Title: Re: [Assam] Re: How We see Things
Rajen:

Let us stop it, I don't want to spend any further energy in this fruitless excercise with you.
 
Let us stop this  and remain friends.



*** I will readily accede to your suggestion. And if I might add, I would remain your friend as long as you would let me, regardless of where our net arguments lead us :-).


Having said that, allow me to explain one thing here:

** The two statements -- yours and mine, that you think of as the same, are not at all so. Mine was a complaint about an attitude among certain individuals, while yours was a broad indictment, of passing broad judgement of an entire people's fitness to govern themselves, based upon your perception that the Assamese people lack courage to stand up for justice.

Justice requires due process in a democracy. You or I cannot just scream for justice, or harass our political reps. or leaders -- stand up to whatever --- as you frame it, and expect justice to fall into place.

It is a significant point of all we have been discussing. That India's, and subsequently Assam's democratic institutions that people can resort to obtain JUSTICE, are dysfunctional. They just don't work. It is only ONE of many such institutions.


Same thing about your question about 'Why culprits go unpunished in Assam?'

First of all, you are making it sound that only in Assam it happens that way. Actually the disease started elsewhere in India, and has now infected every nook and corner of the country. It is the norm now and not the exception.

'Culprits' don't get punished by the people or police on the spot in a democracy. There is a due process. It does not work in Assam, it does not work in India.

Now if we dig deeper into it, we will find many interrelated reasons for this.
If you wish to delve into them, I might join you, provided we do not go into another round of acrimonious arguments. But to make a long story short, it is a FAULT, a DEFECT of the Indian system of governance. It is not a typical problem of ALL DEMOCRACIES. It has nothing to do with the weakness of a democracy.

To change it, Indian democracy has to REFORM, CHANGE some of its institutional
processes.

There are plenty of people in India who know it. But to reform it would require a political will, which the fractured union cannot even get close to generating.


Just look at the issue of the demand to be able to vote NO on a candidate. It is a convoluted demand. People have gotten so used to the sanctity of the system in place, even educated and otherwise informed people believe that the system, the process could not or should not be changed or reformed. Now they want to establish a new law, so they can vote no to a particular candidate.

Just think of your own position --your faith in the system as sacrosanct, and when someone like myself criticizes it as requiring change or reforms, you go ballistic. That is from a person who has seen better. If you take that position, how do you think your compatriots in Assam will react? How would they DEMAND what is right or better?


Then if you go beat up on them, call them names, imply they are cowards, declare them unfit for "democracy", then you would have completed the full circle, of 'xaap hoiw khwta aaru bez hoiw zora". Even 'reputable' newspaper editorials in Assam indulge in that, not to mention Assam Netters, who taunt those , like Mamoni Goswami, or Sanjib Baruah, trying to change things because it involves stepping on what they, ignorantly,  hold sacrosanct and infallible.

Take care.


c

 











At 12:19 PM -0600 2/7/05, Barua25 wrote:
Rajen Barua::  Assamese do not have the courage to stand up for justice
 
Chandan Mahanta: There are plenty of people in Assam who are creative, ... But they are outnumbered. When they speak up, or when they attempt to speak up, they are brought down by their colleagues, their fellow men.
Problem is that EVEN those who know the difference won't stand-up and lend them a hand of support, even if only moral support.

Chandan:
The above shows that we are basicallly saying the same thing. But to you NO, You still want to split hair and lead the net through another excercise of arguments and counter arguments. I would have gladly done it if I would have known that you are serious.
 
Frankly speaking, I am finding it increasingly painfull to go over with you in this fruitless excercise of arguments and counter arguments just for the sake of arguments. You have not intention of doing it for any purpose to contribute towards Assam in any way but you are just doing it to try to throw a monkey wrench to our discussions just to show that whatever we try to do 'Won't work'. 
 
As such I think for the benefit of the netters, we should stop this kind of excercise which actually will end up in 'galw balw khwlakotir tal.' anyway
 
Let us stop it, I don't want to spend any further energy in this fruitless excercise with you.
 
Let us stop this  and remain friends.
 
Thanks
 
Hobo Diok.
 
Rajen
 
----- Original Message -----
From: Chan Mahanta
To: Barua25 ; ram Sarangapani
Cc: [email protected]
Sent: Monday, February 07, 2005 11:20 AM
Subject: Re: [Assam] Re: How We see Things

Rajen:

At 10:43 AM -0600 2/7/05, Barua25 wrote:
>your castigating the people of Assam in many of your recent remarks?


I will give you just one:


 (>If Assamese do not have the courage to stand up for justice, how one
       can even think of an >independendent Assam? That is why I said, Assamese
       are probably not fit for democracy. Do you >think Assamese nature will
        change overnite?)



Why don't you explain this. I have more, but that will come later if you insist.

c

















 
Would you elaborate on this. If I write something bitter or sweet I would mean it and would do it as self criticism and can justify. You may not like it. I cannot say Assamese donot have problems. Please tell me which one.
 
>Instead we should question each other why I think my way and why you think
>your way.


>Why should I get on your case and run an inquisition on you, Rajen? I don't hold YOU responsible for what is happening in India >and how it has influenced what is happening in Assam. You are NOT the issue, as far as I am concerned.  I know all I need to >know about you as a friend.
 
Chandan:
This is the most important part of our learining process. Unless we do that how do we learn. We all are reading or seeing the same messages, but are interpreting differently. The way you responded, as if it is my problem if I don't see the way you see. No, I need to know why you don't see the way I see. I cannot let this issue pass after we have gine thru the whole process. You must tell me why you perceive the way you do.
 
>BUT the main thing you should know about my approaches that you have missed all along is that I am NOT PROPOSING anything at all, much less change India or Assam.
>But I do see a possibility of Assam making a huge difference for itself in moving forward into the future, should it be freed of the >shackles of Indian misgovernment.
 
Chandan:
I don't know what to say. The above is not even wishfull thinking!!! Just a csual thinking as if you don't have any interest in it. I cannot believe you are that dis interested for the future of Assam.
 
>I can Rajen, but I don't think it would be useful for me to go thru the exercise if you cannot see it yourself. Because if you are so >oblivious of it, then it would be an entirely lost cause.
 
This is again, you are almost dumping me for failing to see things your way. In fact you could have dumped me at the very begining for this. In my opinion, every Assamese sees Assam's problem differently. That is why we have so many parties including ULFA.  I insist that you need to tell me what it is>
 
>But it will be nice to see what you had in mind when you declared that you will reform the Indian system when it is needed

 
One obvious reform that needed is to decentralise power. This can be done within the present system by reform within the democratic process making the states, or Assam & NE an Autonmous group. But for this we need to discuss what are the problems and what power we need which will be benefecial for NE.
 
>I know I am getting very subtly  nasty here :-).
 
No it is not a question of getting nasty. What you are doing is I would call: galw balw khwla-kotir tal.
If you had no intention of discussing any problems for contribution towards Assam, you could have told me and the net in the very beginning that all you were doing is excercise in dhemali. You actually don't mean it. I would not have wasted my time and energy in responding to your critical questions.
 
Rajen
 
--- Original Message -----
From: Chan Mahanta
To: Barua25 ; ram Sarangapani ; Alpana B. Sarangapani
Cc: [email protected]
Sent: Monday, February 07, 2005 8:36 AM
Subject: Re: [Assam] Re: How We see Things

Rajen:


All this time I submitted to your inquisition with answers to the best of my abilities.


But you don't answer anything I ask.


Of course that is your prerogative. Unfortunately we don't learn anything in the process.


I would close this chapter with the following reply here:



>Now if you really agree on our basic difference, you should not have
responded the way you responded below which is like calling Assamese names.



*** Say what?

Are you still smarting from my criticisms about your castigating the people of Assam in many of your recent remarks?  I think the best way to get over that would be for you to explain them, if you can.


Instead we should question each other why I think my way and why you think
>your way.


Why should I get on your case and run an inquisition on you, Rajen? I don't hold YOU responsible for what is happening in India and how it has influenced what is happening in Assam. You are NOT the issue, as far as I am concerned.  I know all I need to know about you as a friend.


In my case I am at least proposing a solution for reform (on which many like
>you may not have faith which is understandable).


Good for you. Shows you are contributing something to the discourse.


But you are not proposing
>anything. If you are proposing to change the system. HOW?


I know I am not. In fact I am acutely aware of the HARM I am doing to your (and others' who share your views) agendas by helping people look at issues critically, by analyzing.


BUT the main thing you should know about my approaches that you have missed all along is that I am NOT PROPOSING anything at all, much less change India or Assam. If I knew I had any ability to do so,change India, I would have. I happen to be very aware of my own limitations.

But I do see a possibility of Assam making a huge difference for itself in moving forward into the future, should it be freed of the shackles of Indian misgovernment. That could happen either thru sovereignty as being pursued by ULFA or thru a negotiated autonomous status within the Indian union. But
sovereignty or autonomy, by and of itself, will NOT change anything. In either case, Assam will HAVE to reform its governmental, system, purging all that is holding India back.


I asked:
If you can show me
what are those 'defective parts of Indian democracy' are which are 'serious
handicap' to effective governance and why these cannot be changed under
>present Indian system.


I can Rajen, but I don't think it would be useful for me to go thru the exercise if you cannot see it yourself. Because if you are so oblivious of it, then it would be an entirely lost cause.

But it will be nice to see what you had in mind when you declared that you will reform the Indian system when it is needed.


Are you going to TELL GOI to
>radically change.?


Come on Rajen. I explained so many times that I don't go about TELLING anyone anything, but you still keep asking. On the other hand you claimed you will change things. Naturally I get curious abut how you plan to do that. I am sure everyone else that believe changes are essential are as curious as well.



>By waging a WAR or HOW or you WISH that it will change?

Yes, a war is indeed called for. A war of ideas that is. I do my share to promote that by bringing issues out and analyzing them. I leave wishful thinking to those who for example admonishes ULFA to go away, or telling Assamese people to be more moral, and stuff like that. Not that those are bad ideas. But I know things don't work like that unless one is equipped with some supernatural powers.


>What solution you propose?.


Sorry Rajen, I am not a repository of solutions that I can hand out to India or Assam. That is for the people of and the people of Assam to find, after they determine the problem. I can barely manage my own life, and to go recommending solutions for such complicated issues to even Assam, forget India, will be a highly presumptuous proposition.


I know my limits all too well.


*****************************************************************************

I know I am getting very subtly  nasty here :-). But I hold nothing against you personally. Never did, never will.

And I hope to stay engaged in Assam net, and to engage in debates and conversations or just banter, with you and others like I always have. In other words, as they say here, I am not going to take my ball and go home.

Sorry we had to go thru this chapter of unpleasantness.

Take care.

*****************************************************************************

c





At 8:26 PM -0600 2/6/05, Barua25 wrote:
Chandan:
This is the difference of our perceptions I was referring to. Now that we
have identified our basic difference in perceptions, we will know where our
conflict in response or words are coming from.
Now if you really agree on our basic difference, you should not have
responded the way you responded below which is like calling Assamese names.

Instead we should question each other why I think my way and why you think
your way.
In my case I am at least proposing a solution for reform (on which many like
you may not have faith which is understandable). But you are not proposing
anything. If you are proposing to change the system, the obvious question to
be asked : HOW?
In another mail I asked the question to justify your perception of why the
reform cannot be done in the existing system: I asked:
If you can show me
what are those 'defective parts of Indian democracy' are which are 'serious
handicap' to effective governance and why these cannot be changed under
present Indian system. Again the bottomline question is even if I agree with
everything you are saying, what solution you propose? If you are saying that
the existing Inaidna system need to be radically changed, how do you propose
to change it? That is the bottom line question. Are you going to TELL GOI to
radically change.? By waging a WAR or HOW or you WISH that it will change?
In absence of an action plan, you have just presented a problem. What
solution you propose?.

Rajen

----- Original Message -----
From: "Chan Mahanta" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: "Barua25" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "ram Sarangapani"
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; "Alpana B. Sarangapani" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Cc: <[email protected]>
Sent: Sunday, February 06, 2005 6:28 PM
Subject: Re: [Assam] Re: How We see Things


>
> Rajen:
>
>
> >This is our main difference of convictions. Now I see why you don't want
to
> >discuss the problems.
> >
>
> >1) I want to solve the problems under the existing system or reforming
the
> >existing system if necessary.
>
>
> I wish you well on your endeavor. And when  you succeed, I will buy
> you a beer and together we shall celebrate. But don't forget to send
> me a note, when that happens :-).
>
>
> But till then, I would keep my ears cocked to hear HOW you and your
> allies in the effort intend to get that done. Obviously you have
> something up your sleeve that all the folks in Indian governance over
> the decades have had no clue about. For if they had, one might have
> guessed that after so much of expressions of despondence spanning
> decades, they would have attempted to do something about them.
>
>
>
>
> >2) You want to change the system. PERIOD. You think nothing short of that
> >will solve the problems whatever they are..
>
>
> I believe that India cannot forge the political will to institute the
> reforms the system that it so very badly needs. Indian intelligentsia
> knows what its problems are, because you can read it all over the
> place. It just cannot get any change to take place.
>
>
> That is different from how YOU phrase the statement above, implying
> that maybe Chandan wants a dictatorship in Assam, or a new kingdom,
> or whatever :-).
>
>
> The question for which it will still be nice to have an answer Rajen
> is: Why did you (and some other Netters) want ME to participate in
> putting together that master list of problems for Assam for which you
> are contemplating finding solutions :-)? And the list that you put
> together so-far, how are you proposing implementing that?
>
>
> c
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> At 3:17 PM -0600 2/6/05, Barua25 wrote:
> >* . Again I am convinced it (changes)
> >          cannot happen under the existing Indian system.
> >
> >Chandan:
> >The above is your statement of YOUR belief.. This is exaclty what I was
> >saying YOUR belief to be in the following:
> >According to me, YOU think
> >>The present democratic system
> >>  >in Assam will not work unless it is radically  changed to something
else.
> >>  >There is no point in discussing the problems because the soultion
will
> >not
> >>  >work in the prsent systemn anyway.
> >
> >This is our main difference of convictions. Now I see why you don't want
to
> >discuss the problems.
> >1) I want to solve the problems under the existing system or reforming
the
> >existing system if necessary.
> >2) You want to change the system. PERIOD. You think nothing short of that
> >will solve the problems whatever they are..
> >
> >The above is our basic difference of convictions. Just to note.
> >
> >Rajen
>
>


_______________________________________________
Assam mailing list
[email protected]
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Mailing list FAQ:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
To unsubscribe or change options:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam

_______________________________________________
Assam mailing list
[email protected]
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Mailing list FAQ:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
To unsubscribe or change options:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam

Reply via email to