptions, then we try to convince the other guy why my perception is
correct why the other guy's perception is not (YES/NO)

Yes

6) When we find that we cannot agree with our perceptions, we should not
continue debating, because there is no point. We will never agree, unless
one can convince the other guy the differnt perception.(YES/NO)

Speaking for MYSELF again, maybe, maybe not. Depends upon context.

Now when I suggested for a private debate, I wanted to find out your
perception in private so that if I find that it is something I would never
agree, I would have told that Chandan, there is no point in our continued
debate because we will never agree. Let us not debate in public and ruin our
friendship. Instead, let us not debate but let agree to disagree and remain
friends.

Why should a public disagreement on our positions lead to ruining our
friendships? Is our friendship built upon an agreement to agree only? Did you not write only yesterday that: "--- 2) I never take things personally."

Now what I am finding is that following is our majoe difference in our
perception:
1) You think Assam is being colonized by GOI. The present democratic system
in Assam will not work unless it is radically changed to something else.
There is no point in discussing the problems because the soultion will not
work in the prsent systemn anyway.

Your perceptions, presented the way you do, are MOSTLY wrong:

* I believe, that the GoI's concentrating most significant powers
state in its hands, without the checks and balances of a functioning
democratic governance, in a vacuum of accountability, in an environment
of opacity, has resulted in severe damage to Assam and the NE's
legitimate rights and interests in ways that should not happen
in a federal democratic republic as proposed at independence .


* I also believe,from observations spanning decades, that India is
unable, or unwilling, or both--to institute radical reforms to
restore the essential institutions of democracy to a functioning,
        dependable state.

* Therefore, the only possible means left for those who wish to
institute such reforms is by way of establishing sovereign or
autonomous democratic governments.

* I also believe that some parts of Indian democracy has
        proven to be grossly defective, and have become a serious
        handicap to effective governance. Therefore, should Assam ever
        be able to fashion its own democratic government, either as an
        autonomous entity within a reformed Indian Union, or as a
        sovereign nation, it must change those. Again I am convinced it
        cannot happen under the existing Indian system.
2) I think GOI is not colonising Assam. The prsent democratic system in
Assam will work if it is reformed and democracy stregthened. ULFA should
stop their on their own activities if they love Assam. etc etc


You are entitled to your opinions Rajen. I can TELL the Indian Govt. to reform its democratic institutions forthwith. But is it going to happen? And how is it going to happen? It would help if you explain the whys and hows of your beliefs. Otherwise we would be expected to accept it because you say so. I am sure you don't expect that.


And to wish ULFA away maybe a good way to assert your own piety, your own goodness. I know many of us have done that. But such wishfulness only underscores their naivete.


My last question: What do the above have to do with your LISt of Assam's PROBLEMS?

c


_______________________________________________
Assam mailing list
[email protected]
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Mailing list FAQ:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
To unsubscribe or change options:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam

Reply via email to